Vacation rentals in Pigeon Key

An outdoor space features a sparkling in-ground pool surrounded by a sun deck with several lounge chairs. A shaded screened-in porch is visible in the background, along with a gas grill and a cornhole game set nearby. Lush palm trees provide a tropical atmosphere.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Cancellation Deal: 08/02 thru 08/09

2025 - New concrete dock, fenders & fish filet table. This ground level waterfront home has received a new face lift. Completely remodeled 3 bedroom with bonus room in the well known Sombrero Beach neighborhood. Just a short block walk to the sandy beach shore. Home has an open floor plan overlooking the in-ground pool deck and new tiki hut. Enjoy your morning coffee and happy hour in the screened-in porch with views of the wide lagoon. Come and create your family memories in the fabulous Keys.

Tiny home in Big Pine Key

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Cheerful Tiny House in the Florida Keys

Enjoy your trip to the keys by staying at this wonderful tiny house, surrounded by nature and deers! This is a hidden gem in the keys for your relaxation, enjoyment. Cozy and roomy space for the whole family! The Tiny house is located in the small Breezy Pines RV Resort. It has everything you would need during your trip. Outdoor patio area with rattan sofa and armchairs, grill offer an additional comfort for incredible vacation! it has everything for your nice and comfy stay close to Key West!

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

A spacious outdoor Tiki Hut provides shaded seating with wicker furniture around a table. Sunning loungers are arranged nearby, facing the water. A ceiling fan circulates air above, while scenic views of the waterway and dock are visible in the background.

Home in Key Colony Beach

Captain’s Quarters Ahoy Mateys! Florida, Keys

This is located at the Florida Keys in Key Colony, Marathon. It is a spacious two bedroom, two bathroom duplex surrounded by water. It is a renovated beauty and close to the best restaurants and the tranquility of this city. It is the perfect getaway where you can recharge your exhausted batteries. Captain’s Quarters is a clean and spacious base camp location for the many adventures that await you in this amazing location. Water views and the accessibility to the best fishing in the world.

Guest suite in Key Colony Beach

A wooden dock extends over calm waters, flanked by posts leading to a serene view of the sky at sunset. Lush palm trees are visible in the background, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere of the canal.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Turtle-By-The-Sea: the Best Deal in KCB!

A perfect get-away for couples or budget travelers, Turtle-by-the-Sea is the best priced vacation rental or hotel room in the middle-keys. Together with its prime location and amenities there simply isn’t a better deal to be had! Bursting with Keys charm, this cozy retreat is the perfect place to relax & escape. Owners Mallory & Steve infused their love of the Keys & its surrounding ocean into every aspect of their waterside home. Shoot us a message & start planning your dream Keyscation!

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Luxury Paradise • Seagrass-Free. New 5BR Pool Home

Escape to this new stunning waterfront pool home. Enjoy panoramic ocean views, a private boat dock, with , fishing area, snorkeling, kayaks, paddle boards, bicycles and more.... The spacious, modern interior features a fully equipped kitchen, cozy bedrooms, and an open living area perfect for relaxation. Step outside to a beautiful patio or two balconies with seating to take in the views. Ideal for multiple couples, big families, or friends looking to explore the best of the Marathon key.

Condo in Key Colony Beach

A view from the balcony captures the serene beach setting with clear blue waters and palm trees swaying gently. A tiki hut is visible in the foreground, surrounded by well-maintained grass and pathways leading to the beach.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 207 reviews

Oceanfront Sunrise Condo Private Beach Heated Pool

Impeccable condo directly on the ocean with water views from every window. Located in Key Colony Beach (middle Keys) with heated pool and private beach. Unit #20 is a studio condo with a classic Keys interior: newly renovated bathroom and crisp white kitchen stocked with everything needed to cook a complete meal (stove, oven, toaster, microwave, blender, fridge, etc). Enjoy the private back balcony and private beach with lounge chairs, patio tables, tiki's and BBQ grills for guest use.

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 270 reviews

A modern houseboat is anchored on calm waters during sunset. The structure features large windows and a spacious front deck with a grill station. The warm glow of the setting sun illuminates the exterior, reflecting off the water, creating a serene atmosphere.

Boat in Marathon

Paradise awaits on this cozy houseboat!

