Vacation rentals in Cicero

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Home in Hartford City

Rustic Lake house with HOT TUB and Pool Table

Come relax in our cozy 1978 Lake House! Conveniently located between Muncie and Hartford City, 16 min. from Taylor University, 24 min. from Ball State, and 10 seconds from the dock! Enjoy the outdoors-Take out the kayaks, go fishing, enjoy the lake, soak up the sights in the hot tub, and maybe end the night with a campfire! Staying in?-Shoot some pool on the 1800's pool table, pull out a board game with the family, or just relax in the four-season sunroom while watching the sunset. Come unwind!

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 269 reviews

Seaside Style Cottage in Lovely Landlocked Indiana

Now with free Netflix! Welcome to lovely central Indiana! With family from Long Island, what could we do but go with a seaside theme? There's great amenities here - music, sports and racin'. Antiques in downtown Noblesville about a mile away. The house is 15 min from Ruoff Music Center (aka Deer Creek). It's about 45 min from downtown Indy, 20 min from Westfield Sports. The area is fairly quiet, with some traffic. My place is good for couples, adventurers, travelers, and families with kids.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Cottage in Cicero

Lake front Cottage on Morse Reservoir w/ Boat Slip

Lakefront home on Morse Lake!! Great for larger groups, Sleeps 10! Walk out Basement. Fire pit overlooking the water, private dock for fishing/swimming. Open floor plan with sliding glass doors looking out to the water, from both up and downstairs family rooms. Enjoy watching the sunset over the water, from the back 2 decks. 15 minute drive to Grand Park. Main floor Master with King Bed. Main floor Full Bathroom with tub/shower. Additional 2 Bedrooms and Bathroom with shower in basement.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

The Cozy Cottage

Enjoy a relaxing getaway in this cozy cottage. Historic Downtown Noblesville is just a short walk where you will find great restaurants, pubs, and boutique shops. The cottage consists of one bedroom, a fully equipped kitchen, and a full bathroom with walk-in shower. There’s also a fenced backyard with fire pit and furniture. The Cozy Cottage is centrally located near downtown Noblesville (2 min), Ruoff Music Center (15 min), Grand Park Sporting Complex (20 min), and over 100 miles of trails.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Guesthouse in Cicero

Adorable cottage walking distance to Morse Lake

10 minute walk to Morse Lake and sleeping 7, this fully loaded modern cottage has everything you need for convenience and fun -- full kitchen, gas grill, private outdoor space, and (with advanced notice) you can park your boat in the driveway. 5 minute walk from restaurants and charming downtown Cicero, . Downtown Noblesville, Ruoff, Grand Park and Connor Prairie are a short, 20 minute drive away. Great Central Indiana location -- 40 minutes to downtown Indy and only 30 minutes to Kokomo!

Superhost

Home in Cicero

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews

Lakehouse Oasis on Morse Reservoir—Private Getaway

The Lakehouse Oasis overlooking beautiful Morse Reservoir is perfect for families and large groups (Sleeps 14). Enjoy backyard waterfront access with a private dock to swim, fish, and boat from. Our open floor plan home has stunning waterfront views so get ready for an epic sunrise every morning! Morse reservoir is an all-sports lake with no shortage of attractions including boating, golfing, hiking, shopping, and of course dining. *Sports families we are 15 minutes away from Grand Park.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

Riverwood Rest Stop next to Ruoff & Koteewi Park

This cozy bungalow sits up in the trees and overlooks the White River. Riverwood is a small neighborhood and was established in the late 1920's as a vacation hideaway. Located only minutes from downtown shopping, Koteewi Park, Purgatory Golf Club & Ruoff Music center. Grand Park is only 20 minutes away. Toby the cat lives here and will greet you when you arrive, he has his own accommodations on the property & welcomes everyone that stays with us. He’s your personal concierge.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Home in Westfield

The Penn House 2 miles to Grand Park - Sleeps 14

The Penn House is a luxury home in the heart of Westfield perfect for the discerning traveler! All the comforts of home nestled in downtown Westfield. Walking distance to shops, restaurants, parks, the Monon Trail, and a quick five minute drive to Grand Park Sports Campus. Feel at home with an inviting front porch, large backyard with a gas grill, and fire pit for some outdoor fun. House is a few blocks from sushi, pizza, Italian, a brewery and wine bar. Perfect Location!

