Vacation rentals in San Carlos Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in San Carlos Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
Apartment in Fort Myers Beach
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Downtown 3rd Street Retreat Lookout—Steps to Beach

📍 LOCATION! LOCATION! LOCATION! 📍 ☀️ Beach, bayside, marina, boat tours/rentals, and dining all steps away—No car required! 🏠 Your ideal island getaway, offering a cozy 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom top-floor unit within the vibrant heart of downtown Fort Myers Beach. 🏝️ 3rd Street @ Old San Carlos Boulevard. Filled with restaurants, shops, and nightlife, only a short walk to the sandy shores! Perfect for families or small groups, this retreat ensures a comfortable, convenient vacation. Book today!

Top guest favorite
The screened-in pool area features a serene swimming pool with shimmering water, two blue lounge chairs positioned nearby, and views of a wide canal. A thatched-roof Tiki hut can be seen across the water, surrounded by lush greenery.
Home in Cape Coral
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 251 reviews

LUX Villa w/ Private Salt Water Pool, Lanai, Canal

Are you looking to swim, relax outdoors, fish and take in beautiful sunsets on a wide gulf access canal? If so you will fall in love with this stunning newly constructed custom built home! The 2750 square foot home is bright & airy with two main bedroom on-suites & a separate family wing! The gourmet kitchen, dining room & great room open via large sliders to the lanai & pool w/ views of the canal in much desired SW Cape! Beach inspired villa! Large captains walk & Tiki! Check out our reviews!

Top guest favorite
An outdoor space features a saltwater pool and a hot tub, both illuminated in soft blue tones under a twilight sky. A large tiki hut provides shaded seating, and lush tropical landscaping surrounds the area, creating a serene and private atmosphere.
Home in Fort Myers Beach
5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Salt Life-beautiful 2 bed/1 bath-pool-hot tub-tiki

This charming two-bedroom, one-bathroom home is perfect for families, offering comfortable beds and a relaxing atmosphere. Just under half a mile to the beach, Margaritaville, and great restaurants, it’s ideally located for both fun and convenience. Outside, enjoy a private oasis with a saltwater pool, hot tub, and a patio featuring a grilling area and dining space. The large tiki hut offers a lounge area with a smart TV. Located on a canal, it’s perfect for kayaking or fishing off the dock.

Guest favorite
Home in Cape Coral
5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Villa510~3 En-Suites~Gulf Access, Heated spa~pool

Villa510 is a newly built waterfront retreat ideal for extended stays in Cape Coral. Enjoy peaceful salt canal water views and manatees from the lanai, then relax in your private heated pool and spa—perfect year-round. The outdoor kitchen and lanai create an easy, comfortable daily routine. Inside offers three private en-suite bedrooms, a den with optional airbed, open living space, and TVs in every room. Close to shopping, dining, and beaches—perfect for snowbirds seeking comfort and ease.

Guest favorite
Home in Fort Myers Beach
5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Fort Myers Beach Sunset Nest

Sunset Nest | Pool, Walk to Beach & Times Square Bright, breezy, and ready for memory-making. This property offers a spacious, sunlit interior with a birds-eye view of the rebuilt, refreshed, thriving Fort Myers Beach neighborhood. Walking distance to the beach and Times Square allows for easy access to shops, dining, and waterfront strolls. The private pool area is just steps away from the main living space. Swim, soak, repeat as you unwind under Fort Myers Beach’s famous skies.

Top guest favorite
A modern kitchen features stainless steel appliances, including a refrigerator and oven. White cabinetry contrasts with a textured brown rug. Natural light flows through large windows, enhancing the bright atmosphere. Potted plants add a touch of greenery to the space.
Guest suite in Fort Myers Beach
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 300 reviews

Charming suite w/ private deck Downtown FMB

Discover the perfect blend of modern and tropical charm at our 1BR/1BA loft apartment in Downtown Fort Myers Beach. Just a 2-minute walk to the white sands, this upscale retreat is walking distance to the beach, Times Square, restaurants, bars, and shops. Enjoy water sports, kayaking, parks, and more. Ideal for couples, snowbirds, or anyone seeking a tropical escape, The Loft FMB combines modern comforts with island relaxation truly designed to feel like your home away from home.