Our vision is for you to kick back, relax, and find your home away from home! Wether you want to celebrate with your loved one or retreat by yourself this floating home offers comfortable space for 2 adults. Located near the 7 mile bridge in Marathon Florida on the Atlantic Ocean nestled in a quiet, reserved mangrove area. This spot is fantastic because you have unparalleled access to out of this world sunset/sunrise views. Kayak through the mangrove and explore the surrounding areas.

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Home in Key Largo

Newely Renovated 3/2-private pool/dock/cabana club

Relax with the whole Coastal Luxury in Key Colony Beach – Brand New Pool & Dock! Welcome to your dream getaway in Key Colony Beach, Florida! This completely renovated (2025) 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom duplex is designed for relaxation and adventure. With 1,100 sq. ft. of beautifully upgraded living space, a brand-new private concrete pool, and dockage for up to a 35- foot boat, this home is the perfect blend of luxury and comfort. Private Pool – Heated & chilled - Free Cabana Club Access!

Cottage in Little Torch Key

A long wooden dock extends into clear blue water, flanked by palm trees and lush greenery. Two turquoise chairs are positioned at the dock’s end, providing an ideal spot for relaxation and enjoying scenic water views under a bright sky dotted with clouds.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 167 reviews

Waterfront Cozy Cottage with Boat Ramp & Dock!

Welcome to Paradise! Stay in the amazing Keys and beautiful waterfront home with 250 foot dock, ramp, and basin for your boat. It's a must-see rustic outdoor environment and fishery experience, very typical in the Keys! The property lot is almost an acre with a work section and still very spacious. Stunning panoramic water views, sunrise and sunset. Steps away from ocean water. Bring or rent fishing and snorkel gear nearby to fish right off the dock and enjoy the underwater scenery!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Home in Key Colony Beach

Waterfront Home 37.5-ft dock, Cabana Club Included

Bright, Open Floor Plan with new floors & kitchen. East facing for sunny mornings and shady afternoons on the great screened porch. Two roomy bedrooms and 2 full baths. Plenty of parking on the paved driveway. Perfectly located with the boater and angler in mind on a 37. 5 ft concrete dock, on deep & wide canal. Here on Key Colony Beach you can walk or bike the entire city to the marina, Sunset Park, 3 restaurants, play golf, tennis, pickle ball, bocce ball, horseshoes & basketball.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 320 reviews

Three colorful Adirondack chairs, yellow, turquoise, and green, are positioned on a sandy beach facing a calm blue ocean. A rocky shore and sparse greenery surround the seating area, while fluffy white clouds drift in a bright sky, enhancing the serene water view.

Villa in Marathon

New Aqua Lodge 2Beds 1 Bath with Full Kitchens

This hip spot is the new thing in lodging. Aqua Lodge is all the modern amenities while being on the water. Full kitchens, flat screen tv's, wi-fi , pool, bikes, sunset beach. We have it all right at your finger tips. You can sleep up to 5 people comfortably. We have great air conditioning and big showers. The deck is furnished with a dining table for those romantic outdoor dinners in the moonlight. We also have a sunset beach area for the best sunsets in the Florida keys!

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

The houseboat is illuminated with green lighting at night, creating a striking reflection in the water. The exterior features a porch with white railings, while the name 'Hokey Couch' is displayed above the entrance. The surrounding area is calm and dark, enhancing the serene ambiance.

Houseboat in Marathon

Houseboat Getaway In Marathon

Get ready to indulge in a relaxing and unforgettable experience at the first overwater houseboat getaway in Marathon, Florida! 🌴🌊 What awaits you is - fun filled days living and exploring out on the fabulous florida keys waters in your own private aqualodge, breathtaking sunsets, and a private sanctuary perched above the sea. 😍 Don't miss out on this one-of-a-kind experience! Book your stay now and create memories that will last a lifetime.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Pigeon Key vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Pigeon Key

A modern kitchen features sleek white cabinetry and marble backsplash. Stainless steel appliances are complemented by wooden accents. Open shelves showcase decorative items, while a large window offers a scenic view of the outdoor area. The spacious island holds a decorative tray with a plant and seashell.

