Hotel vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Find and book unique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated hotel rentals in Kelleys Island

Guests agree: these hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

A shaded front porch is featured, adorned with two wicker chairs positioned for relaxation. Natural light filters through leafy trees outside, casting soft shadows on the wooden floor. The porch is framed by white railings, enhancing the inviting outdoor space.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.64 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Aunt Jane's #1 Downtown Put in Bay up to 12 guests

Aunt Jane’s is in the heart of downtown just behind the Round House! Walk to the Monument, beach, docks, and all the shops, restaurants, pools, bars, and clubs - no cabs or designated driver needed! Bring your own food + drinks and eat better for less! Full kitchen, dining room, three bedrms, one bath w/ tub. We provide pillows, blankets, comforters; you bring sheets and towels. We try to meet or beat the rate of comparable rentals! NOTE: THIS IS AN APT/TOWNHOUSE, not a stand-alone house.

Top guest favorite

A vibrant turquoise sign displays the text 'Friends of the Bay Suite' in white lettering. Decorative sun and flower graphics are positioned around the text, contributing to a welcoming presentation.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

AB Lodging - Friends of The Bay Suite, Put-in-Bay

AB Lodging in downtown Put-in-Bay (in the same building as AB Cart Rental) is a historic island hotelier's home, reimagined as cozy and economical suites. Right downtown yet tucked away for a quiet nights rest you'll be steps away from the national monument, the beach & all the downtown action. We're a short walk from the Jet Express or right across from the Miller Boat Bus depot. Rooms are smaller but comfy and feature individual air control for your comfort. Super comfy beds, too!

Top guest favorite

The image captures a view of a historic monument, framed by a decorative window with a textured glass pattern. The greenery of nearby trees adds contrast to the stone structure, emphasizing the blend of nature and architecture.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

AB Lodging - Cozy Cuddy Downtown Put-in-Bay

AB Lodging in downtown Put-in-Bay (in the same building as AB Cart Rentals) is a historic island hotelier's home, reimagined as cozy and economical suites. Right downtown yet tucked away for a quiet night’s rest. You’ll be steps away from the national monument, the beach and all the downtown action. We're a short walk from the Jet Express or right across from the Miller Boat Bus depot. The bedroom is small. It features individual air control for your comfort. Super comfy beds, too!

Guest favorite

A circular arrangement of colorful Adirondack chairs surrounds a fire pit on a grassy area. The chairs are in shades of blue, black, and white, offering seating for multiple guests. A spacious building is visible in the background under a clear blue sky.

Hotel room in Port Clinton

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Fishermen’s Denn Unit 5

Located just minutes from the Lake Erie Islands ferries, public beaches & East Harbor State Park. Numerous restaurant choices & convenience/ grocery shopping nearby. Full kitchens, backyard fire pit, outdoor grills, fish cleaning station, porch with chairs, boat plug in, & boat/trailer parking included in the rate. Our units can sleep 6 people, but are most comfortable for 4. This unit has 2 day beds with trundle beds underneath & 2 twin beds. It is located on the 2nd floor.

A sparkling pool is surrounded by comfortable lounge chairs and small tables, with a spacious house featuring a distinctive turret visible in the background. Lush greenery creates a serene atmosphere, while a bright sky adds an inviting touch to the scene.

Hotel room in Port Clinton

1 Bedroom Vintage Suite 405

Located directly across the street from Lake Erie and within walking distance to downtown and the Jet Express. This 1BR Vintage suite is located within the OurGuest Inn & Suites Boutique Hotel at 220 East Perry Street, Port Clinton, Ohio. The suite will accommodate up to 2 people and receives daily house keeping services. Shared porch and pool privileges. Lobby and front desk services on site. On site music venue (The Listening Room) brings in national talent.

Superhost

A white door with a clear window panel is framed by deep blue brick walls. On either side, two dark blue chairs are positioned, creating a welcoming entry area. A small mat lies in front of the door, adding a practical touch.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Nautical Suite - Sleeps 6

Located at the newly renovated Anchor Bay Inn and Suites, this 1 bedroom/2 full bath suite with full kitchen sleeps 6 comfortably. While this unit is complete, renovations still continue throughout the property. Centrally located, just 12 mins from Cedar Point and 10 mins in either direction to the Jet Express docks to the islands. This unit has parking for boat trailers directly out front with exterior power hookups for boats to plug in and recharge!

