Cabin vacation rentals in Cottonwood Lake

We recently stayed at Jay’s place in Alma for a ski trip, and we had the best time. The accommodation was perfect and, honestly, one of the best Airbnbs I have ever stayed in. The level of detail he’s put into all the little things makes for such an exceptional stay. Would recommend this to anyone wanting a nice, cozy stay away from the noise but close to the ski field.

This was such an amazing week with the family. The house was beautiful, tucked into such a great place to explore. We love hiking and hiked everyday we stayed. There’s great little trail close to the house for a short hike. Then we went up to Wheeler Lake (still snowy/runoff). Still super fun! Beaver creek for a relaxing hike. Hot tub every night watching the wildlife wander by. Didn’t see Sheila! Maybe another time. Thank you so much Jody!

Mark & Nancy were on top of everything before we got to the cabin. From vehicle recommendations to all of the info we needed to get in. The airbnb was stocked with everything we needed along with fun card and board games to keep everyone entertained. One couple on the trip even got engaged at the top of the hill right by the airbnb with the beautiful mountains in the background! 10/10 would recommend.

Our group of 8 had a wonderful time on our week stay. The house is located in a beautiful spot close to Breckenridge skiing and FairPlay fishing, and the community around it are some of the nicest people I have ever met! Truly an amazing experience!

Our family had an amazing time and thoroughly enjoyed our cabin stay. We celebrated my son’s birthday and Mother’s Day together. My son always likes to go on a trip/experience for his birthday and this was the cabin he chose. Picturesque views. Weather was great. The cabin really helps you feel right at home while soaking up the relaxation. We really had a great time.

Absolutely bliss. Gorgeous. Mountain View from the hot tub was my favorite. A great hike less than 10 minutes away. Quiet, private and super clean!! Highly recommend this to anyone looking to stay near Fairplay. Loved calling this home for a week.

Due to low competition and a decent price point compared to competition this place does well. I would rate it 3-4 stars based on just the mere location. The rating goes to 4-5 with the view you don’t get in Denver and the hot tub. Negatives- right off the highway so your heart rate goes up entering and leaving. There’s no shampoo just some cheap dollar store soap which I guess you can use for shampoo. Up to you.. bring your own if you want. Not really a tranquille mountain getaway as there’s a cabin infront of your nice Mountain View(not shown in the photos) and the sound of the highway outside. Positives- Hot tub with nice Mountain View’s, which make you forget about the highway noise and hopefully you fill it with good conversation with whoever you’re with. The prairie dogs scurrying around out back are cute. Conclusion- I have to say the hot tub saved it. Keep the hot tub maintained and people will be happy.

Lovely, peaceful place that filled our need for a quick getaway from Denver. We were so happy to be able to bring our dog, and we enjoyed the surrounding area and the hot tub immensely. The cabin is very comfortable and homey with a beautiful, stocked kitchen. Thank you for sharing your piece of heaven on earth!

We had the most incredible stay at this secluded mountain cabin! Tucked away in the trees with stunning views and total privacy, it was the perfect escape from everyday life. The cabin was cozy, and thoughtfully stocked with everything we needed. If you’re looking to unplug and recharge in peaceful surroundings, this is the place. We’re already dreaming about our next visit!

Stayed here with 6 people total and everyone was very comfortable. Tara provided helpful instructions and was always responsive to any questions I had. The property requires a gate code and has very little traffic once off the main road. Kitchen was spacious and the loft bedroom upstairs was super cool. We got snowed on pretty good our first night so we were very glad to be able to use the fireplace at the home! The place was very clean and couldn’t have been happier with our stay.

