Vacation rentals with a fireplace in New Castle

Spacious home on lovely property. It had everything we needed for our stay.

Our second time here. Great spot for our family of 4, and Sandy is very responsive

We had a wonderful stay. The home is beautiful, and the hosts were very thoughtful. The crib we requested for our 1-year-old was already set up when we arrived, complete with a soft blanket and pillow. There was plenty of firewood for cozy fires in both indoor fireplaces, and our kids loved making s’mores outside. Ninka was warm, responsive, and helpful throughout our stay.

Elizabeth’s place was great and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay! It had everything we needed to be comfy with our toddler and dog, and the neighborhood had all we needed as well (close to the train station, great coffee at Bobo’s and Lange’s deli for breakfast and lunch). Elizabeth made sure we got in okay and was very responsive. Thanks!

Thanks. Quick comfy stay.

Obsessed with this Airbnb! My husband, dog and I typically go to upstate NY or the Berkshires for long weekends but I came across this Airbnb as I had an event in westchester over the long weekend. Highly recommend! So much hiking, wonderful restaurants and so close to the city. My dog loved this property as well! Will be back.

We were looking to stay somewhere peaceful and relaxing to celebrate a graduation, and this property hit every mark. In a weird way, the photos dont do it justice with how nice the property is and how comfortable it was to stay in. The host was also very responsive and reasonable with our check in / check out. 10/10 will try to come back one day!

Edina and Glen's house was beautiful, spacious, and pristine. It was the perfect setting for a "girls weekend". The grounds were stunning, and made for a great setting. Very close to town, shopping, and wonderful restaurants. We really appreciated that our hosts were very proactive in reaching out and making all instructions clear. They were communicative and flexible. Thank you for having us in your beautiful home! Very memorable weekend.

Amazing spot! Peaceful and perfect for a get away

We had a wonderful stay! The place was spotless and incredibly well-prepared. The host went above and beyond—there was a bottle of wine and a charcuterie board waiting for us when we arrived, which was such a thoughtful touch. She truly thought of everything we might need, from toiletries to kitchen essentials, including a variety of snacks/breakfast items, coffee and teas. It made our stay comfortable, relaxing and stress-free. Highly recommend and would definitely stay again!

My partner and I enjoyed a pleasant stay in New Jersey while attending the Cowboy Carter concert at MetLife Stadium. The home is conveniently located just a short drive from MetLife Stadium, the American Dream Mall, and NJ Transit, which provides easy access to New York City.

Great place close to everything in downtown and an easy drive to surrounding areas. Simple amenities that more than do the trick.

We’ve stayed at a few of Grahams places over the years and they are always wonderful! Clean and exactly as described! We always enjoy ourselves!

I look forward to stay Lismary place on my next trip. Great location, very clean and well decorated. I feel like I am at home.

Melissa was an amazing host from the minute we booked the reservation. Her home was beautiful and provided a sense of peace. The binder with local activities as well as restaurants was extremely helpful and although it rained our whole weekend we didn't mind because the hot tub area was so nice. Will definitely be back again!

Urbys apartment was exactly like the pictures shown. Walkable distance to Path station and good restaurants, located in a quiet and safe neighborhood. The apartment was clean, well kept with ample supplies of bed and bath linens. We couldnt have asked for more!

This was a lovely getaway, went up for Memorial Day Weekend and getting some nature in at Minnewaska state park, it was rainy this weekend so we ended up having more time at the house then planned but we were so cozy it was a delight, we had some empty tanks for the grill when we arrived but the hosts offered to reimburse us for the refuel which was very kind, also had a friend who left their jacket and keys and Kyle and Jasmine have been wonderful in helping them get it back! A great cozy stay, the ride up was scenic

We enjoyed our stay here and it was comfortable for us to sleep 4 people. The bedrooms were nice and bathroom recently updated. We experienced some loud noise from the above neighbors on a Sunday morning but other than that it was quite. There is a nice washer and dryer with detergent that we used too. It was also nice to be close to Pershing field park and not far to get on the PATH train into NYC.

Everything was absolutely amazing. We felt at home the entire stay and had everything we needed. Carl was really easy to work with. I mistakenly booked the trip a day shorter than needed. At the last minute I realized my mistake and Carl was quick to respond that adding an extra day was no problem. The system had a problem though allowing me to book an overnight stay on the same day I “checked out,” but Carl worked back and forth with me and with AirBnb help until I was finally able to book that extra night. Carl remained professional, calm, and polite, even though I know that was probably stressful and a pain to deal with. The problem was 100% on me, but he helped to fix it with such grace. I really appreciate the professionalism. I highly recommend both Carl and this specific rental. Thank you!

This place is incredible. There are so many places for small group conversations and hangout time. It felt like being in two houses. Bedrooms are lovely and varied, kitchen is well stocked. Lighting is soft and plentiful, with lots of natural light during the day. We loved spending time around the fireplace and out on the deck. Thank you for creating such a wonderful property!!

It was a great place for 8 of us to stay and enjoy an upstate weekend. An easy drive from NYC and easy access to many attractions. Kitchen is well equipped and fully functional. Ricky was very responsive. Overall I would stay here again.

The house is very modern, clean and organized. Nice stay, but too bad the weather didn’t allow us to enjoy the outdoor space.

Great setting, lots of beautiful areas to explore, and very private. Paula was a great host, and also gave great local recommendations.

We had a fantastic stay! The home was perfect for our group! There was plenty of room for everyone to relax and enjoy. The house has a stunning view of the lake and the kids loved the swing set in the yard. Everyone enjoyed the hot tub. The house was clean, well-equipped, and exactly as described. The hosts were incredibly responsive and helpful. The location was peaceful and picturesque — waking up to the lake view each morning was a treat. We would absolutely recommend this place to families or groups looking for a relaxing getaway in nature. Would love to come back again!