Vacation rentals in Lake Mills

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

A branch adorned with delicate white flowers is positioned in a vase on a table, creating a soft focal point. In the background, a spacious bed is partially visible, with natural light entering from a window, enhancing the bright interior.

Loft in McFarland

#301 Private Apartment in Historic McFarland House

*** Our 2nd Floor is being remodeled throughout 2025 adding 4 more units to the old McFarland House This newly remodeled unit is located in the attic of the Historic McFarland House, built in 1857 in the community that bears its name. Nestled in our small suburban downtown, this unit is perfect for travelers visiting the Madison area or nomads making a pit stop in the mid-west. Only 8mi to campus or a quick commute to the capitol, McFarland is an easy exit off multiple highways and interstates.

Natural wood accents are featured throughout the entryway, highlighting a stone fireplace and a warmly lit chandelier. A decorative area rug provides contrast against the light wooden floor, while a cozy armchair invites relaxation near the staircase leading to the upper level.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 218 reviews

The Treehouse

Welcome to the Treehouse. This is our home away from home—and hopefully yours too. We love coming to the treehouse just off clear Rock Lake. The Treehouse is a getaway, although there are neighbors, you feel as if you are nestled in a grove of trees. The house itself provides places where guests can linger, relax, sip a glass of wine or a cup of java or simply just be. One of my favorite features is the glass windows that wrap up around the ceiling so that it feels like the outside is coming in.

Guest suite in Sun Prairie

A two-story home with a mix of stone and wood siding sits on a grassy lot. Large windows allow natural light inside. A paved driveway leads to the garage, with trees and a view of open land in the background.

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 369 reviews

Entire Lower Level, Countryside Garden Suite

Welcome to our home! We have upgraded our Garden (lower) Level to host travelers much like ourselves and long-term guests. The view of our backyard is incredible! You will find yourself lost in the country, yet less than ten minutes from all the excitement that Madison has to offer. Along with a private drive and entrance, you will have 1,000 square feet of comfort all to yourselves. This property is perfect for a quiet getaway we all need from time to time. All designed with you in mind.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 185 reviews

A historic home features a multi-gabled roof and intricate architectural details. The exterior showcases a blend of light and dark hues, complemented by well-maintained landscaping and a spacious lawn. A charming porch wraps around the front, providing an inviting entrance with rocking chairs nestled on one side.

Home in Wales

Beautifully Restored Historic Victorian

Whether this is for a single, couple, or small group, your stay at this historic home will truly be memorable. You’ll love the MBR suite featuring a gas fireplace, whirlpool tub, and double walk-in custom tile shower. There is an additional very nice full bath/shower on the main floor. The finished lower level has two separate rooms, each with a quality double futon with bedding available for your guests. For this attractive price, the upper 4 bedrooms are locked but may be opened for more

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

The cozy sitting area features a mix of patterned sofas and an armchair, with warm ambient lighting from two table lamps. Rich green walls create a comfortable environment, while a view into the dining area is visible through an open doorway, adding to the home's vintage charm.

Home in Watertown

Beautiful Victorian in Historic District

My Victorian home, "Belle Maison" (beautiful house), is waiting just for you. Newly restored, with 2 bedrooms, 2 baths - one with its original claw foot tub!- and a queen size sofa bed in the TV room. It is located in historic, downtown Watertown. Just a block from Main Street - with lots of shops and restaurants within walking distance - and the beautiful Rock River. The location is perfect - whether you're visiting Jefferson County or looking for a home base between Madison and Milwaukee.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 610 reviews

A wooden deck sits beside a serene lake, surrounded by lily pads. Two lounge chairs are positioned on the grass, offering a peaceful spot to relax. Nearby, trees provide natural shade, enhancing the tranquil outdoor setting.

Yurt in Cambridge

YurtCation

YurtCation is a relaxing getaway with lake frontage and nature trails. There is another yurt about 300ft up the same driveway. There are a total of two yurts and two homes that have access to the same 17 acre lake. Each yurt is off the grid and has their own queen-sized comfy bed, wood stove, Weber grill w/charcoal, fire pit, firewood, fresh water, canoe, and clean Porto Potty. Pet Policy: Max two - Must be in your sight and supervised at all times or $500 fine and check out immediately.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 137 reviews

Cabin in Fort Atkinson

Cozy Lake Cottage With The Best View & Pontoon!

Location, Location, Location! Incredible views! Retreat to this cozy Lake Koshkonong cottage with vaulted ceiling and southern exposure. Enjoy spectacular sunsets and views of the 10,000 acre lake from the north shore. Fish, hunt, boat, ski, swim, snowmobile, or simply soak up the sun and take in the view from this quiet retreat on a dead-end street. Fresh paint, bedding, and furniture make this little gem very comfortable. Great Walleye ice fishing right in front of this property!

