Vacation rentals in Middlebury
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in Middlebury
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.
Secret Haven ~Jacuzzi~Wildlife~Private Trails~
Situated on 103 private acres of abundant wildlife, trails & lush nature, your next stay provides a touch of nostalgia, having once been a cherished Girl Scout camp. Secluded yet close to town, this charming hideaway is crafted to whisk you away from everyday life and envelop you in a romantic, peaceful atmosphere. Relax, reconnect with nature, and let the jacuzzi bring you to a flow state of mind. Pay back your hard-working mind & body or surprise your spouse with a few nights at Secret Haven.
Stone Lake Cottage Middlebury IN Boat Fish getaway
Located on beautiful Stone lake in Middlebury, IN. Crafts Amish antique auction fish swim lake relaxing. Bedding, towels, and personals/toiletries are provided. 2 queens, 1 twin, 2 double beds. Includes 3 BR/4 baths (detached 3rd BR CLOSED in winter), room for 6-8, AC, Smart TV, streaming services , WiFi, fireplace, lake, pier, kayak, paddle boat, grill, fire pit, dishwasher, toys for swimming, fishing, and 5 miles from Shipshewana/Middlebury. Min primary guest age is 21. Motel hotel
The Farm Vista
Retreat and unplug in a quite country neighborhood in the heart of Amish country. The covered porch overlooks a farm and you can see a great sunset and often wildlife as well. The apartment itself is a walkout basement with a front entrance and large windows overlooking the farm and field across the road. This apartment offers all the comforts of home with two bedrooms, a pullout sofa bed, large kitchen, living room and bathroom. This retreat provides a chance to unplug and do things together.
1-bedroom RV, in a quiet spot for couples getaway
Enjoy the sounds of nature when you stay in this unique place. This unit is on the grounds of Teaberry Wood Products... In the heart of Amish country... Rise n Roll bakery is less than a 1/2 mile from our location. The Pumpkine Vine bike trail is about a mile away, the attractions in Shipshewana and Middlebury are within 4 miles. A safe place for your children… If you prefer to stay at one of our local campgrounds, we will set up our unit for $50.00 plus you would need to pay the campground.
Joy House on Main Luxe - Downtown Middlebury
Experience luxury at The Joy House on Main - a beautifully restored historical home from 1904. Now owned and operated by us, Wes & Chelsea, owners of Joyfully Said. Immerse yourself in the charm of the past while enjoying modern comforts. Located in the heart of downtown, you'll have easy access to the renowned Pumpkinvine Trail, the charming shops, and top-notch local restaurants. Only 10 minutes away from Shipshe, this is the perfect destination for a small-town getaway with loved ones.
Amen Corner - A Modern Retreat in Amish Country
Welcome to this brand new private guest house in Middlebury, Indiana tucked quietly away in the heart of Amish country. Amen Corner offers the best of both worlds…modern amenities surrounded by nature’s beauty and amazing sunsets. - Enjoy a beverage on the back patio while watching birds or the neighboring horses - Cuddle up for your favorite series inside with bedroom & living room fireplaces - Peace and quiet can be found also if you’re looking to just relax and walk some of our trails
Home with loft, Shipshewana, Elkhart, Notre Dame
Whether you are on a weekend getaway, wanting to explore the lovely towns of Shipshewana & Middlebury, or in the area to enjoy a Notre Dame game the Back Porch is the perfect place for you. At the Back Porch, guests enjoy a dreamy interior with live plants and the peaceful nature out back. Guests can easily observe Amish country, the Shipshewana flea market (16 min), stroll through the beautiful quilt gardens of Middlebury (15 min), or cheer on a Notre Dame football game (40 min).
Hidden Country Hide-A-Way
Come relax in our cozy, modern country, studio apartment. It is equipt with a fully stocked kitchenette, private bathroom, comfortable living space, large screen tv and office work space. Enjoy some of the most picturesque landscape Northern Indiana has to offer. We are just a 10 min walk from Stone Lake and have kayak rentals available upon request. We are conveniently located 8 miles from Shipshewana and Middlebury, IN and just a 40 minute drive from Notre Dame.
Mullet's Speed Shop
Refresh and relax at this newly constructed guest suite! Mullet's Speed Shop is conveniently located just 3 minutes from the famous Das Dutchman Essenhaus Restaurant and Bakery, less than 10 miles from the quaint shops of Shipshewana, and an easy 40 minute drive to Notre Dame (for the football fans). Take a bike ride or a peaceful walk on the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail less than 2 miles away. Nestled in the heart of Amish country, enjoy the buggies passing by!
| Hot Tub | Amish Farm Country | Pergola | Deck |
Backyard country living at its absolute finest!! Hot tub, back deck, patio, pergola, grill, pastureland, fire pit, open space – Welcome to your Home Away From Home! This newly/fully renovated 3 bed/2 bath ranch house in the heart of Amish country is ready for you to explore the abundant activities. Located right next door to a real working farm makes it ideal for your country getaway, and not to disappoint, Amish buggies pass by often!
Cabin off 39 - Peaceful, private one bedroom cabin
Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Nestled among the trees, it provides a quiet getaway from the chaos of life allowing you to recharge and renew. The main residence is approximately 400 feet from the cabin. The cabin is secluded and yet close to local attractions, restaurants, biking and nature trails. The Cabin has a total of 420 sq ft living space with 280 sq ft on the ground floor and a 140 sq ft bedroom loft.
Mayberry on 8 In Amish Country Sleeps 12+
Family get togethers, Girlfriend shopping trips, Couples looking for a place to reconnect with friends...we look forward to providing a great place to make memories. The wraparound porch invites you to stay awhile in the heart of Amish Country. Hosts live onsite in Owners Suite, you have the entire house to yourselves! Booking allows exclusive use of all guest bedrooms, as well as all common spaces at Mayberry on 8.
Popular amenities for Middlebury vacation rentals
Other great vacation rentals in Middlebury
Rustic Roots Cabin| 3bd/3ba Cozy/Shipshewana/ND
Farm stay in Amish Country - 4 Bedroom 2 Bath
The Red Thread Retreat
Serene Sanctuary | Tiny Home #1 in Amish Country!
Haven Suites - “Apt. A” YOUR place of REST.
Serenity Farmhouse-1 BR in Indiana Amish Country
Newly Renovated Home-Comfort in Quiet Shipshewana
Secluded Solar Amish Farm-Breakfast upon request!
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places to stay in Middlebury?
Stays near the town center make it easy to access shops, markets, and walkable areas. Quiet, rural surroundings are also frequently suggested for those looking to experience Middlebury’s countryside atmosphere.
What are the best things to do in Middlebury with kids?
Families often explore local parks, interactive farms, and the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail. Visiting area museums or hands-on craft shops can also provide fun, educational experiences for children.
What are some of the best things to do in Middlebury?
Walk the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail, visit Krider World’s Fair Garden, and sample regional foods at local markets or cheese shops. Exploring area craft studios and learning about Amish culture are also popular activities.
How is the weather in Middlebury?
Middlebury has cold, snowy winters around 17–36°F (-8–2°C), and warm, humid summers reaching 79–83°F (26–28°C). Rain is spread throughout the year, with spring and summer bringing the highest rainfall.
When is the best time to visit Middlebury?
Late spring through early fall is often recommended for comfortable temperatures and lively outdoor activities. This period highlights blooming gardens, local markets, and community festivals in and around Middlebury.
What are the best places to visit in Middlebury?
Krider World’s Fair Garden is often recommended for a relaxing stroll, while local cheese factories and markets let you explore regional flavors. The Pumpkinvine Nature Trail draws those interested in outdoor activities.
What are some hiking trails in Middlebury?
You can explore the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail, which runs through scenic countryside and woodlands. Parks and nature preserves around Middlebury also have walking paths suited for different activity levels.
What are some family activities we can do in Middlebury?
Try biking or walking the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail, visiting family-friendly farms, or relaxing at local parks. Craft demonstrations and seasonal community events also invite families to participate together.