My sister and I had a wonderful experience with Doug and felt right at home at his little rustic cabin nestled in an Aspen grove by the creek. The surrounding area is beautiful and Doug was very helpful with local recommendations. Bonus points for helping us load the car after I came down with appendicitis on our last day and had to have an appendectomy, which limited my lifting capabilities. Thanks, Doug! We’ll definitely look at coming back soon! And hopefully I’ll not lose another organ while I’m there! :-)

Our whole group (8 total) really enjoyed our "girls weekend" here. We were all blown away by the view through the huge living room windows when we first came in the back door. The place was also bigger than we expected, which was a great surprise. The house had everything we needed for a big home cooked dinner, good night's sleep, and a movie night. We also loved the deck for happy hour drinks and star viewing at night. I really appreciated how quiet of an area it is. I highly recommend this home for anyone willing to be outside of town/a 20 minute drive to Buena Vista.

We stayed here for our wedding, and we could not be happier with our stay. We had everything we needed, and it was a nice, quiet place to get away. A bit far from stores and restaurants, but we were prepared and loved to cook at the house. Scenery was beautiful, I loved waking up to the mountain sunrise every morning. Thanks for such a beautiful home for our stay!’

Beautiful cabin with even more beautiful views. Lots of room. I visited with my fiancé, our two daughters, and my mom. We had an amazing few days in the mountains. David was super informative ahead of time and was responsive/easy to reach. The deck and views alone make this place worth it. Definitely recommend!

We loved the beautiful home and private property. Kerry was friendly, helpful, and reaponded quicklu when I reached out to ask about the thermometer. We thoroughly enjoyed the cedar tub! 10/10 would recommend!

The cabin was everything we expected. The view was stunning and the accommodations very comfortable.The patio was perfect to sit and watch the sunset from and in the mornings just enjoy the view of Twin Lakes.

The cabin was lovely and exactly as described. We felt right at home for our getaway into the mountains and had all the amenities we needed. We loved the game room and took advantage of the pool table and jacuzzi many times! Great for families and would highly recommend for anyone looking for a trip to the Rockies!

Josh’s place was perfect for us! We loved the location and enjoyed all the wildlife. The house was clean and comfortable and had a fully stocked kitchen which made cooking easy!

This home is lovely. It’s in a beautiful location with lots of trees and an amazing front porch! We loved the rocking chairs! It’s really easy to get to the grocery store and restaurants. Inside is beautiful. It’s well-decorated and well-stocked. The bed is awesome and it was super clean. We will definitely be back!

Holy-moly, what a place! Private, secluded, breathtaking views (& not just from the cabin but on all the roads & routes to the place), &, as others have said, everything you might need was stocked (tho you might want to bring your favorite herbs/spices if you plan on cooking). The bed was super cozy, heating/cooling a breeze, & NO scented stuff anywhere (thank goodness)! The grounds were fun to wander around &, when we arrived, we were literally greeted by a very friendly White-breasted Nuthatch who graciously took unsalted peanuts right out of my hand. Note to those not from higher altitudes: Come prepared with O2 in cans (stocked in convenience stores in CO) & hydration aids…it is UP there & very dry. Sharon is responsive & ready to help, even early on Sunday a.m. if need be. We can’t speak highly enough about this rental; we hope to be lucky enough to rent here again someday.

Wonderful place, beautiful scenery, got to see deer walking in the backyard, that wasn’t expected but wonderful to see. Will definitely stay there again when we visit Buena Vista. Well worth what paid to stay.

Great place to stay for all that Buena Vista has to offer ! There are other houses around but you feel really secluded and it’s so quiet and peaceful. Kitchen was great for cooking. Sleeping was great. Not the greatest shower but totally doable. Overall, we absolutely enjoyed our stay. The location was perfect and close to everything.

This home was absolutely Beautiful! Our family had a great time staying here. The views were stunning and had a picture-perfect view of the lake. The amenities in the home were great. The hot ube was a hit with everyone as well as the Pac Man game on the lower level. 5-star recommendations. The host was also very easy to work with and went above expectations.

Such an amazing stay at Katie’s A-frame! Favorite Airbnb to date. The location is remote (but with wifi and TV binging abilities) and silent with the most gorgeous view. Katie was responsive and quick to troubleshoot if needed. Highly recommend and can’t wait to stay again!