A spacious living room is presented with a large sectional sofa and a wooden coffee table. Natural light fills the area through multiple windows, while built-in shelves display various decorative items. A flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall above a modern fireplace.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 133 reviews

Rock Lake Retreat - Lake Mills Wisconsin

Welcome to the Rock Lake Guest House. Situated right on Rock Lake and only minutes away from charming "legendary" Lake Mills, this bright and light filled home gives you a stunning private wooded retreat with tree top views from every room. A cozy living room with charming built-ins and two patio doors to an expansive wrap around deck provides a scenic overlook to the lake. The house is a retreat for all seasons. Relax and unwind to this quiet, serene setting in an updated lake home.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 317 reviews

Two Adirondack chairs are positioned on a grassy area overlooking Lake Koshkongong. The bright blue sky complements the sunlight reflecting off the water, creating a serene waterfront setting.

Home in Edgerton

Vast Lake Koshkonong Views from Pier, Deck, & Home

Our 2 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom House is located directly on the shores of Lake Koshkongong. The back deck overlooks thousands of acres of lake with endless lake views. Just steps off the deck, one can enjoy the grassy landscape leading to the lakeside fire-pit. Then continue out onto the end of the 140 foot top notch pier. The pier (seasonally of course) includes a bench on the end and stairs into the water so that you can take a refreshing swim on our sandy bottom shoreline.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

The image depicts a charming three-building arrangement situated on a cul-de-sac. The structures feature varying architectural styles with a mix of siding colors. Lush greenery is visible in the surrounding landscape, and an American flag is displayed on one of the buildings under a blue sky with scattered clouds.

Guest suite in Deerfield

Studio on the Prairie Fen

Kick back and relax at the Studio! The Studio is a 400 sq ft unique suite in the lower level of our home. A private locked entrance opens up to a sunny space with great views of a wetland beyond the backyard. Private patio to enjoy morning coffee and the sunrise. A great place to unwind and enjoy nature's beauty! We have binoculars if you love bird watching, and bikes to ride or hike the Glacial Drumlin Trail just 0.1 mile from the front door. Lic LICHMD-2021-00621.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 346 reviews

The front view of a rustic stone cabin is framed by lush green trees. The structure features a wooden overhang supported by sturdy columns, with large windows allowing natural light to fill the interior. A neatly stacked pile of firewood is visible at the base.

Cabin in Whitewater

Glamping Cabin on Cold SpringTree Farm

Unfortunately we can't accommodate same day bookings as we don't have enough lead time to prep the cabin for your stay. Glamping on a working Christmas tree farm. Beautiful single room stone cabin with loft and wood burning stove. Two small beds in loft and futon on main floor folds out into full bed. Lots of room around to pitch tents as well. Situated on 40 acres of land with a pond, barn with basketball court, creek and Christmas tree fields.

5 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

An open-concept living space features warm wood paneling and large glass sliding doors offering views of the river. A seating area is arranged with plush cushions, and a wooden table with bar stools is positioned nearby, inviting relaxation while enjoying the serene waterfront scenery.

Cabin in Edgerton

Waterfront modern cabin w/ kayaks

NO CLEANING OR ADD ON FEES! Enjoy your own private dock including 2 kayaks. Beautiful modern riverfront cabin near Lake Koshkonong's eateries and entertainment. Soak in the gorgeous Wisconsin summer with water activities at your fingertips. The rest of the year take in the pristine wonderland views in our enclosed balcony. Only 30 minutes from Madison's world class culinary experiences, performance arts, sports & festivals.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Cabins

Kick off your hiking boots at these rustic lodgings

Hotels

Stylish accommodations with great services and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Popular amenities for Lake Mills vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Lake Mills

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

An outdoor gathering space features four wooden Adirondack chairs arranged around a central fire pit. The area is surrounded by lush greenery, including tall hedges and colorful flowers, providing a tranquil setting for relaxation.

Cottage in Lake Mills

Airy Cottage Close to Rock Lake w/ Fire Pit!

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

Guesthouse in Lake Mills

BoatHouse ~Rock Lake~HotTub~ Pet-Friendly

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

A neatly arranged bedroom features a spacious bed with soft linens and accent pillows. Natural light fills the room through two large windows. A small bedside table with a lamp stands next to the bed, and a vintage-style ladder is positioned at the foot of the bed.

Home in Marshall

1898 Farmhouse on 75 acres - MJ's Farm

5 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

A spacious patio area features a combination of seating options and a built-in grill. Sunlight filters through surrounding trees, with views of Lake Ripley visible beyond. The surface is paved, providing a durable space for outdoor gatherings.

Home in Cambridge

Huge Lake House Near Madison

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

The living area features wood-paneled walls and a high ceiling with exposed beams. A comfortable black sofa faces a wooden coffee table. Light filters in through several windows, highlighting the inviting layout that connects to the kitchen area beyond.

Cottage in Fort Atkinson

Hummingbird Haven Cottage on Lake Koshkonong

A private pier stretches over the calm waters of Rock Lake, featuring a small orange pedal boat and a blue kayak secured at the end. A bench offers a scenic view, while an American flag gently waves in the breeze against a clear blue sky.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Wonderful home on beautiful Rock Lake!

The exterior of the getaway features a charming log cabin style with multiple windows allowing natural light to fill the space. A landscaped yard displays a variety of plants and flowers, while nearby trees provide greenery. A barn-like structure can be seen in the background.