Cabin vacation rentals in Mountainside

Great place to stay with a bunch of people in one house

I had an absolutely wonderful stay! The space was spotless, beautifully decorated, and had all the amenities I needed for a comfortable visit. Sparta was perfect for a weekend away. It was a short walk away from a beautiful private lake and quiet and relaxing. Mario was incredibly welcoming and responsive, making check-in seamless. It truly felt like a home away from home. I’d definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a peaceful stay.

Everything was great. Our family enjoyed being here and my son wanted to stay longer😁

I had such a wonderful time during my stay here. Everything was perfect—the atmosphere, the people, and the stunning views. It truly felt like a home away from home. I’m already looking forward to coming back and experiencing it all over again. Can't wait for the next visit!

We just stayed here for a 4-day Girls' Trip and had an amazing time! The house exceeded our expectations, with everything we could have possibly needed. Adam's instructions were clear, check in was super easy, and he has been super quick to respond to any questions. The house and surroundings were clean, quiet, and peaceful. If you come in the warm months be sure to ask for the kayaks and paddle boards to be left out! We had a blast! The house was also close to lots of trails for hiking and great restaurants. Overall, a 5/5 experience, would definitely recommend!

Good location quiet neighborhood. Home is charming has everything you need. If you’re staying with children house has a lot for the kids, games a playground outback and for the adults a hot tub. We were staying while our home was under renovation so we didn’t have time to enjoy the amenities. Lisa is very responsive , and answers all your messages in a timely manner. Would recommend this place! Thank you for hosting us.

Just a moment spend always be remembered. Beautiful artistic house. Optimist peaceful energy. Great responsive host with thoughtfulness of small details ❤️

I booked this property as a kind of ad hoc writing retreat. It was the perfect location to complete what work I needed to do. A quick drive into Sparta for restaurants and supplies also made this a great location.

Absolutely lovely lake house and we loved every minute and wished we could have stayed longer. Bob was great in providing instructions and information, and was very flexible. There is good parking for 3 cars, pictures and description is very accurate. You do have to walk down a path and steps to the house (as pictured), and the three main bedrooms are upstairs. The views are the lake are fantastic! And the covered porch on the back of the house looking out over the lake is just wonderful. This was a very special gathering of lifelong friends for a wedding celebration nearby and it was such a great place to stay to enjoy spending time together in a beautiful setting. The kitchen is exceedingly well stocked with everything needed to cook and prepare meals, great appliances and both a Keurig and a drip coffee maker (preferred) is provided. Wifi worked well. Bathrooms very clean. Lovely linens, bedding and towels provided. Bob was a wonderful host and this is a wonderful gem of a place.

My friends and I had an unforgettable stay at this cozy mountain cabin! From the moment I arrived, I was taken in by the breathtaking views and peaceful atmosphere. The cabin was exactly as described—clean, beautifully decorated, and fully stocked with everything I needed for a comfortable stay. Mornings were magical with coffee on the porch surrounded by trees and birdsong, and evenings by the fireplace were the perfect way to unwind. I especially appreciated the little touches—extra blankets, board games, and a detailed local guidebook provided by the host. If you’re looking for a quiet escape in nature, this is the perfect place. Whether you’re hiking nearby trails or just relaxing with a good book, this cabin offers the perfect balance of adventure and rest. I’ll definitely be back!

Nice, spacious cabin, beautiful outdoor space. We really loved the creek running downhill in the backyard and the retro vibe of the kitchen (even with the modern appliances). The bathroom is pretty small but that was really the only complaint from us.

Kristina’s place fit our group nicely! We were down there for an event and had 6 people (plus a kid) that fit in her home nicely. The beds were comfortable, bathroom was clean, kitchen was well stocked and clean, couches were comfy to lounge on, and it was easy to find when arriving. We will be staying here again if we need this amount of space in the future! Plus it was dog friendly which is always a huge plus! There’s a nice little loop to walk them in the neighborhood too!

The place was as described in the listing. The house is out in nature but not far from local restaurants and stores. The kids loved seeing the wildlife around the house, like chipmunks and groundhogs. We even saw a black bear from the dining room window.

David’s camp is spectacular. Meeting us two at the appointed time, he could not have been more gracious and friendly as we toured the property that he has been developing for over a decade. Our lodging had all the qualities of a cabin in the woods that we could imagine plus modern technology, a beautiful bathroom, modern kitchen, comfortable furniture, a vast bedroom, and a sheltered porches on two levels. David’s handiwork includes two fish ponds, a waterfall, and more features in progress. The camp is staggering in scope and execution, but David himself is the highlight.

We were looking for a place to spend Christmas with our older daughter who has a tiny studio in the Bronx. The carriage house was in a fantastic location, convenient to the GW Bridge and our daughter’s apartment. The private parking was wonderful and the property was right next to some woods which were perfect for our dog. The apartment was spacious enough for our Christmas together and very well appointed including spices in the kitchen. Our bed was very comfortable and the apartment was very clean. Joe and Victoria were very gracious, helpful hosts who were very responsive communicators and provided a lot of good local info. I would highly recommend the Carriage house; I know we’ll be back!

We had a wonderful stay at this charming cottage. We experienced the first snow here, it was absolutely peaceful and serene. The cottage is located on a spacious farm, offering a perfect blend of privacy and convenience, with restaurants, grocery stores, and the train station all nearby. Communication with George was excellent—he checked in to ensure we had everything we needed, which made our stay even more enjoyable. Highly recommend this place!

We had a relaxing stay here. The view was lovely and house was exactly as described. The hosts were very responsive too.

Boondocks cabin was absolutely charming. As another reviewer mentioned, it feels much more spacious inside than the pictures can show. The well-laid-out kitchen with large counters is great for those who prefer to stay in and cook. It rained our first night, and there were plenty of games and books to keep us occupied. The location was also a perfect "home base" to check out everything the area has to offer. It's only a few yards down the road from several of the trailheads in Stokes, and close enough to other hiking spots that we easily drove to several over the course of our weekend (Buttermilk Falls, Copper Mines trails, Turtle Lake). It's only 5 minutes from Lake Ashroe, which is a super convenient and affordable option for families with younger kids who might not have the attention span or experience for the longer pre-planned river runs offered by the larger canoe/kayak rentals in the Water Gap. The gallery & retail space at Peters Valley is also a must-see. As a potter myself, I was thrilled to see the quality and variety of artists represented, and how many of the artists are local. All in all, we had a great experience. We spent 4 days at Boondocks and could easily have filled 4 more with all the area has to offer. GREAT communication from our hosts, too. Thanks, Dan & Kara!

The cabin was beautiful. Very quiet calm location. If you’re looking for a relaxing getaway you will not be disappointed.

Our stay at Erik's wonderful place was perfect -- close (walking distance) to miles of hiking trails, well equipped for cooking, games, and relaaxion, and a perfect place for a family gathering. I would definitely stay there again!

Alexandra was very attentive and responsive. The house was beautifully decorated and immaculately kept.

This cabin was very cozy and the surrounding area was very scenic and pretty, as well as quiet and peaceful. Kerri allowed my group of friends to shoot our short film outside the house, and it was a great location for filming as well as a great place for some of the crew members to stay overnight and hangout after shoot. We didn't have much free time but we were provided with lots of recommendations of places to checkout nearby and I'd love to maybe rent the place again sometime to explore the scenery. The neighbors were friendly and Kerri gave us very clear and useful information about the house to make our stay easy.

Great host and great stay! We really enjoyed our time here, would highly recommend to anyone interested. Beautiful, peaceful, everything we needed and more.