Guest favorite
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

“Welcome to Relax and Unwind".

“Welcome to Relax and Unwind, your perfect waterfront getaway in beautiful Fort Myers Beach. This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath home at 70 Emily Lane offers everything you need for comfort and relaxation — a queen bed, twin beds, a cozy futon, and a fully equipped kitchen. Enjoy peaceful mornings by the water, take a kayak or bike ride. Just minutes from the beach and top attractions like Margaritaville Resort, the Key West Ferry, the vibrant marina, and local restaurants

Top guest favorite
An expansive open kitchen and dining area showcases sleek white cabinetry and a large kitchen island. Wooden barstools provide seating at the island, while contemporary lighting fixtures hang above. Large windows enhance the airy atmosphere, revealing a modern living space in the background.
Home in Fort Myers
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 96 reviews

Modern City Loft in Downtown River District

Welcome to Gun-Loft, a custom-designed modern sanctuary in the Downtown River District. This expansive 3500 square foot city loft is tailored for those seeking to embrace the cosmopolitan lifestyle, with the perfect blend of urban luxury and cultural richness. Whether it's a leisurely stroll to the Edison Ford Home, an exciting night out, or a culinary adventure in the restaurants nearby, Gun-Loft offers an unparalleled experience in the city's most coveted location.

Guest favorite
The exterior of Captain Jack’s Cottage is displayed, featuring a light-colored wooden structure with a spacious patio. Colorful adirondack chairs are arranged around the outdoor area, with a calming sunset in the background. A staircase leads to the upper level, enhancing accessibility.
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Cap't Jack's Waterfront Cottage

Escape to Captain Jack’s Cottage, a newly renovated canal-front retreat perfect for up to 4 guests. Just a 10-15 minute walk to the sandy beach, this charming home offers a tranquil vibe with modern amenities, a private patio, and stunning water views. Walk to local restaurants or hop on the nearby beach trolley. Whether relaxing or seeking adventure, Captain Jack’s Cottage is ideal for a memorable coastal getaway. Book now and unwind in paradise!

Top guest favorite
Home in Fort Myers Beach
5 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Icon on the bay - Panoramic views/Rooftop hot tub

Waterfront fun meets luxury in this 3-story Fort Myers Beach home on San Carlos Island! Featuring 4 bedrooms, bay-view living room with balcony, and a full kitchen & dining on the 2nd floor. Enjoy an outdoor kitchen with grill and bar, plus pool table, ping pong & air hockey. Private dock with boat lift and a rooftop deck with turf, lounge chairs & a 6-person hot tub for sunset soaking. Perfect for families, boaters & group getaways.

Guest favorite
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Across the beach, free parking, bbq, fits 4, pets

Stay just 600 ft from the beach and a 10-min walk to downtown Fort Myers Beach, with bars and restaurants like Mr. Waves Island Bar. This cozy bungalow sleeps 4 with 2 queen beds, a full kitchen, and a luxurious shower in the full bathroom. Enjoy the patio, grill-ready back porch, and a large garden perfect for outdoor games. We provide beach chairs, umbrella, cooler, and towels—everything you need for a perfect beach day.

Top guest favorite
An eat-in kitchen features sleek granite countertops and stainless steel appliances. A spacious island with seating for six invites casual dining, while modern cabinetry provides ample storage. The warm wood tones and travertine floor create a welcoming space, enhanced by bright overhead lighting.
Apartment in Fort Myers Beach
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Top rated 2 bedroom 2 bathroom. 1 block to beach!

Prepare to be impressed by this wonderful 2nd floor apartment located just 1 short block from the beach. It sleeps a total of 4 guests (two queen beds) and features a tastefully designed kitchen, granite counters, stainless appliances, updated vanities, 3 tvs & travertine floors. Wifi, bbq grill and a private balcony…pretty much everything you’ll need for a great beach vacation! 247+ very happy guests and counting!

Popular amenities for San Carlos Island vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Florida
  4. Lee County
  5. San Carlos Island