Vacation rentals with lake access in Fire Island

Andrew and Kenneth were excellent hosts. Some of the most professional, responsive and attentive I have experienced. The home is cozy, and the space is really well used and appointed. Some of the appliances are a bit quirky -- like the washer/dryer, which isn't very effective; and the stove/oven which the hosts are aware needs some repairs. The location is lovely. Be prepared to listen to the ducks on the lake. They can be loud even during the night. The outdoor shower was the icing on the cake for me. I nearly stayed longer, except I had another opportunity overseas.

We had an absolute PERFECT stay here! First off- the house. This home is so charming in every way. We loved the way it’s decorated and laid out, and it’s so cozy, clean and beautiful. You are truly able to relax here. Also, the bed is extremely comfortable, the water pressure is great, and the A/C works very well. However, perhaps the best part of this house is the view! There are sliding doors in the living room and bedroom, and the view of the lake is breathtaking. The area is super safe and quiet, and you are in walking distance to downtown Niantic and the Boardwalk which you cannot beat! Also only about 20 minutes from Mystic. I cannot forget to mention how amazing our host, Katie, was! Super attentive and responsive with messaging, and she was even here doing yard work when we arrived so she greeted us which was such a nice touch. Overall, we will DEFINITELY be looking to stay here again! Loved every minute of it.

This was the second time staying at Angela’s place and it was a great experience, again! The location is great and the back yard is so peaceful and cozy. My family says it feels like it’s our Fairfield Home! I would highly recommend it! First Class!

Joann's place is exactly as described. The cottage sits in a peaceful neighborhood that provided some nice little walks for our dog. Joann was extremely accommodating and responsive - we got a flat tire right before checking out so it was a bit chaotic and she was very understanding. It was the perfect place for our family to stay while dealing with house renovations close by. It rained most of the time we were there but there was a fire pit and kayaks provided that would have been so nice to use. I wouldn't hesitate to recommend this place if you are looking for a quaint little getaway.

My friend and I had the most wonderful stay at Carey’s beautiful home. It looks just like the photos and is the perfect charming stay for 2 friends or couples. The location is fabulous—about 10 minutes to all the attractions of Southampton but also very secluded. We loved walking to the beach at the end of the road, visiting Lunch for Lobster Rolls, taking tennis lessons close by at the water mill community center, and even driving about 20 mins to Sagtown coffee in Sag Harbor. On sunny days we enjoyed reading our books out by the water. Carey was a fabulous host and was extremely communicative from the minute we booked all through our stay. For any minor things that needed attention (like a changed lightbulb or sticky doorknob), she had a lovely local handyman come by within a day, all the while communicating with us to ensure it worked with our schedule—what more could you want from an Airbnb host?! We can’t wait to hopefully return soon.

Sarah’s place was absolutely lovely! Super clean and well stocked kitchen for making a meal. Sarah was also very responsive and had great local recommendations. Our group also found the beds to be quite comfortable! Highly recommend!

we loved this place! Beach was so close walkable, the house was perfect for our stay. Host is super responsive. House had all the amenities we needed, beautifully tastefully decorated. We loved our stay

The house was spacious with great outdoor seating, pool and hot tub. Great for large group

Upon arriving we were taken with the location, beautiful and ample plantings and attention to detail like a bottle of wine and a variety of snacks to welcome us. The hosts were gracious, warm, gave us privacy, and great tips on where to eat. Cowfish in Hampton Bays is not to be missed. A large and private hot tub, comfortable lounges, and outdoor shower are just some of the amenities. A fire pit with water views was a great spot to unwind at night. The hosts gave us kindling and a lighter, and were very responsive with other asks and recommendations. It’s a great location with ease of access for both the North and South Fork. Would not hesitate to recommend to others.

My wife and daughter came in for a soccer tournament. Initially it was 4 of us and a dog but we changed it as one of my girls plans got cancelled. Aseem had no issue accommodating the change and refunded the difference. The place worked out great. Thank you.

We had a great weekend. Apartment was exactly as described and spotless.

Ana was a great host, firstly the apartment smelled AMAZING and it was nice and cool, she had toiletries laid out and the bed was comfortable. The ambiance of the apartment was very welcoming and homey. Will definitely be back, thank you for the hosting.

Lovely place! We enjoyed our stay. So close to everything Greenport has to offer!

Ricardo’s place was truly incredible. It’s such a cozy, clean and convenient spot located in a very good area. Had everything you need and have a very home-like feel. I was visiting my girlfriend for our anniversary and the weather wasn’t the greatest outside but that didn’t bother us one bit. We were comfortable cooking and eating at home and we had everything to make that happen. Ricardo and his wife were so kind and flexible with us. We would love to come back in the summertime and fully enjoy their spot again because there are great views in the backyard by the water. Well worth the price of admission. Thank you Ricardo and family. We will definitely be back if you’ll have us! Cheers 🥂

Great stay! The apartment was super clean and just as described. The host was very responsive and helpful throughout our visit. We were even allowed to check in early, which made things so much easier. Would definitely recommend!

Susan's place was great and I would highly recommend. From check in to check out everything was great. Will definitely return if in the area again.

Adorable cottage across from a pretty lake. Private and quiet. Cottage was clean. Plenty of nice towels and hot water. View was beautiful. Bring your cotton sheets if you don't like microfiber, and bring your SS pans if you don't like non-stick cookware. Robert was very kind and responsive. Would stay here again!

Such a lovely host and stay. Anne is the kindest - a truly special place and person!

Great place to stay for a lovely weekend getaway. Peaceful and beautiful!

Deb’s place was very peaceful, comfortable, and well appointed. We immediately felt at home and enjoyed the interesting decor and personal style. It felt like staying in your own bed and breakfast. There were so many places to relax, and the front and back porches were so welcoming. The location can’t be beat if you want to check out the local wineries, farmstands, and great restaurants. An easy walk across the street to Peconic Bay, you can see from the upstairs bedroom. Kitchen was well appointed with everything you would need for cooking. Short ride to markets, farmstands, and Love Lane for shops and restaurants, about 20 minutes to Greenport.

I can’t say enough wonderful things about this spot and Monika. This is our second stay- my husband, toddler, dog and I loved it last summer and came back. The back sliding doors open onto a porch where birds chirp and visit all day. The bright green lawn under towering trees is perfect for playtime or a family picnic. Little touches of thoughtfulness and charm are just everywhere. Monika’s hospitality is unparalleled- snacks and a handwritten note upon arrival, homemade treats throughout our stay, and nearly instant responses. Without being asked, she even sent us a hand-drawn walking route for a dog and baby and directions for getting there. Beaches, playgrounds, town centers, bagels etc are a short drive. The street is busy so wouldn’t go for a nearby walk necessarily but thats pretty standard throughout the Hamptons. For parents of young kids: FYI there isn’t laundry, but truthfully I just packed more- that’s how much we liked it. A laundromat is also nearby tho!

This tiny, cozy space was exactly what we needed for an overnight place to relax and sleep, with a kitchen for us to make our coffee in the morning. We also felt we would have been quite comfortable there if we had needed to stay for a few days. The host was kind, responsive, friendly, respectful, and genuine. We will definitely stay here again. And the view! Gorgeous.

Super special place. Very peaceful. Beautiful surroundings. If you love nature and a charming location, this is the place. The host was also extremely responsive and the cottage had everything I needed for a three month stay! Highly recommend!

A truly stunning architectural gem, like a mid-century modern treehouse floating above a pond. Comfortable bed, convenient layout, private and secluded, but close to so much. Do note: requires some steps that might be slippery when wet — but well worth it. Also: pay close attention to the directions, don't just trust the gps.