Top guest favorite

A modern desk area is shown with a clean, dark wood tabletop. A sleek lamp is positioned at the back, alongside a beverage bucket and remote controls. Two upholstered chairs with a quilted pattern are visible, providing a comfortable seating option.

Hotel room in Sandusky

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Close to Cedar Point Sports Force Kalahari

Experience the charm of The 419, a boutique hotel where you are within walking distance to top-rated restaurants, lively bars, shopping, and ferry rides to the islands! Our rooms are designed with your comfort in mind featuring plush bedding, modern decor, and an inviting environment. - Room 206 has a queen bed and pull out full size sofa bed - Microwave - Refrigerator - Free off street parking - High speed internet/Wi-Fi - Keurig coffee station

Guest favorite

A stone fire pit is surrounded by a circular seating area, with a warm fire glowing at its center. In the background, a spacious pavilion with a gabled roof offers shaded seating amid landscaped greenery.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Cozy Stable 5, 6 miles from downtown Sandusky

Come enjoy Millsite Lodge. Where more than a room awaits you. Our Honeymoon Suite is situated on a private corner within the beauty of Millsite Lodge. Go fly fishing in our spring fed trout stream $, then grill or smoke your catch for supper. Explore our 25 acres or settle in and enjoy a good book by the fire. Come get "unplugged" with family and friends. Rediscover the joy of being together. Millsite Lodge; a tucked away treasure.

Guest favorite

A compact bathroom is shown with light-colored walls and a window providing natural light. A white toilet is positioned next to a small sink, with toiletries neatly arranged on a silver shelf above. Fresh towels are draped over the shelf, complementing the modern fixtures.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Tranquil waterfront hotel in a fishing village

Nestled along the shores in the quiet village of Bay View, The Cedar Motel features newly renovated rooms in a relaxed setting and boasts panoramic views of the neighboring calm waters of Sandusky Bay. Located directly off State Route 2 located in between Sandusky and Port Clinton, The Cedar Motel’s central location within the Lake Erie Shores & Islands makes it the perfect place for travelers looking for a nice night’s rest. Edit

An aerial view of the resort reveals a landscaped courtyard featuring a heated outdoor pool surrounded by lounge chairs. The three-story building is painted in soft yellow, with balconies facing the courtyard. Lush greenery and carefully arranged flower beds enhance the tranquil setting.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect summer vacation destination. The Venture Resort is the only resort hotel on the island and is located within walking distance to all of the downtown action and island transportation. We offer modern amenities and beautifully appointed suites, each with their own private patio and incredible lake views!

Top guest favorite

A hand-painted wooden sign features the word 'Flybridge' in whimsical lettering, complemented by decorative flowers and a sun illustration. The vibrant turquoise background enhances the playful design, providing a welcoming touch to the space.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

AB Lodging - Flybridge Suite downtown Put-in-Bay

AB Lodging of Put-in-Bay was built as an old hotelier's home but is now newly reimagined as cozy and economical suites. You'll be steps away from the monument, the beach and all the action but in a quiet area for a great nights rest. A short walk from the Jet Express or we are directly across from the bus depot if you take Miller Ferry. Our small bedrooms have individual air control and super comfy beds.

The Bayshore Resort is captured from an aerial view, showcasing its unique architectural design. Bright blue roofing contrasts with the softer tones of the building, surrounded by well-maintained green lawns. The sparkling waters of Lake Erie are visible in the background, enhancing the resort's waterfront appeal.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

Sleeps 6! Deluxe Lakeview Suite

Welcome to Bayshore Resort! The Bayshore Resort is here to make your stay on the island enjoyable and memorable. Located on the cusp of Lake Erie, this modern waterfront property offers breathtaking views from the comfort of every guest room. This 3-acre property offers relaxing accommodation, while still being within walking distance to all restaurants and local attractions on Put-in-Bay.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Cottages

Quaint homes, peaceful surroundings

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Popular amenities for Kelleys Island hotel rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Family-friendly hotel rentals

The exterior of a two-story house is seen, featuring a classic design with light blue siding and a welcoming front porch. Large windows illuminate the front, surrounded by well-maintained greenery and colorful flowers. A driveway leads to the entrance, enhancing ease of access.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Aunt Janes 2: Large House in Downtown Put in Bay!

