Vacation rentals in New Holstein

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Holstein

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A spacious bedroom features a central bed with a gray quilt, flanked by two dark wood nightstands. Large windows allow natural light to fill the room, complemented by light-colored curtains. A patterned area rug spreads across the hardwood floor, enhancing the space.

Apartment in Kiel

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Loft Unit Historic Kiel 8 miles to Road America

Less than a 10 minute drive to Elkhart Lake/ Road America 25-30 minute drive to Kohler, Sheboygan, etc. and less than 1 hour to Milwaukee & Green Bay. Perfect location to stay in the heart of downtown Kiel. Located upstairs in a beautifully restored historic building located on the main street in town. Relax and enjoy your stay with all of the amenities of home which include all new appliances as well as you will be able to walk to local dinning and nightlife attractions that Kiel has to offer.

Top guest favorite

The A-frame cabin is framed by lush greenery and colorful landscaping. A welcoming pathway leads to the entrance, featuring a spacious deck. The cabin's dark exterior contrasts with the surrounding trees, creating a serene and private atmosphere.

Cabin in Elkhart Lake

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 285 reviews

Elkhart A-Frame, Wooded Retreat near Road America

The Elkhart A-Frame is an ideal location for the adventure seeker who wants a unique and private experience that is still close to all the action. The home sits on a wooded three-acre private retreat only about a mile from the village of Elkhart Lake, Road America, and Golf Courses. This unique cabin was built in the 1970's but has been recently renovated with a fun Scandinavian modern flair. It has all the amenities for a memorable vacation stay that provides plenty of epic photo opportunities.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the property is framed by lush greenery and colorful flowering plants. A rustic wooden fence runs along the foreground, while the house is partially obscured by trees, creating a serene and inviting environment.

Home in Kiel

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Kiel River House

Located on the Kiel river, 1 hr from Lambeau, 1 hr from Milwaukee, 20 mins from Kohler, 15 mins from Elkhart Lake/ Road America, and 50 mins from EAA. It's a 5 min walk to Roeck's Bakery, run by the same family since 1908. The following businesses are around 5 mins walking distance ,Christel's Pet Store, Dairy Queen, Badger's Den, Bob Schoenborn's Jewelry, and Bird's Nest Home Decor. Fork & Dagger Ale Haus and Lumber yard Brewery are less than a 5 min drive along with 6 more restaurants

Top guest favorite

The two-story home features a beige exterior with multiple windows, surrounded by a grassy yard. Two chairs are positioned in front on a small patio area. Large trees provide shade, while a view of the countryside and other structures is visible in the background.

Home in Glenbeulah

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Stay at Sunrise LLC, Like being at Grandma's

Welcome to Stay at Sunrise LLC. We offer a clean and comfortable home for your vacation enjoyment. We are in a rural area, recreation trail head is 3 miles east of us as is the Wade House, 7 miles from Road America. Large yard, Fire pit, picnic table, child swing set. Garage parking on site if arranged in advance. We do not have WIFI Phone reception for Internet is good. No Cable or Satellite TV, Over 32 antenna channels. Smoking is allowed outside of the home. No pets allowed.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the historic building is characterized by its stone façade and archways, featuring large windows that let in natural light. The entrance is framed by a bold arch, leading into the interior spaces.

Home in Kiel

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Luxury Historic Rental Road America, Kohler golf

One of a Kind Rental in an 1890's Historic State Bank conveniently located within a few miles to Elk Hart Lake and Road America! Spacious at 2000 square feet with three bedrooms (6 beds mostly sleep number) two bathrooms and fantastic showers (one in the second vault). Fantastic amenities such as a pool table, foosball table, poker table, token slot machine and a wide array of automotive memorabilia and art. The perfect place to stay for automotive & golf enthusiasts with ample private parking.

Superhost

A simple entrance is highlighted by a white door adorned with a small window, framed by green siding. A festive decoration, resembling a snowman, composed of evergreen branches and a golden hat, is positioned beside the door, adding a cheerful touch.

Apartment in Plymouth

4.64 out of 5 average rating, 319 reviews

Pineyard Plymouth Apartment

Enjoy this older upper floor apt. with two single bedrooms with a twin bed in one and a full bed in the other, full bath, kitchen, living room, and off street parking. VCR/DVD player and internet is available. Kitchen is equipped with dishes, pots, pans, stove, and refrigerator. We are five minutes from Road America, fifteen minutes from Sheboygan, and thirty minutes from Fond du Lac. Only three blocks from downtown Plymouth enjoy many shops and eating establishments. Pets are NOT allowed.