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Luxury 5Bdrm/6bath New in 2024

CatherineRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Timothy’s house was spacious, comfortable, and clean. The pool was a great way to beat the Florida Keys heat and the sunset views from the 3rd floor were awesome! Boaters will love the boat ramp next door. The fish cleaning table and outdoor freezer were a huge plus.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

A serene beach scene features soft, sandy shores lined with palm trees. Gentle waves lap against the coast, while a wooden pier extends into the calm waters. Clear blue skies and fluffy clouds enhance the tranquil atmosphere.

Home in Key Colony Beach

ABeachBungalow-60’dock w/ access to pool and beach

DesireeRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We enjoyed our stay and felt very at home. I had a few questions when settling in and I got responses very quickly. The house was tidy, the location was perfect and the kayaks were fun (be careful getting in the water as the rocks are very slippery). The owners recommended babyquip which was very helpful in providing toys, a crib and a high chair for my little ones.

A serene waterfront scene captures a vibrant sunset reflected on calm waters. A palm tree stands beside a dock lined with boats, while a charming blue house is visible in the background, creating a tranquil ambiance in a coastal setting.

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Dock Pool Ramp Jacuzzi Ocean Views Kayaks

WillRating, 5 stars1 month ago

This stay was the perfect vacation I was looking forward to, I stayed 7 days at this water front property with a great balcony to enjoy evenings and a boat ramp to launch the boats in the back yard along with the pool to keep us cool. Plenty of room for our trucks and trailers, the inside of the home was comfortable and relaxing. Was truly a great vacation Thank you

A spacious oceanfront estate is surrounded by tropical landscaping, featuring flowering bushes and palm trees. The house, painted in light colors, is elevated above a gravel path leading to the beach. Kayaks can be seen in the water, complementing the serene coastal view.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Million Dollar View

JohnRating, 5 stars1 month ago

This home was everything we expected and more. Stunning location with absolute privacy. The extra long dock was amazing, the pool was fantastic, and the grounds were meticulous. It’s literally your own private resort. Roman, the host, was very quick with communication. He and his wife actually met us when we checked in to see if we had any questions and provided us with an arrival gift. If you have looked at the listing and are thinking of renting it, do it. You will not be disappointed at all. Excellent value all around.

A spacious entertainment area is highlighted by a classic Olhausen pool table with a blue felt surface. Natural light fills the room through large windows, illuminating the wood flooring. A staircase leads to the upper level, complemented by decorative elements including a marlin on the wall.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Beautiful Beachfront Villa w/ Pool/Tiki/Dock

RobinRating, 5 stars1 week ago

This home is even more than the pictures show! It is an extraordinary home for people who love the sun, shade, beach, and the beautiful home just makes it a luxurious vacation. I could not find one aspect I didn’t love.❤️

A private pier extends over calm water, featuring a wooden bench and a small table set on a sturdy deck. The surrounding posts rise from the water, under a clear blue sky, creating an inviting space for relaxation and enjoyment of the coastal views.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

Beach House, Private Pool & Dock, Gulf Sunset view

DanielRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

Our 7 day stay was the most relaxing vacation we’ve had in years. The location was somewhat remote but only a short drive into Marathon. We hope to come back soon!!!

5 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Spacious lux home, private pool/spa, 80' dock

HeatherRating, 5 stars1 month ago

The house was exactly how it was described online. Everything was well marked. Lots of stuff to do at the home. Very spacious and well maintained. There were only 7 of us, so lots of extra space. The pool is on the perfect side so your not blasted with the late afternoon sun. However, there is a huge umbrella in case it is needed. Kitchen is fully stocked so nothing was needed. There is a BBQ grill as well as a flat top which is nice for outside cooking. The only thing I would recommend is to bring your own pillow if your a particular pillow person (we love our feather pillows), house pillows were not feather ones. If you rent here and have a boat definitely go to the Sombrero Lighthouse to snorkel. Never saw so many fish in one place. The Conch Cafe and Coast to Coast pizza are both great food restaurants and walkable from the home. Publix is so close it was a daily visit. Truly enjoyed the week stay!!!!!

A sandy beachfront is framed by palm trees, with the glistening Atlantic ocean in the background. A volleyball net is set up on the sand, along with multiple seating areas for relaxation, inviting guests to enjoy the tranquil environment and scenic views.