What are some of the best day trip ideas from Middlebury?
Explore Amish-related experiences, visit local markets, or discover small towns around the region. Nature areas, craft shops, and museums nearby are often recommended for a broader view of northern Indiana’s heritage.
Are there any pet friendly accommodations available in Middlebury?
You can find a range of pet-friendly accommodations in and around Middlebury. Many hosts list pet policies, so it is often possible to travel with dogs or other companion animals.
What are some local tips for visiting Middlebury?
Consider exploring Middlebury’s locally rooted shops and restaurants, and take time to appreciate the area’s traditional crafts. Respect local customs in Amish communities, and check schedules for markets or seasonal festivals.
What is Middlebury known for?
Middlebury is known for its Amish heritage, local cheese producers, and the connection to the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail. Many visitors come to experience its traditional crafts, welcoming markets, and small-town atmosphere.
What are the best hidden gems to explore in Middlebury?
Explore local antique shops, quiet stretches of the Pumpkinvine Nature Trail, or small independent bakeries for a taste of Middlebury’s charm. Pocket gardens and handcraft studios are also frequently suggested by returning travelers.
What are the best foods to try in Middlebury?
Local kitchens often serve comfort dishes, homemade pies, and traditional baked goods reflecting Amish and Midwestern influences. Many visitors look for freshly made noodles, chicken dinners, and seasonal produce at local restaurants or markets.
What should I bring for a trip to Middlebury?
Pack for changing weather—layered clothing, a rain jacket, and comfortable footwear are useful year-round. Outdoor activities call for sun protection and sturdy shoes, while winter visits often require warm coats, gloves, and hats.
What is the nightlife in Middlebury like?
Middlebury is known for a calm, laid-back evening atmosphere with casual dining spots and community gathering places. Live music, small cafes, or occasional local events are the main evening attractions rather than late-night venues.
What are the most popular events or festivals in Middlebury?
Middlebury frequently celebrates its agricultural roots with fairs and seasonal festivals, especially in late spring and summer. Nearby towns host similar gatherings featuring local crafts, music, and traditional foods.
Are there family friendly vacation rentals in Middlebury?
Many vacation rentals in and around Middlebury are well suited for families, often featuring extra space, kitchens, and outdoor areas. Family travelers can filter for amenities such as yards, multiple bedrooms, or child-friendly furnishings.
Quick stats about vacation rentals in Middlebury
Total vacation rentals
Explore 10 vacation rentals in Middlebury
Nightly prices starting at
Middlebury vacation rentals start at G$18,828 GYD per night before taxes and fees
Verified guest reviews
Over 1,260 verified reviews to help you choose
Family-friendly vacation rentals
10 properties offer extra space & kid-friendly amenities
Rentals with dedicated workspaces
10 properties have a dedicated workspace
Wi-Fi availability
10 of Middlebury vacation rentals include wi-fi access
Popular amenities for guests
Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Middlebury rentals
5 Average rating
Middlebury stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 5 out of 5!
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Vacation rentals
- Indianapolis Vacation rentals
- Columbus Vacation rentals
- Cleveland Vacation rentals
- Louisville Vacation rentals
- Cincinnati Vacation rentals
- Detroit Vacation rentals
- Milwaukee Vacation rentals
- Lexington Vacation rentals
- Traverse City Vacation rentals
- London Vacation rentals
- Downtown Chicago Vacation rentals
- Warren Dunes State Park
- University of Notre Dame
- Potato Creek State Park
- 12 Corners Vineyards
- Grand Mere State Park
- Weko Beach
- Fort Wayne Children's Zoo
- Four Winds Casino
- Dablon Winery and Vineyards
- Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
- Studebaker National Museum
- Potawatomi Zoo
- Four Winds Field
- Howard Park
- Pokagon State Park
- Country Heritage Winery
- Morris Performing Arts Center
- Basilica of the Sacred Heart, University of Notre Dame
- St. Patrick's County Park
- Auburn Cord Duesenberg Automobile Museum
- Kalamazoo Valley Museum
- Blue Gate Theater
- Allen County War Memorial Coliseum