Hotels in Fire Island

Find and book unique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated hotels in Fire Island

Guests agree: these hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The kitchen features navy blue cabinetry, a white countertop, and a large island with seating. A stainless steel stove and sink are included, along with modern appliances and stylish decor. Natural light enters through the nearby windows, highlighting the warm wood flooring.
Hotel room in Greenwood Heights
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

3 Bedroom Private Apt - DPLX

A charming Airbnb nestled in the heart of one of New York City's most desirable neighborhoods Greenwood Heights/South Slope. This tastefully decorated and fully furnished unit offers a unique and comfortable stay for travelers seeking a cozy home away from home. Drawing inspiration from the neighborhood's rich history, as you step inside, you will be greeted by an open-concept living space, where natural light floods through large windows, illuminating the warm wooden floors and stylish decor.

Superhost
Hotel room in Downtown Brooklyn
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 625 reviews

Near Barclays Center with On-site Dining & Gym

Stay downtown at Hilton Brooklyn New York, located just one block from the subway and minutes from the Barclays Center and Brooklyn Heights Promenade. Situated on the corner of Smith Street, we are surrounded by Boerum Hill's renowned shops and restaurants. Relax in modern rooms featuring digital key access and streaming entertainment. Enjoy Italian-inspired dining at our on-site restaurant, Carne by Allora, or stay active in our 24-hour fitness center. The best of NYC is at your doorstep.

Superhost
The exterior of the Courtyard by Marriott Shelton is showcased, featuring a modern, multi-story structure with large windows. The entrance is prominent, framed by landscaped greenery and a spacious parking area. The building is complemented by soft evening lighting.
Hotel room in Shelton
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 154 reviews

Close to Yale University + The Bistro. Pool. Gym.

Settle into comfort at Courtyard by Marriott Shelton, located near I-95 with easy access to Yale, Downtown New Haven, and area parks. Fuel up with Starbucks® drinks at The Bistro, unwind in the indoor pool, or stay productive in the 24/7 fitness center. Free parking and Wi-Fi keep things simple, while nearby hiking trails, restaurants, and local attractions make it easy to explore. Whether you're in town for work or a weekend escape, this stay makes it feel effortless.

Guest favorite
A well-appointed bedroom features a spacious bed with neatly arranged towels. Natural light fills the room, highlighting the light-colored walls and wood flooring. A modern mirror and a dresser with a warm wood finish are present, contributing to the room's inviting ambiance.
Hotel room in Kismet
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Moonrise Motel Kismet Unit 101

The Moonrise Motel is a newly renovated vacation spot located in the heart of Kismet, just steps from the Marina. Enjoy our pet friendly, 1, 2 and 3 bedroom units that include a kitchenette, patio seating, courtyard access with BBQ, and an attached outdoor Bar and Market. Other local restaurants are steps away and the beach is just a short walk down the block! Beach chairs and towels are included with your room. We also offer bike rentals for you to ride around town!

Guest favorite
A modern living area is displayed with a gray sofa adorned with a colorful throw blanket. A sleek coffee table sits in front, accompanied by small decorative items. Wall-mounted oval mirror reflects light, and views of the kitchen can be seen through an open doorway.
Hotel room in Hell's Kitchen (Clinton)
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

New Renovated - 1 Bed Wash/Dryer & Kitchenette -E

At SQUARE 42, we redefine urban accommodation by blending the comforts of home with the luxury of hotel living. Nestled in the bustling heart of New York City, our apartment hotel offers a serene retreat from the vibrant energy of the city streets. Whether you're visiting for business, pleasure, or a bit of both, Square 42 is thoughtfully designed apartments cater to every need of the modern traveler. **ABSOLUTELY NO SMOKING ALLOWED IN OUR APARTMENTS!**

Guest favorite
Hotel room in Times Square
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 231 reviews

Walk to Broadway Theatres + Rooftop Bar & Gym

Experience a refined escape at Kimpton Theta, an architectural gem in the heart of the Theater District. Just steps from Broadway and Times Square, this boutique retreat features oversized guest rooms that serve as a quiet sanctuary from the Midtown energy. Guests enjoy elevated perks including the rooftop oasis, Bar Sprezzatura, and complimentary morning coffee. It is the perfect blend of high-design sophistication and the vibrant soul of Manhattan.

Superhost
Hotel room in Greenport
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 99 reviews

Long Island Sound Views | Free Breakfast & Pool

Wake up to the waves at Sound View Greenport. Every room boasts a private waterfront deck overlooking the Long Island Sound. Unwind on our quarter-mile private beach, lounge by the seasonal pool, or savor local seafood at The Halyard. Just minutes from North Fork wineries and downtown Greenport, this mid-century modern retreat offers the perfect mix of relaxation and adventure. End your day with a cocktail at the Piano Bar and a stunning sunset.

Superhost
Hotel room in North Fork
4.79 out of 5 average rating, 94 reviews

Partial Harbor Views + Free Breakfast & Pool

Wake up to harbor views at The Harbor Front Inn, perfectly set in the heart of Greenport Village. Just steps from Mitchell Park Marina, boutique shops, and the Shelter Island Ferry, this stay blends coastal charm with modern comfort. Enjoy the seasonal outdoor pool, start your mornings with complimentary breakfast, and take advantage of free parking while exploring Long Island Wine Country and the North Fork’s best spots.

Guest favorite
Hotel room in The Financial District
4.78 out of 5 average rating, 471 reviews

Near Wall Street | Restaurant + Skyline Views

Experience New York from a bold new perspective at M Social New York Downtown, where skyline views meet sleek design in the heart of Lower Manhattan. Overlooking the Brooklyn Bridge and One World Trade Center, this stylish hotel is steps from Battery Park, Wall Street, and the 9/11 Memorial. Enjoy modern rooms, a restaurant & bar on-site, a 24-hour fitness center, and unbeatable access to subway lines and ferries.

Top guest favorite
A cozy bedroom corner is highlighted by a wooden dresser and bedside table, adorned with potted plants and a decorative basket of flowers. A warm lamp casts a soft glow over the space, complementing the neutral-toned bedding and the natural wood elements.
Hotel room in Chelsea
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 244 reviews

Tranquil Midtown Sanctuary - Full Bed

Step into a peaceful Zen sanctuary in the heart of NYC. This cozy room features a memory foam full bed, desk, closet, private sink, and sunlit window. Enjoy plants, natural light, and serene vibes. The shared hallway bathroom is private-use and kept spotless. Guests also have access to a quiet Zen backyard, dining area, filtered water, coffee, and free breakfast items all day. Service dogs OK with proper docs!

Superhost
Hotel room in Times Square
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 235 reviews

Near Times Square with Rooftop + 5 Dining On-site

Stay at The Knickerbocker, an iconic luxury hotel set at the crossroads of Times Square and Broadway. Blending Beaux-Arts heritage with modern sophistication, this landmark stay places you steps from Fifth Avenue shopping, world-class theaters, and NYC’s most celebrated sights. From rooftop moments above the skyline to refined interiors below, it’s a polished retreat in the heart of Manhattan’s energy.

Superhost
Hotel room in NoLita
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 2,318 reviews

Untitled at 3 Freeman - Studio Queen

Welcome to UNTITLED at 3 Freeman Alley! Our Studio Queen room measures 125 sq ft and features a queen-sized bed as well as a small desk. This room is located anywhere between the 2nd and 7th Floors with minimal or no views. All pictures shown are for illustration purposes only. The actual room layout, windows and views may vary depending on location within the property.

Popular amenities for Fire Island hotels

Quick stats about hotels in Fire Island

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 20 vacation rentals in Fire Island

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Fire Island vacation rentals start at G$48,151 GYD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 290 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Pet-friendly vacation rentals

    Find 10 rentals that welcome pets

  • Wi-Fi availability

    20 of Fire Island vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Fire Island rentals

  • 4.8 Average rating

    Fire Island stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.8 out of 5!

  • Nearby attractions

    Fire Island's top spots, include Fire Island National Seashore, Islip Cinemas, and Plaza Cinema & Media Arts Center

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Fire Island
  6. Hotel rooms