Island vacation rentals in New York

Find and book unique island rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated island rentals in New York

Guests agree: these island rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Superhost

The living area features a wood-paneled ceiling and walls, complemented by large windows allowing natural light. A cast iron gas fireplace stands against one wall, and a wooden coffee table sits in front of a spacious sofa. A small desk and two chairs are positioned beside the fireplace.

Cabin in Paul Smiths

Mrs. Otis's Cabin with Woodland View

In the tradition of the Adirondack Great Camps - magnificent rustic compounds of comfort built a century ago by the rich and powerful on wilderness estates. White Pine Camp offers a year round restful retreat in unparalleled natural surroundings. Here, in the heart of the Adirondacks the largest protected wilderness in the continental United States, guests receive the key to peace and tranquility, a place to recharge the spirit. As a guest, you have your choice of 13 distinctive cabins

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Top guest favorite

The interior of the glamping tent showcases a spacious layout with various cozy rugs. A comfortable queen bed is complemented by warm lighting and unique furnishings, including a small dining table and a sofa, enhancing a relaxed atmosphere.

Yurt in Greig

Island Glamping w/ Boat, HotTub and Pet Friendly

Ultimate waterfront glamping on Grant Island, Brantingham Lake, featured on ABC & BuzzFeed. Why guests love it: • Dedicated electric jon boat • Private waterfront deck, dock + BBQ • Queen bed + fold-out bed • Dog-friendly • Hot tub access • Seasonal natural lake cold plunge • Private convenience toilet • Full bathroom + shower access • Wi-Fi + 50-inch Roku TV • Canoe + pedal boat access included • 20% off Jet Ski, ATV & boat rentals • Beach, diving board + fire pit • 420-friendly outdoors

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Superhost

A quaint cabin surrounded by tall trees features outdoor seating composed of two wooden chairs. Hanging pots and tools adorn the cabin's exterior, complementing the natural setting. Sunlight filters through the foliage, creating a serene atmosphere in this forested area.

Bungalow in Greig

The Stabbin Cabin Grant Island w/Boat, HotTub, Pet

The Stabbin Cabin is a unique private bungalow for two on Grant Island, Brantingham Lake, featured on ABC & BuzzFeed. Here’s why: • Experience island life • Dog-friendly • Steamy hot tub • 2 electric boats for exploring and transportation • Great fishing • Beach, diving board, floats and toys • Bathroom and shower just 4 feet away • 20% off Jet Ski, pontoon and ATV rentals • Private BBQ, hammock and seating • Fast Wi-Fi • Roku with streaming apps • 420-friendly outdoors

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Superhost

A rustic cottage is set among tall pine trees, surrounded by lush greenery. A sandy pathway leads to the entrance, where a small outdoor seating area is visible. The structure features large windows that offer natural light to the interior.

Home in Greig

Island Waterfront w/Pontoon boat, HotTub, Dogs Lv!

Escape to Grant Island Main Cottage, a boat-in private-island stay for up to 8 on Brantingham Lake. Why guests love it: • Private pontoon boat included • Private hot tub • Private dock, fire pit + swimming area • Dog-friendly • Full kitchen • 4 bedrooms • Canoe, pedal boat + 2 kayaks included • Seasonal natural lake cold plunge • Fast Wi-Fi + Roku streaming apps • 20% off Jet Ski, ATV & boat rentals • Adirondack lake views, fishing + stargazing • 420-friendly outdoors

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Guest favorite

Island in Saranac Lake

Stay on your own island. Awe Inspiring!

This memorable place is anything but ordinary. Stay on your own island with many of the comforts of home. Magnificent water and mountain views - sunrises AND sunsets. Nature abounds - including eagles and loons. Canoe, kayak (25+miles of contiguous waterway) , water sports, nearby hiking. Outdoor patios and decks. Water-taxi services ($70 round trip), shopping, and meals services available (ask for a menu) 12-minute boat ride to Saranac Lake. Close to Lake Placid.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Top guest favorite

A cozy interior features a spacious bed with a textured blanket, surrounded by framed artwork and plants. A wooden dining table is positioned nearby. Large glass doors allow natural light to fill the space, providing views of the surrounding greenery.

Tiny home in Brantingham

Stabbin Cabin #2 on Grant Island-HotTub,Boat,Pets

The Stabbin Cabin #2 was created with couples in mind and featured on ABC. Here’s why guests love it: • Boat-in island experience • Dog-friendly • Electric boat access • Great fishing • Hot tub access • Seasonal natural lake cold plunge • Lake-view projector + Guitar Hero • Private balcony + BBQ • Bathroom + shower about 50 ft away • Fast Wi-Fi • 420-friendly outdoors • 20% off adventure rentals • Beach, diving board, fire pit + lake toys • Memories for a lifetime

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 95 reviews

A private cottage is surrounded by a lush green lawn and tall trees. The front porch features a railing and is adorned with two chairs. Large windows reflect natural light, while an American flag hangs nearby, adding an inviting touch to the outdoor space.

Guest suite in Redwood

Outback Cottage Located on Island-Goose Bay!

Boaters, fish enthusiasts, & adventurers are all welcomed here at the Wintergreen Isle cottages! Enjoy a beautiful and relaxing scenery with this 2 bedroom & 1 bath private cottage w/ porch, BBQ grill, fire pit, & outdoor activities. Kitchen and kitchenware is available for your use. Must have a boat if you plan to rent as you will need to use it to cross from the mainland to your private getaway (dock space & parking included)!

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Guest favorite

Two wooden Adirondack chairs are positioned near the water's edge, offering a view of the St. Lawrence River. A large freighter is visible in the background, surrounded by lush greenery and distant homes along the shore.

Cottage in Fishers Landing

Private Island & Pet Friendly ~ The Sea Angell

The Sea Angell is a 1.2 acre PRIVATE ISLAND (just you will be on it). There is DEEP water docking, electricity, modern plumbing, WiFi, and great cell service. And, yes … this property is dog friendly! The island is very easy to find, located just offshore in a prime location near Foxy’s Restaurant, and has a charming vintage cottage dating back to the 1870’s!

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Top guest favorite

A charming waterfront home features a spacious deck with white railings, surrounded by lush greenery. The two-story structure has gabled roofs and a mix of stone and siding on the exterior. Direct access to the water is visible, enhancing its tranquil setting.

Home in Riverhead

Bayside Bliss - 2bdrm Lower-level Apartment

Escape to the serene beauty of Long Island's East End with our charming 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom waterfront apartment, nestled perfectly between the North and South Forks. This idyllic retreat offers guests a unique opportunity to experience the best of both worlds – the tranquil beauty of Reeves Bay and the vibrant culture of the Hamptons.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

A bright living room features large windows offering panoramic views of the Long Island Sound. Comfortable seating is arranged around a rustic wooden coffee table, which holds a bowl of red apples. Natural wood walls enhance the room's welcoming ambiance.

Home in Southold

The Shorecrest Beach House

Located on a bluff overlooking the Long Island Sound with it's own beach, stunning sunsets and panoramic water views, this newly renovated, spacious house offers a tranquil getaway in bucolic Southold on the North Fork of Long Island's Wine and Farming Country.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

A spacious outdoor area is highlighted by a refreshing pool surrounded by lounge chairs. The pool house, featuring a white exterior, sits in the background amidst lush greenery. Flower pots and garden plants frame the scene, enhancing the tranquil environment.

Guesthouse in Shelter Island

Sleek and Chic cottage/Pool House

Unwind from the city craziness in our pool house cottage, take advantage of the nature around you being surrunded with beutiful specimen and fruit trees.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews