Vacation rentals in Magician Lake

Peaceful Cable Lake Getaway w/ Dock & Views

Escape to easygoing lake life at this cozy 2-bedroom, 2-bath cabin on beautiful Cable Lake. Perfect for families or friends, this well-equipped retreat offers peaceful views year-round, plus direct lake access for fishing, boating, or simply relaxing by the water. Spend your mornings on the screened porch, your afternoons on the lake, and your evenings by the fireplace or grill. Local wineries are just a short drive away, and St. Joseph makes a fun day trip. Why you’ll love it: - Private backyard with lake access & stunning views - Open, modern living space with fireplace & lake-facing windows - Fully stocked kitchen + wine/beverage cooler - Deck, patio furniture, Adirondack chairs & life vests - Sleeps up to 6 with a loft for extra space - Easy parking for up to 3 vehicles Whether you’re here to unwind or explore Southwest Michigan, this lakefront cabin is the perfect place to slow down and enjoy it all.

Cabin on Swede Hill

Welcome to "Cabin on Swede Hill". Our family has farmed this land since 1871. My great grandparents, Swan and Johanna Johnson immigrated to America in the 1860's, found this land which was similar to Sweden. They raised their family here. Approximately 65 Swedish families settled in this community, became to be know as the "Swede Hills". We just received the Hoosier Homestead Award from Indiana celebrating the Sesquicentennial Award. We invite you to come...... and experience country life.

-The District 5 Schoolhouse-

The District 5 Schoolhouse was historically built "with not a single nail in the structure" in the 1800's. It still stands as a symbol of dedication to craftsmanship and community. Lovingly restored, preserving as much of the original soul as possible, it promises to be a luxury stay in understated sophistication with 100% linen sheets, beautiful kitchen/dining, lovely private outdoor space, tranquil idyllic work/recharge areas, and enough space to make your own history. You won't want to leave.

Couples country stay, Creek, Private Hot Tub

Imagine soaking in a private hot tub under a star filled sky, while a gentle creek flows just steps away. Surrounded by trees and pure country quiet. This secluded couples' retreat in Southwest Michigan is your escape from everything. Enjoy a meal, book, or game while watching our feathered friends at the bird feeder right outside your door. Leave the noise behind and reconnect in a quiet setting. Lake Michigan, Amish Country Shipshewana, and Wine Country are all within 45 minutes of us.

Magician Lakehouse Escape

This Magical Lakeside Escape offers a perfect blend of luxury and comfort, making it an ideal destination for relaxation. Take a stroll on the private dock, swim in the sandy bottom waters, or kayak the shoreline. The spacious living area offers panoramic views, with breath taking sunsets. Enjoy cozy evenings by an indoor or outdoor fire. Spend the day on a (rentable) pontoon. Experience the magic of lakeside living at the newly updated Magician Lakehouse and create unforgettable memories.

Modern Minimalist Tiny House | Firepit | Nature

Welcome to our modern minimalist tiny house located a half mile from Warren Dunes State Park beach and 1.5 miles from all that Sawyer Michigan area has to offer. Tiny is the second dwelling on this property and is technically a mobile tiny house. While we do have electricity and water, much like an RV the drains run to holding tanks. This means VERY LIMITED WATER USE for showers and toilet flushing. It features a fully stocked kitchen, bathroom, and a queen bed in the small loft.

Hot tub open year round in modern/rustic cottage!

Kick back and relax in this rustic & stylish cottage that is surrounded by gorgeous landscaping on almost 2 acres in Harbert. Cherry Beach a 5 min drive, 15 mins to New Buffalo, & minutes to Greenbush, Infusco, Susan's & the new Out There wine bar! Perfect place if you seek peace & quiet - play a record, hit the hot tub, read a book in screened in porch or hammock, hang out by the firepit or jump on one of the 4 bikes! So close to boutiques, coffee shops and cute restaurants!

Sister Lakes A-Frame: Private Beach, Dock & Kayaks

Welcome to Keeler Lake Lodge! This classic 1960s A-frame sits on 100 ft of private sandy beach on all-sports Keeler Lake - just 2 hours from Chicago. Sleeps 10 across 3 bedrooms, a loft & sleeper sofa. Floor-to-ceiling lake views, a private dock, kayaks, paddleboards, fire pit, grill & pontoon rental available May–Oct. Updated with modern comfort while keeping the charm that makes a cabin feel like a cabin, this is the kind of place people come back to year after year.

The Wildwood Cottage, private lake access

New for summer 2023, private lake access across the street on Little Crooked Lake! Peaceful, 2-bedroom cottage in the heart of Sister Lakes, Michigan. Fully renovated in 2021, this cottage features a large deck overlooking trees and a partial view of Little Crooked Lake. Eat-in kitchen, Weber charcoal grill, Adirondack chairs, and patio dining for 6. Walking distance to The Strand and Sister Lakes Brewing Company. 17 miles to Lake Michigan and 30 miles to Notre Dame.

Pontoon Included *5/1/26-10/12/26* MI Getaway

This 1100 SF 3 bed/2 bath home is perfect for your multi-family or individual stay. It is located on 40 feet of water frontage on Magician Lake. A pontoon boat is included in the rental from May to mid-October. Additional private/walk-in lake access for all Bay properties is just down the street. Fish off the dock, take the boat for a few laps around the lake, or anchor at Hemlock island and enjoy the shallow waters surrounding it!

Cabin off 39 - Peaceful, private one bedroom cabin

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Nestled among the trees, it provides a quiet getaway from the chaos of life allowing you to recharge and renew. The main residence is approximately 400 feet from the cabin. The cabin is secluded and yet close to local attractions, restaurants, biking and nature trails. The Cabin has a total of 420 sq ft living space with 280 sq ft on the ground floor and a 140 sq ft bedroom loft.

Rainbows End 🌈 Puryear

Discover the tranquility of a charming cottage nestled on a 20-acre farm, surrounded by nature with walking trails that end up at the South Branch of the Galien River. Unwind on the patio with a cozy fire pit and enjoy all the amenities you'll need for a perfect getaway. Just 10 minutes away from the beautiful shores of Lake Michigan and only 3 miles from Four Winds Casino. Experience the peaceful countryside retreat—book now!