Vacation rentals with lake access in Buckeye Lake

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

The exterior of a coastal-modern home is visible, featuring blue siding and large windows. A spacious patio area is shown with a gas fire pit and outdoor seating. Lush greenery surrounds the property, giving a serene lakefront atmosphere.

Home in Thornville

Joyful Haven on Buckeye Lake

Welcome to a serene, stylish lakefront escape tucked inside the private, double-gated Compass Pointe on Buckeye Lake. With nearly 2,900 sqft, this custom coastal-modern retreat offers high-end finishes. Step inside to 10 ft ceilings, custom trim, and open views that invite the outside in. A sunroom and screened porch lead to a 70 ft private boardwalk. Whether you’re sipping wine at the Buckeye Lake Winery, at our gas firepit, or strolling to Fairfield beach, this place is perfect. Sleeps 14.

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

The entrance of a charming bungalow is surrounded by lush greenery, enhanced by wooden decks and soft lighting. A dark front door is framed by large windows, with a decorative wreath displayed. A cozy chair sits nearby, inviting relaxation.

Tiny home in Millersport

Bungalow on the Buckeye Lake Canal *Kayaks+Bikes*

Welcome! This unique, quaint abode is the perfect cozy getaway for 2. Tucked down in the trees along the Buckeye Lake canal, but still so close to all the fun! Relax at the shared firepit or fishing dock, paddle the kayaks provided to the marina, rent a boat to experience the beautiful lake or hop on one of our bikes to explore. So many restaurants, coffee + shops are just minutes away, with Buckeye Lake State Park and boat launch less than 1 mile away! Hope you enjoy our little nature oasis!

A welcoming entryway is highlighted by a bold blue front door. Natural light pours through the large windows, leading to an outdoor view of the waterfront. The herringbone-patterned flooring adds texture to the space, setting a warm and inviting tone for guests.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 96 reviews

Waterfront House with Private Dock on Buckeye Lake

The ultimate Lake House on the North Shore of Buckeye Lake. This newly renovated water front property is located next to the Boat Yard at Buckeye Lake and 5 min walking distance from the Buckeye Lake Yacht Club, the North Shore State Park boat launch, restaurants, bars, supermarkets and more. Enjoy this 3 bedroom home with its extensive private garden and outdoor fire pit area. The house includes a private lot for 10 cars or you can use it to park a boat. One side of the dock will be provided.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews

The exterior of the home features a newly remodeled design with a blue and gray façade. A gravel driveway accommodates parking for up to three cars. A fenced backyard is visible in the background, providing a private outdoor space.

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

Anchors Away - Relaxing Cottage Minutes from Lake

Newly remodeled home just a short walk to the Lake, Bars & Restaurants! 2 bedrooms & 2.5 bathrooms with a cozy nautical design. Fully stocked kitchen and spacious living room are perfect for vacationing with family! Additional amenities included for our guests are: 3 Bikes, Yard Games, Firepit, Propane Grill & Board Games We can accommodate a MAX of 3 Cars and no street parking available. All Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinances #2022-36/#2023-27

A bright and welcoming dining area is presented with a spacious table for six, surrounded by light-colored chairs. The adjoining living space features a comfortable couch, and windows allow natural light to fill the room, enhancing the overall warmth.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Crane House

Enjoy this lakeside escape at Buckeye Lake! This charming 4BR home boasts modern amenities, serene lake views, and a deck -- all within walking distance of local restaurants and bars, Crane Lake Beach, North Shore Boat Ramp, and the walking and biking trail. Step inside to find a spacious residence meticulously designed for relaxation and entertainment. The house proudly features four generously sized bedrooms and two bathrooms. It's the perfect retreat for a getaway with family or friends.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

A small boat is seen on the water with two people onboard, enjoying a day of leisure. Lush greenery outlines the shoreline, with trees and cottages in the background adding to the serene lakeside environment.

Cottage in Buckeye Lake

Buckeye Lake Cottage

Whether you love boating, fishing, kayaking, catching a concert at Legend Valley, or watching drag races at National Trails Speedway—or simply relaxing and spending time with family—this is your perfect home away from home. Located just half a mile from Buckeye Lake, the cottage offers easy access to the water as well as a variety of local favorites, including lakefront restaurants, breweries, and some of the best pizza spots around—all just a short ride away on our six-seater golf cart.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

A spacious house with a modern design is surrounded by lush greenery. Large windows provide ample natural light, while a covered porch area is visible. The property features a well-maintained lawn and a short walkway leading to the entrance, creating an inviting outdoor space.

Home in Millersport

Your home away from home on Buckeye Lake!

Amazing sunrises to sunsets in this gorgeous waterfront beauty! Offering 5 spacious bedrooms, 3.5 baths. Roomy living spaces offering multiple TVs and reading nooks. Chefs kitchen offers stainless appliances, amazing oven and stove to cook family meals. Bring your boat or rent one close by. There is a brand new dock with lift as well as Lilly pad for your wave runner. Fish and swim from the dock! Rent bikes and kayaks or bring your own! Much to do here and endless days and nights of fun!

The modern ranch-style home showcases a sleek exterior with a combination of white siding and dark green accents. A welcoming entrance is highlighted by large windows and a metal roof. A manicured lawn surrounds the home, enhancing its inviting curb appeal.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

New Home - "See More" at the lake

New home just blocks from the North Shore State Park and boat launch. A short walk to some of the best restaurants, bars and views on the lake. Modern design, comfortable 3 bedroom home with ample dining space and fully stocked kitchen. Offering a nice backyard for a game of cornhole or outdoor dining. Ranch style home makes this property easily accessible for unpacking and relaxing. Enjoy time around the lake, on the water, or biking the 4 mile path along the north shore.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

The exterior of a single-story home is depicted with light-colored siding and a gray roof. Two seating chairs are positioned on the front porch, accompanied by a small planter on either side. A flag pole displays an American flag, and lush trees provide a natural backdrop.

Cottage in Thornville

Buckeye Lake Retreat

A great place for families and fishermen Beautiful home right on the channel and direct access to the lake. Excellent for fishing, catching catfish right from the dock. It's an excellent place to relax and unwind. Fish directly off the dock or use the Kayaks included to explore the lake. We have an extra-long dock that can accommodate your boat(s). Fully equipped kitchen, your own washer and dryer, and a gas grill. There is a fire pit for the nights you want a campfire.

Superhost

The kitchen features warm wooden cabinetry and modern stainless steel appliances. A stainless steel dishwasher, an oven, and a microwave are included. Natural light streams in through a window above the sink, illuminating the granite countertops and backsplash.

Vacation home in Buckeye Lake

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 96 reviews

Cheerful 3-bed vacay home w/free car &boat parking

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space, just a short walk from the lake. At the Buckeye Bungalow, there's something for everyone! You can enjoy taking a dip in the lake, or spend the afternoon at the beach or water's edge fishing or relaxing. Or, for a more active vacation, there is water skiing, hiking, and kayaking or paddle-boarding around the lake. Take advantage of the beautiful bike/jogging trails, and 4+ miles of wonderful views around the lake.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 165 reviews

A dining area features a light-colored wooden table surrounded by four woven chairs. Plates and utensils are arranged neatly at each seat. In the background, a cozy sleeping area is visible, highlighted by warm wood-paneled walls and soft natural lighting from a nearby window.

Cabin in Buckeye Lake

Little Red Cabin @ Buckeye Lake with Hot Tub

Make some memories at this unique and family-friendly cabin with a cozy modern feel. The home is located just a few blocks from the Buckeye Lake park, bike path, boat ramp and plenty of fantastic restaurants. The home includes a fully functioning kitchen, dining area, large living room, indoor wood burning fire place, outdoor fire pit, grill, outdoor seating area and a new hot tub recently added! There is also plenty of parking available in the rear of the home.

A collection of framed photographs is displayed on a white shiplap wall, showcasing scenes from local history. A decorative fishing net drapes above, complemented by colorful buoys. This wall art adds a coastal charm to the space.