Vacation rentals in New Lyme

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Lyme

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
An aerial view of a lush, green landscape reveals a tiny home nestled among dense trees, with a serene lake visible in the distance. The surrounding area showcases a mixture of forested land and open fields, underscoring the property’s secluded and natural setting.
Tiny home in Andover
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Exclusively Pymatuning Tiny Home w hot tub

This 110 acre lake side tiny home Estate will reconnect you to nature while you relax in the hot tub. The neighboring state park has over 14,000 acres with a lake and trails. This tiny home is where nature meets luxury!! The electric fireplace will welcome you while resting and watching your favorite show. There is a fire pitt and charcoal grill as well as full size kitchen appliances. Owner lives on the property, but no shared facilities. This house has star link internet but not guaranteed.

Guest favorite
The image captures a lush, green pasture with several horses grazing peacefully. A wooden fence encloses the pasture, providing a tranquil rural setting, with trees dotting the landscape in the background. The sky is overcast, giving a calm ambiance to the scene.
Farm stay in Chardon
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 374 reviews

Bonnie's Guesthouse @ Peridot Equine Sanctuary

***ALL PROFITS SUPPORT THE HORSES OF PERIDOT EQUINE SANCTUARY*** The rustic decor and well lit space reflects the nature of our horse farm, where you can stay for a peaceful country getaway and bring your horses along! We're rural, but you'll still have easy access to lots of amenities in the wonderful nearby town of Chardon, less than 10 minutes away. Cleveland itself, currently going through a "rustbelt renaissance" is only about 45 minutes minutes West. We welcome guests of all backgrounds!

Guest favorite
The living room features comfortable seating, including a gray sofa, an armchair, and a coffee table on a patterned rug. Natural light illuminates the space through large windows, and decorative artwork adorns the walls, creating a cozy atmosphere.
Home in Geneva
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Sand V-Ball Ct w/ Vineyard Views SPIRE 5 Min

Enjoy a relaxing stay in this fully renovated 1860's 3BR/3 Full BT home. Featuring a spacious, fully stocked kitchen, outdoor gathering spaces, including fire pit, and sand volleyball court with vineyard views. The Grand Getaway is perfect for romantic getaways, girls weekends, bachelor/bachelorette parties, family vacations and more! Centrally located in the heart of The Grand River Valley within minutes from all local wineries and a short drive to GOTL. The perfect space for creating memories!

Guest favorite
A two-story farmhouse is visible in the background, surrounded by open grass and bare trees. In the foreground, a welcoming sign for Hockran Family Farms displays the name and address, set against a cloudy sky.
Home in Andover
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews

Hockran Family Farms Guesthouse

Fabulous Farm House - built in the 1940's this farmhouse is a family treasure. Fully renovated and modernized this home is a great place to relax and find some peace in a great small town with an abundance of local activities. This home is a great place for those seeking spiritual renewal or some quiet family time away, including all you nature lovers to the Pymatuning Lake State Park both in Ohio and Pennsylvania. This home is fully staffed by a great caretaker and local owner. Come Enjoy!

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Middlefield
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

The Wildflower

Come enjoy this brand new cabin in a private wooded setting. Sit on the front porch swing or relax by the fireplace. Enjoy the whirlpool for two and new stylish decor with black metal railing against a backdrop of the finest craftsmenship of woodworking. This cabin was built by local Amish and Mennonite builders. There is a double reclining loveseat and a queen size pull out sofa with a memory foam mattress. We provide snacks, sodas, coffee, tea, cereal, juice, pancaKe mix & maple syrup!

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a modern ranch house is showcased, featuring a vibrant red façade and a metal roof. A spacious deck is visible, complete with outdoor seating and a view of the nearby creek and surrounding trees. A gravel driveway leads to the entrance.
Home in Garrettsville
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 524 reviews

“Willow Ledge at Silver Creek”with Private Hot Tub

New Construction Modern Ranch House features rustic upscale design with beautiful cozy interiors and comfort at every turn. Stunning views await with floor to ceiling windows overlooking beautiful Silver Creek and surrounding nature. Private deck is spacious and inviting with oversize hot tub, concrete fire pit, gas grill, and outdoor dining furniture. A few minutes from great restaurants, the Brewery at Garrett’s Mill, and the coolest Coffee Shop. Perfect weekend getaway or business stay.

Top guest favorite
The sun sets over the calm waters of Lake Erie, casting a golden reflection across the surface. Soft clouds scatter in the sky, complementing the tranquil atmosphere of the lakefront. A rocky shoreline is visible in the foreground, enhancing the natural beauty.
Cottage in Conneaut
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Water’s Edge Lake House with Fabulous Views!

