Vacation rentals in Italy Hill State Forest

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Italy Hill State Forest

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A modern single-room cabin is nestled among trees, featuring large windows that offer natural light and views of the surrounding woods. A covered porch with seating invites relaxation, while a wooden railing adds to the cabin's rustic charm.
Cabin in Dundee
5 out of 5 average rating, 127 reviews

Timber View At Timber Trails

Escape to the countryside at the charming, “Timber View.” Surrounded by wineries & scenic beauty, this country retreat offers a peaceful getaway for those seeking to disconnect & rejuvenate. Wake up to the sounds of nature, enjoy your morning coffee on the porch, & spend your days exploring the Finger Lakes region with activities like hiking, visiting local farmers' markets, or simply enjoying the tranquility of rural life. In the evenings, gather around the fire pit for stories and stargazing.

Top guest favorite
Tiny home in Burdett
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

FLX 3- Lake View Wine Country Tiny Cabin

Nestled up on a hill overlooking Seneca Lake, watch the sunset while laying in bed or from your own patio with a fire crackling. We are local hosts and will make sure you have an unforgettable stay! Everything you could want to do in the Finger Lakes will be at your fingertips. Wineries galore, two even just next door, multiple breweries nearby, minutes to the lake, 15 minutes to downtown Watkins Glen, 10 minutes to hiking trails at the national forest, or stay in, relax, and enjoy the view!!

Top guest favorite
A comfortable living area features a green sofa paired with a wooden rocking chair. A dark coffee table sits in front, with natural light illuminating the space through two windows. A dining table with four chairs is positioned nearby, creating a cozy gathering spot.
Apartment in Penn Yan
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 559 reviews

Crows nest lake view flat

Crows Nest is located on the Keuka Lake wine trail. It is next to Red Jacket Park and Morgan Marine on one side, Seasons on Keuka Lake on the other. Very close to Penn Yan/Yates County Airport and between the Main Deck restaurant and Route 54. The property is NOT water front. Keuka Lake is accessible thru Red Jacket Park and visible from the property, but not directly on the water. There is a sidewalk from the property to town for Guests who prefer to walk, approximately 1 mile to Village center

Top guest favorite
Cabin in Branchport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

Secluded Cabin, Hot Tub, Fire Pit, Pets, Grill

Escape to the Black Birch Cabin – a stylish, romantic hideaway designed for couples. Tucked away in the heart of the woods, this cozy cabin offers ultimate seclusion w/ a private hot tub, a crackling fire pit, and serene forest surroundings. Perfect for unwinding together, whether stargazing by the fire, playing board games, enjoying the peaceful ambiance, or simply reconnecting. The Black Birch cabin invites you to relax, recharge, and create unforgettable memories in a truly magical setting.

Top guest favorite
A single-story cottage is set among lush greenery, featuring a welcoming front entrance with a blue door. The well-maintained yard includes vibrant shrubs and trees surrounding the home, with a large garage visible to the right, adding to the property’s charm.
Cottage in Penn Yan
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 152 reviews

Blūm on the Hill Cottage in the Finger Lakes

Enjoy a peaceful stay in our cottage located just over 2 miles from the quaint village of Penn Yan on Keuka Lake. Relax in the newly renovated 2 bedroom, 2 full bath home with a fully equipped dine-in kitchen, spacious living room with electric fireplace, and dining room. Enjoy the fresh air on the back deck with Keuka Lake peeking through the trees. Take in the sites of the many trails, vineyards, breweries and state parks in the area during your stay. So just relax, you're on lake time.

Top guest favorite
The cabin's exterior is displayed, featuring a welcoming porch with comfortable seating. A vibrant garden with multi-colored flowers and decorative stones enhances the entrance. An American flag gently flutters above, while a small pumpkin adds a seasonal touch to the landscape.
Cabin in Hector
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 316 reviews

Wine Trail Cabin with a view Cabin 2

New construction In the heart of the finger lakes. 1 mile from the Seneca lake wine/beer trail 7breweries and 17 wineries within 5 miles. 1 mile from the Finger Lakes National Forest, 15 minutes from Watkins glen. Lake view surrounding vineyards. Keep an eye on the sky while sitting on the porch and you may see a bald eagle. Don’t be surprised if a deer turkey. Fox etc wander through. No worries if there’s a power outage as all cabins have a backup generator that will turn on automatically.