NoahRating, 5 stars10 months ago

Had my bachelor party here and it was a perfect spot, right next to the swim up bar, perfect spot for anyone looking to have a bunch of people in one house.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

Aunt Jane's #4 Top downtown Put-in-Bay spot for 12

JaredRating, 5 stars11 months ago

Amazing air bnb and an amazing team to help us with our stay! We arrived on put-in-bay and checked into a different air bnb and it was not at all what the pictures showed we had to share beds. I found this one last minute and they helped us get checked in a situated the same day

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Basement apartment in downtown Put in Bay

TimRating, 5 stars8 months ago

the staff went above and beyond, gave us a complimentary upgrade from a single floor apartment to a whole house. and the people who greeted us were awesome and friendly. would definitely recommend 10/10 times!

The two-story house is framed by green foliage, featuring a welcoming screened porch with large windows. The exterior showcases pale yellow siding and green shutters, complementing the surrounding greenery and creating a comfortable, inviting appearance.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.48 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Aunt Jane's Yellow House downtown Great for Events

NinetteRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

We had a group of 14 and everyone fit just fine. We notified them right away of a couple of things we noticed, but wasn't going to interrupt us where they could take care of it later. After the first night there was a slight issue and they took care of it ASAP. We had a chance to meet some of the staff and all were so friendly. The downstairs shower is a little tight, but it was manageable. For the Aunt Jane's Yellow House, what you see in the pics is what it is. We did a lot of cooking where we brought a crock pot, seasonings, some utensils just in case because not all places are stocked with everything, but not our first rodeo to the island, so we were prepared! Everything was in working order! If you call them with a question for anything, they are on top of it!

Guest favorite

A charming two-story house is framed by vibrant green grass and colorful flowers. A welcoming porch features a white railing and a flag gently fluttering. The exterior showcases light-colored siding, with a sloped gray roof and a manicured garden enhancing the inviting appearance.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

AJ's Guest House downtown Put-in-Bay

KalynRating, 5 stars9 months ago

Great location - Just a 2 min walk from the main strip! The house was just what we needed for our weekend adventure & the hosts were always nearby & available if we needed anything. Would stay again if we came back!

Show all

Hotel rentals with a pool

A spacious hotel room is featured, containing three queen sized beds arranged with light linens and dark red bedspreads. The yellow walls and patterned carpet create a vibrant atmosphere. Two nightstands with lamps are positioned beside the beds, and air conditioning is available.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

3 Queen Room with Large Pool!

HunterRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Wounderful experience wish I can stay again

A spacious hotel room features two queen-sized beds, each dressed in white linens with a red accent piece. A bright yellow wall adds a pop of color, while natural light fills the room through the window draped with patterned curtains.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

2 Queen Room Outside Cedar Point

JessicaRating, 5 stars7 months ago

This was byyy faaarrr the best motel I’ve ever stayed in. Hotel quality for sure. Super clean, great host, easy to find, and convenient self check-in. I will definitely stay here every time I visits Sandusky

Guest favorite

A well-appointed room is furnished with two spacious queen beds with light bedding, positioned against a neutral wall. A ceiling fan provides airflow, and natural light is invited in through the window, which features sheer curtains. A seating area with a chair adds comfort.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

JessieRating, 5 stars10 months ago

We really enjoyed our stay! The room was really nice and we enjoyed the pool!

A spacious sleeping area contains a king-size bed with white pillows and a purple quilted coverlet. Two bedside tables with lamps flank the bed. A framed black-and-white photograph is displayed on the wall, providing a modern touch to the room.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

4.5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

RobertRating, 5 stars6 days ago

First time staying but wont be the last! Great location with clean rooms. Nice to have a little bar and grill next door also. Just wish there was more parking. Lot was filled with golf carts.

