Hotels in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated hotels in Lake Shafer

Guests agree: these hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Hotel room in Monticello

Hotel Room- 1 Queen Bed w/Kitchenette

Your family will be close to everything when you stay at this centrally located resort. The hotel is approximately 1/4 mile walk to the north entrance of Indiana Beach Amusement Park. There are plenty of places to visit within approximately 5 miles including, restaurants, grocery stores, a winery, drive in movie theater, golf course, etc. This hotel also offers access to Lake Shafer where you can enjoy swimming, fishing or access to our private boat docks for an additional fee.

Hotel room in Monticello

New place to stay

Family Suite with Patio at Indiana Beach Hotel

Our Family Suite offers everything you need for a comfortable and convenient stay. Each room features its own private entrance with patio doors that open to a relaxing sitting area—perfect for enjoying your morning coffee or winding down after a fun-filled day. Enjoy in-room amenities like air conditioning, free Wi-Fi, AM/FM radio, mini fridge, microwave, cable TV, hairdryer, and ironing board. You’ll also appreciate the clean and spacious bathroom with a tub/shower combo.

Top guest favorite

A spacious room features a king size bed with a neutral-tone bedspread. An armchair sits beside a side table with a lamp. A work desk and chair are positioned near a closet, while a decorative framed image adorns the wall. Soft lighting creates a calming ambiance.

Hotel room in Frankfort

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Secluded ADA accessible King room

Enjoy a good night's sleep in this stylish, upscale room. The room features a king size bed and large bathroom with a roll-in shower large enough for 2. Choose between the traditional shower head and a hand held unit. A shower transfer chair is available upon request. Easy access, no stairs. Free Wifi. Smart TV with Hulu plus you can log into your own streaming services. Mini fridge and microwave and coffee maker are in the room for your convenience.

Hotel room in West Lafayette

Standard King + Free Breakfast +Nature Oasis

The Whittaker Inn is more than a place to stay — it’s an experience. Each room is uniquely designed, breakfast is made-to-order, and hospitality is warm and personal. Nestled near Purdue yet tucked away on 25 acres for peace, it’s perfect for getaways, business retreats, or special occasions. With boutique charm, thoughtful details, and a story born from passion, The Whittaker offers comfort, connection, and an unforgettable stay.

Superhost

Hotel room in Monticello

Dave's Last Resort - Unit #4

Classic lakeside retreat steps from the main gate of Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park on beautiful Lake Shafer! Fully refreshed in 2025 with updated interiors and quiet split-system AC — your perfect home base for fun and relaxation.

Superhost

Hotel room in Monticello

Dave's Last Resort - Unit #1

Superhost

Hotel room in Monticello

Dave's Last Resort - Unit # 6

Superhost

Hotel room in Monticello

Dave's Last Resort - Unit #2

Superhost

Hotel room in Monticello

Dave's Last Resort - Unit #3

Classic lakeside retreat steps from the main gate of Indiana Beach Amusement & Water Park on beautiful Lake Shafer! Fully refreshed in 2025 with quiet split-system AC — your perfect home base for fun and relaxation.

Superhost