Vacation rentals in Geist Reservoir

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Geist Reservoir

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

An open living space features a cozy seating area with light-colored sofas on a patterned rug. A dining table is set for four, while bright natural light streams through large windows, highlighting the seamless connection to the kitchen in this welcoming environment.

Home in Carmel

Carmel Remodel near Arts & Design on 2 Acres

Welcome to this newly remodeled 1,300sf ranch in the heart of Carmel. Luxuriously appointed with fully-stocked custom kitchen, tile showers, memory foam matresses, and loads of charm and comfort. Enjoy your morning coffee watching the deer and other wildlife meandering the 2-acre property. While you may never want to leave this peaceful retreat, it's located in the heart of Carmel within walking distance of the Arts & Design District; a hub for dining, shopping, entertainment, and nightlife.

LocationValueQuiet

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Fishers

Spacious Fishers 3BR | Park + Fishers District

Spacious 2,300 square-foot ranch in a quiet Fishers neighborhood, just steps from Cumberland Park and 1.3 miles from Fishers District. The home sleeps 6 comfortably with a king bedroom, one queen bedroom, and a third bedroom with two twin beds, plus two full baths. Enjoy an open concept living area, 75 inch Roku TV, fully equipped kitchen, large outdoor deck, multiple seating areas, and a large walk-in rain shower. A great home base for Fishers, Westfield Grand Park, Golf and Indianapolis.

FamilyLocationQuiet

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Indianapolis

Indy Funhouse: Huge Game Room, Pool, Pong, & More!

Welcome to Halyard Haven! Amenities: 🎮 Game room w/ large TV & pull-out couch 🎱 Pool table + classic arcade: NBA Jam, Mortal Kombat, Skeeball & more 🕹️ Video games galore 🏀 Basketball hoop for some outdoor fun 🍿 Popcorn bar—perfect for movie nights ☕️ Stocked coffee bar to jumpstart your day 🏡 Spacious, cozy layout great for groups 📺 Two living rooms w/ big-screen TVs Location: 📍 25 min to downtown Indy 🌊 5 min to scenic Geist Reservoir 🌟 5-star home in one of Indy’s best areas

LocationFamilyCheckout

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 64 reviews

Guest favorite

The exterior of a brick home is illuminated at night, showcasing well-manicured landscaping. Warm lights highlight the architectural features, including large windows and a welcoming front entrance. A tree and shrubs add to the charm of the inviting façade.

Home in Fortville

Stylish w/ game room, gym, office -x’lent location

Enjoy this 5,000+ square foot home located in one of the country’s most sought after places to live, Fishers, In. Fishers is just 25 miles northeast of downtown Indy and one mile from Geist Reservoir. Whether you’re in town to visit family, the lake, a music or sporting event, holiday, work or just relax, this home has all the comforts of your own home. You can relax inside by playing games, working out, just visiting or you can use the private office to catch up on work.

FamilyLocationNearby

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Guest favorite

Home in Fishers

Cozy Home in Downtown Fishers

Top rated home in the heart of downtown Fishers! Short walk to brunch spots, sports bars, and two nearby breweries! Nearby attractions: ⛳ Top Golf (3 min) 🏟️ Fishers Event Center (7 min) 🎵 Ruoff Music Center (10 min) 🐎 Connor Prairie (10 mins) 🏀 Mojo Up Sports Complex (12 min) ⭐ Indiana State Fairgrounds (18 min) ⚾ Grand Park Sports Complex (25 min) 🏟️ Lucas Oil Stadium (30 min) 🏟️ Gainbridge Fieldhouse (30 min) 🏎️ Indianapolis Motor Speedway (31 min)

ValueLocationComfort

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Top guest favorite

A modern living area features a light-colored sofa adorned with a decorative throw and pillow. A geometric accent wall serves as a backdrop, while a wooden coffee table with decorative items is positioned in front. A lamp and a small dining area with a chair are visible.

Apartment in Fishers

King Bed - 1B/1BTH - POOL

BRAND NEW upscale one bedroom apartment with king bed. Minutes away from Downtown Fishers. Complex is conveniently located next to nature preserve, walking path & Nickel Plate Trail. Enjoy the amazing amenities: Pool, hot tub, fitness center, business center, clubhouse lounge & outdoor grilling space. 10mins away from Ruoff Music Center. Note: POOL AND HOT TUB ARE DURING SUMMER MONTHS ONLY. (FROM MEMORIAL DAY THROUGH LABOR DAY)

LocationValueCheck-in

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 207 reviews

Top guest favorite

A single-story home with a welcoming façade features a well-maintained lawn, colorful flower beds, and a two-car garage. A neatly paved driveway leads to the entrance, highlighted by a front door adorned with a decorative window and an American flag.

Home in Pendleton

Sunset Oasis | Water Views + Pool Access

Welcome to Sunset Oasis, a peaceful single-story retreat designed for families and friends to relax and reconnect. Enjoy beautiful water views, stunning sunsets, a fenced backyard, and access to neighborhood amenities including a pool, playground, and walking paths. Conveniently located in Pendleton near I-69, Sunset Oasis offers the perfect balance of comfort, privacy, and easy access to Indianapolis attractions.

ValueFamilyCondition

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Indianapolis

Charming Spacious Farmhouse

Our 5-bedroom farmhouse in Indianapolis sleeps 16, with a master suite featuring a jetted tub. Perfect for families or groups, the game room offers fun for all or can be converted into a banquet space (fees apply). Host meals for up to 40 guests with optional dining setups. Conveniently located near the Carmel Arts District, sports venues, and more, it’s ideal for family reunions, retreats, and special events.

FamilyLocationNearby

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews

Guest favorite

A modern kitchen and dining area features dark wooden cabinetry and countertops, complemented by earthy stone accents. Bar stools line a central island, while a dining table with metal chairs sits near a window, allowing natural light to brighten the space.

Home in Fishers

Cozy Home in Fishers Cul-de-sac

Spacious home in the heart of Fishers, Indiana, perfect for groups up to 16! Just minutes from Hamilton Town Center, Ruoff Music Center, The Arena at Innovation Mile, Downtown Fishers, Conner Prairie, and Fishers Event Center. Surrounded by shops, dining, and easy I-69 access. Ideal for families or group getaways—includes highchair and Pack 'n Play for infants. Enjoy comfort, space, and a great location!

LocationFamilyDecor

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

Guest favorite

A modern living area features a light-colored couch adorned with orange throw pillows. A coffee table is positioned in front, complemented by a decorative area rug. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, with a cozy armchair added for seating.

Apartment in Fishers

*Luxury Walk in the Park* - King Bed

Upscale 1 bedroom apartment w/ king bed walkable to downtown Fishers. Complex is conveniently located next to nature preserve, walking path, & nickel plate trail. Enjoy walking to downtown Fishers to have coffee, icecream, casual or fine dining. Enjoy the amazing amenities: pool, hot tub, luxury fitness center, business center, clubhouse lounges, & outdoor grilling space. 10 minutes to Ruoff Music Center.

FamilyValuePool

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 161 reviews

Top guest favorite

A bright living room features large windows allowing natural light to fill the space. A spacious couch is paired with two armchairs, and a patterned ottoman sits in the center. A console table with a round mirror complements the decor, enhancing the room's welcoming feel.

Home in Carmel

Home in the Heart of Carmel

Welcome to your home away from home! High End Finishes. Walk to Downtown Carmel. Modern 3 bedroom Ranch. Master Suite with new, updated private bath, gourmet kitchen, high speed internet, large screen TV’s. Privacy fenced backyard, gas grill, corn hole set and basketball court. Just a 5 min easy walk to the Monon trail in downtown Carmel and all that it has to offer. Safe and very quiet neighborhood.

ValueLocationHeating

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Guest favorite

A spacious living area is presented with high, sloped wooden ceilings and large windows offering views of the surrounding greenery. A comfortable sectional sofa is arranged alongside a coffee table, with a soft area rug beneath it, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

Cabin in Indianapolis

Unique A-Frame Retreat•Prime Location•Custom Bath

Perfect for families, friends, or weekend getaways — this unique A-Frame cabin offers peaceful privacy, a fire pit + patio, screened porches, and easy access to downtown Indy and Broad Ripple! Unique architecture and comforting features makes this home one you won't want to leave. Great for a romantic weekend getaway, a family trip with plenty of space for all, or a gathering of friends.

LocationValueLayout

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews