Lake house vacation rentals in Buckeye Lake

An aerial view captures the lakeside property set amidst lush greenery. The serene lake reflects the surrounding homes, with visible boat docks and a road curving along the shoreline. The marked location highlights the retreat's proximity to both nature and the vibrant community.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Crane House

Enjoy this lakeside escape at Buckeye Lake! This charming 4BR home boasts modern amenities, serene lake views, and a deck all within walking distance of local restaurants and bars, Crane Lake Beach, North Shore Boat Ramp, and the walking and biking trail. Step inside to find a spacious residence designed for relaxation and entertainment. The house features four generously sized bedrooms and two bathrooms. It's the perfect retreat for a getaway with family or friends. Boat dock available to rent!

ValueFamilyNearby

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Lakefront 6BR w/ Heated Pool, Fire-pit & Boat Slip

Escape to lakeside luxury on Buckeye Lake at this 3,400 sq ft, three-story retreat in a quiet lake front setting just ~40 minutes east of Columbus. With six bedrooms, a heated salt-water pool (open April 24 – Oct 31 starting 2026), a private boat slip, multiple decks and balconies, lakefront fire-pit seating and a chef’s kitchen, this home is perfect for families, friends and multi-generational get-togethers. Hosted by Stupendous Stays. Stupendous Stays is a local family run hospitality company.

FamilyLocationNearby

The living area features a comfortable seating arrangement, including a gray sofa and tan armchairs. A coffee table sits on a patterned rug, with natural light streaming in through large windows. A television is mounted on the wall, enhancing the welcoming space.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 80 reviews

Edgewater Escape

Welcome to our tranquil haven at Buckeye Lake, Edgewater Escape, where the gentle lapping of the lake and stunning views create the perfect backdrop for your getaway. Bring your boat or rent one from Freedom Watersports! This newly renovated home, with its open floor plan and stylish comforts, offers an unparalleled lakeside experience. You can savor the best of Ohio’s vineyards and craft beers. The property is just minutes away from local restaurants and entertainment. Host is licensed Realtor

ValueLocationBathroom

A modern building featuring a white exterior with wooden accents and large windows. An outdoor seating area is surrounded by neatly arranged evergreen shrubs, with several adirondack chairs positioned around a central fire pit, creating a welcoming space for gatherings.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

The Wharf at Buckeye Lake W/Boat Slip

Have fun with the whole family at this stylish place. This property is located just a short walk to the most premier lakefront dining and nightlife Buckeye lake has to offer, and includes a Boat slip/dock at the local restaurant/Bar Papa Boos. Papa boos has a Marina store for boating essentials including fuel. The house also features an oversized garage for recreation with a pool and ping pong table. Boasting plenty of interior space for you and your family. Come enjoy a stress free retreat!

ValueLocationView

A modern open-plan living area features sleek cabinetry and stainless steel appliances in the kitchen, with a comfortable black sofa and a decorative area rug in the foreground. Bright overhead lights and natural light from the windows enhance the inviting atmosphere.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Lake Goals

Newly renovated 2 bedroom, 1 bath home located within walking distance from restaurants, bars, stores and best of all Buckeye Lake. Whether you want to cook in or go out for dinner both options are here for your relaxation and pleasure. Relaxing interior will take the stress away and keep you entertained all at once. From September 1st till March 31st are on a seasonal discount. Please come join us! Short-Term Rentals in the Village of Buckeye Lake are governed under Ordinance #2024-22.

LocationFamilyParks

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Home in Millersport

The Heron House | Peaceful Lakeside Retreat

Welcome to your modern Buckeye Lake retreat! This brand-new 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home with a bonus room offers the perfect blend of luxury, comfort, and convenience. Completed in 2025, this home features high-end finishes, an open-concept layout, and a bright, stylish design that feels like a true getaway. Located in the heart of Millersport, you're just a short walk from the marina, Weldons Ice Cream, and all the fun of the Millersport Corn Festival. Perfect for a weekend or long stay!

FamilyLocationWalkability

The modern ranch-style home showcases a sleek exterior with a combination of white siding and dark green accents. A welcoming entrance is highlighted by large windows and a metal roof. A manicured lawn surrounds the home, enhancing its inviting curb appeal.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

New Home - "See More" at the lake

New home just blocks from the North Shore State Park and boat launch. A short walk to some of the best restaurants, bars and views on the lake. Modern design, comfortable 3 bedroom home with ample dining space and fully stocked kitchen. Offering a nice backyard for a game of cornhole or outdoor dining. Ranch style home makes this property easily accessible for unpacking and relaxing. Enjoy time around the lake, on the water, or biking the 4 mile path along the north shore.

FamilyLocationAir conditioning

The exterior of a single-story cottage is shown, featuring a small patio area with two white chairs on a grassy lawn. A gas grill sits nearby, while a blue front door enhances the inviting appearance. A flag is displayed, and a wooden fence borders the yard.

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Eagle's Nest Lake Cottage

Welcome to the Eagle’s Nest Lake Cottage! This private and quiet location offers up some amazing views, lots of wildlife, water access, natural shade from mature water Maple trees and a large boat dock! Perfect for fishing or bringing your pontoon. The cottage is the perfect place to come unwind from all the stresses of life! Everything is better at the Lake! This waterfront lake cottage on Buckeye Lake is situated on a private channel with main lake views.

LocationFamilyRiver

An outdoor deck is illuminated by soft string lights, featuring several black rocking chairs and a picnic table. The house's exterior is framed by white siding and dark shutters, surrounded by a grassy lawn and trees in the background.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Charming House W Boat Dock Avail

This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom lake house is the perfect destination for your next getaway. Inside the house, you'll discover a cozy interior and a full equipped kitchen. Step out onto the front deck, a spacious area that's perfect for drinking morning coffee. Just off the deck is a fire pit for memorable evenings with your friends. Our place truly gives you unbelievable privacy yet it's close to everything. Boat Dock available for rent.

LocationFamilyGetting around

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Buckeye Lake Getaway | Game Room, Patio & 2.5 Bath

Welcome to your Buckeye Lake Getaway! Just minutes from fishing, boating, restaurants, and nightlife, this newly renovated 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is perfect for families and groups. Enjoy modern finishes, all-new appliances, a fully equipped kitchen, washer and dryer, outdoor grill, and game room. Relax or explore the lake—you're just a 3-minute walk to the public park and boat launch, where you can conveniently launch and park your boat.

ValueLocationKitchen

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Lilypad B, Perfect Location!

Location is everything in this rental! The bike path stretching along the highlights of Buckeye Lake is right outside the home. You can walk or bike to many restaurants, bars, coffee shops and just a couple minutes walk from the lake. Sleeping 9, this unit is part of a triplex in which you can rent other units to accommodate even more family and friends!! Perfect for a family reunion, gathering of friends, etc. Look for Lilypad A, B & C.

FamilyLocationParking