Enjoy lakefront sunsets in a beautiful ranch home on the shores of Lake Erie. Lakefront home minutes away from golfing and Lake Shore Park providing boat docking, fishing, beach access for swimming, picnic areas. Close to Grand River wineries, Geneva-on- the- lake, shopping, restaurants, covered bridges, public parks. Entire home has recently been updated including the kitchen and bathrooms with added game room with futon and TV. Plenty of outdoor space to enjoy games and attached deck.

Guest favorite
A cozy living space features rustic wood paneling and two comfortable wooden rockers positioned beside a small table. A sectional sofa provides ample seating, while a soft rug lies on the polished hardwood floor. Natural light filters through the window adorned with blinds.
Apartment in Madison
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 260 reviews

Cozy winery getaway with hot tub!

Relax in this cozy country garage apt. in Grand River Valley. The first stop on your winery tour is just 4 minutes away with over 30 more to explore. Visit nearby Lake Erie, Thompson Ledges, Geauga Park District Observatory, or a covered bridge. Kitchenette w/ mini fridge, microwave, Keurig & sink. Quaint bath w/ stand up shower Private keycode entry Electric fireplace King size bed Rustic wood rockers & table Pet friendly Shared access to hot tub, back yard fire pit & patio

Top guest favorite
A rustic living area is featured with wood-paneled walls and a high, beamed ceiling. A patterned sofa and a recliner are positioned around a decorative area rug. A small electric fireplace adds warmth, while a TV hangs above the central seating. The room is adorned with a Christmas tree.
Cabin in Cortland
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 470 reviews

Cozy Countryside Cabin Near Multiple Wineries

Our cozy and inviting cabin, the Eagle's Nest, is nestled in a countryside setting behind Greene Eagle Winery and Brew Pub in rural Northeast Ohio. If you are looking for charm, and quiet relaxing comfort, this 384 sq. ft. cabin with exposed cedar beams is your perfect overnight or weekend retreat. Many activities available in the area with Mosquito lake nearby, bike trails, state park, golf, shopping, wineries, breweries, and restaurants within 10 to 30 minutes.

Top guest favorite
A custom-built cabin is nestled among tall trees, featuring a welcoming front deck with a wooden railing. The natural surroundings are complemented by fallen leaves, and the cabin showcases a rustic log exterior, providing a sense of tranquility in the woods.
Cabin in Ashtabula
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Riverview Country Cabin

Take it easy at this unique, tranquil getaway nestled atop a scenic ridge of the Ashtabula River. Get away from it all and enjoy your morning coffee inside the cozy cabin with views that stretch up and down and across the river. Or bask in the beauty of nature outside on the custom-made porch swing. Keep an eye out for the local bald eagles as they soar above the river daily, right outside your door! This custom built cabin is the perfect quiet getaway!

Top guest favorite
A still lake reflects the surrounding greenery, creating a serene view. Tall trees frame the scene, and the calm waters are lightly disturbed by ripples. The bright blue sky overhead provides a peaceful backdrop, enhancing the natural beauty of the secluded area.
Cabin in Rome
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Quiet Cabin In The Woods

Secluded lakefront fishing cabin on 30 acres offers the very definition of a quiet oasis in the woods. This home lays at the end of a mile long private drive on over 11 acres of manicured lawn surrounded by 300 year old oak trees. The lake, only feet from your front door, contains bass, bluegill, perch and catfish offering both adults and children alike a wonderful opportunity to cast a line and relax while blue heron and eagles nest in the nearby trees.

Guest favorite
The A-Frame cabin stands among towering trees, showcasing its distinct triangular shape and large front deck. Surrounded by lush greenery, the wooden façade and black accents blend harmoniously with the natural environment, creating a sense of privacy and seclusion.
Cabin in West Farmington
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 758 reviews

The Triangle: Unplug in a Charming A-Frame

Step inside The Triangle and the outside world melts away. A wood-burning stove, exposed beams, and countless small details make this 400 sq. ft. A-Frame feel immediately like home. Brand new deck (2024) perfect for morning coffee or evening stars. Nestled in Ohio's Amish Country — minutes from The Place at 534, Nelson-Kennedy Ledges, Observatory Park's dark skies, Holden Arboretum, and Burton Village.

Popular amenities for New Lyme vacation rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Ohio
  4. Ashtabula County
  5. New Lyme