A spacious sleeping area features a large king-size bed dressed in light bedding. Nightstands are positioned on either side, each equipped with lamps. A framed picture hangs on the wall, and a phone is visible on one nightstand.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

AmandaRating, 5 stars9 months ago

I booked here for my parents 60th anniversary. Very clean and spacious, great location. Very accommodating to my Mom and Dad.

A well-lit suite featuring a spacious bed with decorative pillows and a dark wood headboard. The room is complemented by a small side table and lamp. In the background, a sitting area with red chairs is visible, separated by a doorway leading to additional living space.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

KimRating, 5 stars6 months ago

Friendly safe helped in providing us with a great stay. Rearranged a room accommodation with ease when we had 1 member of our party not make the trip. Provided us with local recommendations on area restaurants & activities. Could not have asked for a better experience.

A spacious sleeping area features a king size bed with a lavender quilt and crisp white linens. Flanking the bed are two bedside tables with lamps, and a large piece of wall art is displayed above. The room offers warm lighting and a neutral color palette.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

ADA Glacier Suite at Kelleys Island Venture Resort

AjRating, 5 stars1 week ago

Perfect for a couples weekend. Awesome place to stay. Within walking distance of the main restaurants/ stores. Will definitely be booking again

A spacious sleeping area is furnished with a king-size bed, draped in neutral bedding. Soft lighting is provided by bedside lamps, while a framed artwork is displayed on the wall. A doorway leads to a separate living area, enhancing the suite's open layout.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Glacier Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

GraceRating, 5 stars9 months ago

We loved staying here and plan to return, perhaps with family. We spent a lot of time hanging out by the pool, which was surrounded by flowering shrubs. It was fun meeting and talking to other guests there. We extended our stay because we were havung so much fun. The second night we slept with windows open and slept better listening to the peppers rather than the loud wall AC unit.

Show all

Hotel rentals with a patio

A spacious guest room features a king sized bed with a light blanket, framed by a wooden headboard. A bedside lamp is placed on a wooden nightstand. A flat-screen TV is mounted on the wall, and a mini refrigerator and microwave are positioned within easy reach.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Large King - Near Cedar Point!

RyleeRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Great place to stay for Cedar Point goers on a budget, about 5 minutes right down the road!

A serene bedroom features a spacious bed with neutral linens, flanked by two bedside lamps. Natural light enters through a large window, illuminating the room. A comfortable armchair and wooden side table add to the cozy ambiance, while framed wall art enhances the decor.

Hotel room in Lakeside Marblehead

Standard ADA King at the Wave at Marblehead

AbbyRating, 5 stars7 months ago

We really enjoyed our stay! Great location, and beautiful property.

Superhost

A modern room features a spacious queen-size memory foam bed with a navy blue throw blanket. A small desk and chair are positioned against one wall, while a flat-screen television is mounted above. Natural light enters through a window with dark curtains, creating a bright atmosphere.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.59 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Nautical Themed Boutique Motel Room

BrookeRating, 5 stars10 months ago

This was in a great location central to many things to do, and the ferry boats. It’s great for a short stay if you mostly just need a place to sleep. The place was clean and had plenty of linens, and a few other nice touches of accommodations.

A bright guest room is adorned with pink walls and natural light from a window. A spacious bed is dressed in crisp white linens, accompanied by decorative pillows. A bedside lamp and a woven basket add practical touches, while wall-mounted decor enhances the contemporary aesthetic.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.72 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

New! Cocktail Themed Guest Room

CathiRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

this place is a converted hotel. It is renovated, it is fine. You can park right outside your room, which is nice. All went well.

A spacious guest room is presented with two queen-sized beds, complemented by a comfortable armchair. Floor-to-ceiling windows allow natural light to fill the space, offering an unobstructed view of Lake Erie. A flat-screen television and a small desk are also visible.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

On the Lake! Sleeps 4 at Bayshore

DrewRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Great place. Right on the water and has a incredible view of the lake. The listing is right downtown and has very easy access to everything the island has to offer!