Superhost

An aerial view captures the layout of the property, showcasing a cluster of buildings surrounded by lush greenery and a small pond. Farm fields extend in all directions, while trees add a touch of vibrant color to the landscape.

Barn in Sheboygan Falls

4.7 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Quiet Country Charm

Cozy barn loft with rustic charm. This newly renovated private loft sleeps 4 with the possibility of 1 or 2 more if you don’t mind sleeping on an air mattress. This room includes a bathroom with shower and small efficiency kitchen with microwave, coffee maker, and small refrigerator. The futon pulls out to a double bed. This relaxing local comes complete with barnyard animals for an authentic Wisconsin experience! You won’t forget the peaceful surroundings of this rustic destination.

Top guest favorite

An aerial view of a modern cabin showcases a spacious patio area with outdoor seating and a hot tub. Lush greenery surrounds the property, with a gravel driveway leading to the entrance. The cabin features large windows that allow for ample natural light.

Cabin in Cascade

5 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

hot tub and sauna on 5 private acres

Need a peaceful retreat? Experience 5 acres of tranquil, private woodland paradise. Cool nights are perfect for warming up in the hot tub or infrared sauna which overlook the meadow. Explore hiking trails and lakes that the scenic Kettle Moraine has to offer. Grill a delicious meal and later craft perfect s’mores by campfire as the crickets sing. Unwind at SoLu winery, just a minute down the road. Near Road America, Kettle Moraine State Forest, and Dundee. Your inspired getaway awaits!

Top guest favorite

A comfortable seating area is presented with two sofas featuring soft neutral tones and decorative pillows. A wooden coffee table holds magazines, while a light rug enhances the warm atmosphere. A queen-sized bed is visible in the background, with natural light filtering through a nearby window.

Apartment in New Holstein

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Parkside Retreat | Minutes from Elkhart Lake

Parkside Retreat is located in the quaint city of New Holstein, right on the city’s largest park. The Aquatic Center, basketball/tennis courts, ball diamonds, fishing pond, and walking paths are located just steps outside. Just 10 miles away from Elkhart Lake and Road America we are close to everything yet tucked away from the crowds. Enjoy all that this beautiful area has to offer, then settle in for a relaxing evening at Parkside Retreat. PET FRIENDLY - 1 pet limit

Guest favorite

A cozy bedroom features a large window with sheer curtains that allow natural light to filter in. Views of Lake Michigan are framed by the window, creating a serene atmosphere. A spacious bed rests near the window, with soft bedding and a table beside it.

Home in Two Rivers

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 135 reviews

The Smiling Bear Cabin | lake views, large yard!

Charming cabin just across the street from Lake Michigan, with stunning views from nearly every room. Centrally located between Two Rivers and Manitowoc, with easy access to scenic trails, kayaking, and fishing. Lots of family-friendly events happening around us all summer long. Perfect base for day trips to Door County, Green Bay, and Sheboygan. A relaxing retreat with nature, adventure, and convenience at your doorstep. Feel free to reach out with any questions! <3

Top guest favorite

A relaxing living area features a stone fireplace as its focal point. Comfortable seating options, including a leather chair and a spacious sofa, are arranged around a rustic coffee table. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, with glimpses of the surrounding scenery.

Cottage in Fond du Lac

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 287 reviews

Beautiful Lake Home.

Our Beautiful two bedroom cottage is located on the shores of Lake Winnebago . Centrally located to many of Wisconsin's best attractions. Less than 1 hour from Milwaukee, Madison, Green Bay, Close to Oshkosh (EAA) and Elkhart Lake. Includes 2 bedrooms, with plush queen beds, 1 full bathroom, Laundry room with washer and dryer. The perfect home for a laid back group of friends, couples or a family to stay with all the comforts of being at home.

Top guest favorite

The sign for Red Willow Guest House is prominently displayed, featuring bold red letters against a white background. The surrounding landscape includes green grass and trees, with a hint of a barn visible in the background, creating a rural setting.

Home in Kiel

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 194 reviews

Red Willow Guest House

Renovated farmhouse located just 48 miles south of Lambeau Field and 50 miles north of Milwaukee. This guesthouse is the perfect vacation home for large family/group gatherings. The property is a retired dairy farm with acres of trees and grasslands to explore. The farmhouse is three miles east of Kiel, nine miles from Elkhart Lake, home of Road America race track and 18 miles to Blackwolf Run golf course in Kohler.