Guest favorite
A red log cabin is seen across a tranquil pond, surrounded by vibrant fall foliage. The reflection of the cabin and colorful trees creates a serene scene. The sky is clear and blue, enhancing the peaceful atmosphere of the property.
Cabin in Branchport
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

Retreat @ Keuka Cabin

It's The Cabin! This picturesque cabin sits on 8 acres of mowed and wooded land. Enjoy all that the property has to offer with a half mile's worth of walking paths, a large front porch to drink your morning cup of joe, fully stocked pond, a fire pit/wood and more. It offers serenity in the Finger Lakes Region. Easy access to countless wineries, breweries and distilleries. The cabin is where memories are forged, belly laughs are had, and adventures await. Come, kick back, and take it easy.

Top guest favorite
A charming cabin is depicted with a covered porch, featuring white railings. In front, two grey adirondack chairs are positioned on the green grass, accompanied by a black firepit nearby. A grill is located on the left, adding to the outdoor amenities.
Cabin in Montour Falls
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Hillside Cozy Cabin

Experience a cozy cabin in a country setting with stary nights and wildlife. This 480 sq.ft. cabin will be fully stocked with amenities and more! Smart TV and a electric fireplace for extra coziness. A covered porch to enjoy those summer stormy days/nights. You will also have a firepit, chairs and a propane grill. Only a few miles away from local wineries, breweries, hiking trails, restaurants and Seneca Lake with water activities. Check out our other listing! *CABIN HOSTS UP TO 2 GUESTS!*

Top guest favorite
The kitchen area features modern appliances, including a refrigerator and microwave, alongside a granite countertop. A wooden shelf displays dishware and cooking utensils, while a window allows natural light to fill the space. The rustic wood ceiling complements the white shiplap walls.
Guesthouse in Penn Yan
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

Quiet Guesthouse near Keuka Lake and Penn Yan!

Welcome to our cozy guesthouse! Nestled in the Fingerlakes Region of New York, it's the perfect place to rest after a day spent exploring our beautiful lakes, wineries, hiking trails, and so much more. Our guesthouse is located 2 minutes away from the Keuka Outlet Trail, 5 minutes from Penn Yan and Keuka Lake, and just minutes away from several local wineries. In the winter, we love to visit Bristol Mountain Ski Resort, 45 minutes from us! We can't wait to host you!

Top guest favorite
The view showcases the charming cottages along Keuka Lake, with a gravel driveway leading to a landscaped front yard. Cars are parked in front of the house, while distant views of the lake are framed by clear blue skies.
Cottage in Hammondsport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Finger Lakes with a lake view, walk to Wineries!

Keuka Lake view cottage located half way between Hammondsport and Penn Yan on the East side of the lake. This is a year round guest house that was rebuilt in 2019-2020. It has a beautiful lake view from inside the house and from the front porch, we do not provide direct lake access. Location to launch your boat 1/2 mile away, walk to 2 wineries & 1 distillery, 1/2 mile to The Switzerland Inn & Keg & Barrell. We are also close to Watkins Glen and Seneca Lake.

Guest favorite
A charming log cabin with a blue metal roof is situated amid lush greenery. The wooden exterior features multiple windows and a welcoming front door, complemented by a pathway lined with grass. Two chairs can be seen near the entrance, offering a place to relax.
Cabin in Naples
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 602 reviews

Hi-Tor Hideaway. The Cure for Cabin Fever.

A beautiful log cabin in the woods with an incredible view, that sleeps 5. There is a queen bed downstairs, a double in loft and then a roll-away twin in living room. Peace and quiet, discovering nature and resetting yourself. Life has been a challenge and it is good to step back sometimes. Our peaceful retreat is centrally located near many parks and waterfalls. Located between beautiful Canandaigua, Keuka and Seneca Lakes.

Top guest favorite
A serene view of Lamoka Lake is framed by tall trees, showcasing a manicured lawn and a circular arrangement of rustic wooden chairs around a fire pit. The calm water reflects the surrounding greenery and distant hills under a clear blue sky.
Cottage in Bradford
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 132 reviews

Riesling Retreat - Waterfront Cottage, Lamoka Lake

Riesling Retreat is situated on scenic Lamoka Lake, in NY’s Finger Lakes Region, between Keuka and Seneca lakes. Our cottage is professionally cleaned after each visit and boasts an expansive covered porch, full kitchen with gas stove and island for cooking, manicured lawn with fire pit, dock, and launch for the kayaks or canoe. It is central to Watkins Glen, Hammondsport, and more than 250 wineries; you can’t go wrong!

Popular amenities for Italy Hill State Forest vacation rentals