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 302 reviews

Private & Peaceful Stay Near Ruoff/Grand Park

Stroll through historic Noblesville Square with an abundance of restaurants and local shops all within a mile of the home. Lovely historic architecture and small town vibes all walkable from your front door! This space is also convenient whether you’re in town for a conference, visiting friends and family, travelling to Grand Park for a soccer game, or simply want a convenient place to spend the weekend as you take in the summer concerts and the charm of Hamilton County!

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Cottage in Noblesville

Water front Casita: kayaks, fishing, golf, hiking

Welcome to @WhiteRiverCasita - a cozy getaway minutes from historic downtown Noblesville and Koteewi Park - enjoy a breathtaking slide down Koteewi Run, Indianapolis’ best and only snow tubing hill! This hidden 1-bedroom, 1-bath gem features a large deck overlooking the river with comfortable furniture for dining and enjoying the outdoors. You’ll love the peaceful surroundings but there’s also plenty to do nearby, including kayaking, hiking, golfing, shopping and more.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Private Room w/ private entrance.

Comfortable and Spacious Room for One Guest. Please note that additional guests or visitors are not allowed, so kindly refrain from inquiring about bringing extra visitors. Private Bathroom & Independent Entrance: Enjoy full privacy with a dedicated entrance. Modern Amenities: Smart TV: Stream your favorite shows with your personal login details. Microwave, Coffee Maker, and Mini Refrigerator. Convenient Located in a quiet neighborhood close to shops and dining.

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Home in Arcadia

Cicero, Morse Lake / Self Check in, Wifi, Office

Charming family-friendly home in Arcadia, Indiana—just 5 minutes from Cicero Downtown and Morse Lake! This beautifully renovated 3-bedroom, 3-bathroom retreat offers comfort, space, and privacy. All bedrooms are upstairs, with a dedicated workspace for remote guests. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, outdoor patio, and thoughtful amenities throughout. Perfect for families and travelers. Ask us about seasonal discounts and book your stay today!

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Cicero vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Cicero

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Home in Fishers

Master King Suite, Game Room, 2 mi to Event Center

KristiRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Really enjoyed our stay at Amber's place. We spent mornings on the screened porch with our coffee. The location was very convenient to the wedding venue and rehearsal restaurant. We would definitely stay there again.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Home in Indianapolis

White River Retreat

TiffanyRating, 5 stars2 days ago

Max was great! Always quick to respond and super polite. His place made you feel like you aren't even in the city, yet you are minutes away from everything you could want or need!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Private room in Fishers

Room 2 - Clean and Private Bedroom in Fishers

TedRating, 5 stars3 days ago

This was a great place to stay it was extremely clean I can see that the carpet was vadoomed just moments before my arrival and everything was meticulously clean and the host was very helpful and communicated greatly. I would highly recommend for future stays

Castle in Westfield

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Wizarding World Themed Castle 8 Acres!

TaraRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

What an amazing find close to home! The kids absolutely loved all of the magical touches and felt like they were in the wizarding world! All of us agreed that we would recommend it to any Harry Potter fans!

Home in Fishers

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Stack'd at Nickel Plate

JanRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We LOVED Joe’s place! It’s unique and decorated in a clean, fresh style. He had games for us to play…which we took advantage of. He has outdoor spaces, which we could still use even though the weather wasn’t perfect! There were no unpleasant surprises at Joe’s place. It is as clean and inviting as the pictures. Joe was super easy to communicate with…always responsive. He allowed us to check in early so we could unpack before our granddaughter’s warmups…and check out late to allow us to pack after she finished her meet Sunday morning. The 3 of us are looking forward to returning next May. Can’t wait to go back!

Guest suite in Noblesville

5 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

All the comforts of home.

TaraRating, 5 stars5 days ago

A perfect spot in Noblesville. Easy parking and walkable to downtown. The space was perfect for our family of three. Richard was responsive and helpful with the check in. The book of recommendations was super helpful!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

Home in Westfield

Poppin on Poplar | Gold Guest Favorite | Sleeps 13

SteveRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

Our stay at Darin's location was spectacular! We come to Indy annually for a golf trip, and he was incredibly easy to work with. Responses were borderline immediate, and all instructions for the stay were simple & concise. I'll absolutely be trying to use his place for future events!