Hotel vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Find and book unique hotel rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated hotel rentals in Kelleys Island

Guests agree: these hotel rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

The exterior of a two-story house is seen, featuring a classic design with light blue siding and a welcoming front porch. Large windows illuminate the front, surrounded by well-maintained greenery and colorful flowers. A driveway leads to the entrance, enhancing ease of access.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

Aunt Janes 2: Large House in Downtown Put in Bay!

Aunt Jane’s is in the heart of downtown just 1/2 block from the Round House! Just a few steps to the Monument, beach, docks, and all the shops, restaurants, pools, bars, and clubs - no long walks, cab rides or designated driver needed! Bring your own food and drinks, and eat better for less! Features fully equipped kitchen, BBQ, dining room, large living room. We provide pillows, blankets + comforters; you bring sheets and towels. We will try to meet or beat the rate of comparable rentals!

Top guest favorite

A vibrant turquoise sign displays the text 'Friends of the Bay Suite' in white lettering. Decorative sun and flower graphics are positioned around the text, contributing to a welcoming presentation.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

AB Lodging - Friends of The Bay Suite, Put-in-Bay

AB Lodging in downtown Put-in-Bay (in the same building as AB Cart Rental) is a historic island hotelier's home, reimagined as cozy and economical suites. Right downtown yet tucked away for a quiet nights rest you'll be steps away from the national monument, the beach & all the downtown action. We're a short walk from the Jet Express or right across from the Miller Boat Bus depot. Rooms are smaller but comfy and feature individual air control for your comfort. Super comfy beds, too!

Top guest favorite

The exterior features a bright yellow building with a wooden deck and handrail leading to a white door. The gravel pathway is bordered by a wooden fence, and outdoor seating is positioned nearby for relaxation. Air conditioning units are visible for added comfort.

Hotel room in Put-in-Bay

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

AB Lodging - Cozy Cuddy Downtown Put-in-Bay

AB Lodging in downtown Put-in-Bay (in the same building as AB Cart Rentals) is a historic island hotelier's home, reimagined as cozy and economical suites. Right downtown yet tucked away for a quiet night’s rest. You’ll be steps away from the national monument, the beach and all the downtown action. We're a short walk from the Jet Express or right across from the Miller Boat Bus depot. The bedroom is small. It features individual air control for your comfort. Super comfy beds, too!

Guest favorite

A circular arrangement of colorful Adirondack chairs surrounds a fire pit on a grassy area. The chairs are in shades of blue, black, and white, offering seating for multiple guests. A spacious building is visible in the background under a clear blue sky.

Hotel room in Port Clinton

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Fishermen’s Denn Unit 5

Located just minutes from the Lake Erie Islands ferries, public beaches & East Harbor State Park. Numerous restaurant choices & convenience/ grocery shopping nearby. Full kitchens, backyard fire pit, outdoor grills, fish cleaning station, porch with chairs, boat plug in, & boat/trailer parking included in the rate. Our units can sleep 6 people, but are most comfortable for 4. This unit has 2 day beds with trundle beds underneath & 2 twin beds. It is located on the 2nd floor.

Superhost

A white door with a clear window panel is framed by deep blue brick walls. On either side, two dark blue chairs are positioned, creating a welcoming entry area. A small mat lies in front of the door, adding a practical touch.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Nautical Suite - Sleeps 6

Located at the newly renovated Anchor Bay Inn and Suites, this 1 bedroom/2 full bath suite with full kitchen sleeps 6 comfortably. While this unit is complete, renovations still continue throughout the property. Centrally located, just 12 mins from Cedar Point and 10 mins in either direction to the Jet Express docks to the islands. This unit has parking for boat trailers directly out front with exterior power hookups for boats to plug in and recharge!

Guest favorite

An aerial view captures the expansive grounds of Millsite Lodge, featuring multiple buildings set amidst manicured green lawns. Surrounding fields and rows of trees create a serene rural backdrop, enhancing the lodge's secluded atmosphere. Open spaces are visible, inviting exploration and leisure.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Cozy Stable 5, 6 miles from downtown Sandusky

Come enjoy Millsite Lodge. Where more than a room awaits you. Our Honeymoon Suite is situated on a private corner within the beauty of Millsite Lodge. Go fly fishing in our spring fed trout stream $, then grill or smoke your catch for supper. Explore our 25 acres or settle in and enjoy a good book by the fire. Come get "unplugged" with family and friends. Rediscover the joy of being together. Millsite Lodge; a tucked away treasure.

Top guest favorite

An aerial view captures a vibrant waterfront area at sunset, with colorful buildings lining the shore and a serene harbor. The sky transitions from soft pink to deep blue, while the moon rises gently above the landscape, highlighting the urban scenery.

Hotel room in Sandusky

5 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Close to Cedar Point Sports Force Kalahari

Experience the charm of The 419, a boutique hotel where you are within walking distance to top-rated restaurants, lively bars, shopping, and ferry rides to the islands! Our rooms are designed with your comfort in mind featuring plush bedding, modern decor, and an inviting environment. - King bed and a pull out queen size sofa bed - Free off street parking - High speed internet/Wi-Fi - Fully stocked kitchen - Keurig coffee station

Guest favorite

A weathered wooden bench is positioned by the water's edge, offering an unobstructed view of Sandusky Bay. The calm blue waters extend into the distance, with gentle waves lapping at the shore. A clear sky is adorned with scattered clouds, creating a peaceful atmosphere.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Tranquil waterfront hotel in a fishing village

Nestled along the shores in the quiet village of Bay View, The Cedar Motel features newly renovated rooms in a relaxed setting and boasts panoramic views of the neighboring calm waters of Sandusky Bay. Located directly off State Route 2 located in between Sandusky and Port Clinton, The Cedar Motel’s central location within the Lake Erie Shores & Islands makes it the perfect place for travelers looking for a nice night’s rest. Edit

Top guest favorite

A weathered wooden bench faces the calm waters of Sandusky Bay, offering unobstructed views of the distant shoreline and a clear blue sky. Light reflects off the water’s surface, enhancing the serene environment.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Peaceful waterfront hotel in quiet fishing village

Guest favorite

The entrance to a spacious suite is visible, featuring a white door opened to a patio area. A flat-screen television is mounted on the wall, and a coffee maker and refrigerator are positioned on a countertop, creating a welcoming space.

Hotel room in Kelleys Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Iroquois Suite at Kelley's Island Venture Resort

Welcome to Kelley’s Island Venture Resort! Located on the largest island in Lake Erie, Kelleys Island is the perfect summer vacation destination. The Venture Resort is the only resort hotel on the island and is located within walking distance to all of the downtown action and island transportation. We offer modern amenities and beautifully appointed suites, each with their own private patio and incredible lake views!

A bright guest room features a spacious bed with a white coverlet and decorative pillows. Above the bed, cocktail-themed artwork adorns the blue wall. A bedside lamp and a tray with folded towels complete the inviting space, complemented by a window allowing natural light.

Hotel room in Sandusky

4.73 out of 5 average rating, 59 reviews

The Cocktail Cabin! 2 Miles to Cedar Point

Family owned and operated; we can't wait to welcome you to the area. This newly refreshed cabin is essentially around the corner from Cedar Point! Though a nearby train chugs along Cleveland Rd, we've provided Relax in our outdoor pool, open from Memorial Day to October! We are slowly refreshing this area, so you might see us watering flowers, organizing furniture, and painting!