Cottage vacation rentals in Brookhaven

Louise's place was perfect. Louise was so easy to communicate with, super responsive, kind, thoughtful and truly appreciated that she had the option of flexible dates (instead of so many sat to sat or sun to sun requirements in summer). The cottage was cozy, cute, spotless & well stocked. My teenage kids loved the hot tub (as it was a bit chilly in the evenings) and I loved the outdoor shower. We loved having the bikes to take rides around the Island and loved the location. Our only regret is that we didn't get to stay there longer! We will definitely try to stay at Old Snuggler again!

I had a wonderful weekend at Andrew’s place in East Hampton. It was gorgeous, perfect location, perfect layout, and such a central location to everything. It was incredibly clean and organized and the backyard was beautiful for relaxing. Andrew was also a terrific host- he left us beverages, was super communicative and flexible and I’m so happy I stayed here. Hopefully I’ll rent again soon!!

Tabitha's place was perfect for our group stay. Right in the middle of town and perfect for what we needed for the week!

beautiful house, great location and very nice and peaceful neighborhood close to the beach and the vineyards the house is very well equipped ! Richard was very nice and even find a little bed for our baby boy ! thanks !

Ivana and John are the most wonderful hosts! This was truly like staying at a family cottage and everything was just beautiful. John greeted us upon arrival and even had a bottle of wine for my husbands birthday! We loved staying here from the city because it was only a little over a hour to arrive and less than a hour to South Hampton where we had dinner. Also the little town is so so cute and we were able to walk over so quickly! We can’t wait to stay here again. Thank you again Ivana and John!

Lil Nauti was perfect for our family. The bedrooms were adequate, with very comfortable beds and plenty of pillows. The wardrobe space and drawers were great as we had a long stay with a lot of baggage! Jason has absolutely everything you could possibly want or need for a stay. The kitchen is really well equipped. Cute cottage and delightful private garden.

We had a truly wonderful stay at this charming old house. It’s full of character, beautifully maintained, and well-equipped with everything we needed. One of the highlights was the private yard — perfect for enjoying a quiet morning coffee or relaxing under the stars in the evening. The host was exceptionally kind and helpful, always quick to respond and full of thoughtful local recommendations. Thanks to them, we discovered a few amazing winery with surprisingly good wine and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. This was a peaceful and authentic experience — perfect for anyone looking to slow down and enjoy the local charm. Highly recommended!

We had a great stay! The house was pristine and the kitchen was very well stocked. The cottage was very close to beaches, restaurants and grocery stores! I would definitely recommend to anyone looking to get away for a beach vacation!

Staying at Fabiola's was a dream. This place is very homey and welcoming. We had a lovely stay for Christmas with family, walking to the beach in the morning and cozying up around the fire in the evening. The kitchen is well stocked for cooking, the beds were comfortable, and our dog loved the fenced in yard. Would love to stay again.

What a fabulous cottage and something totally new to us! Beach very close by obviously and the pet friendly gated on porch convenient!Thank you Michelle to share your place with us!

We had a great experience staying at Melissa’s cottage and would happily recommend it to anyone else! We were in town from Florida visiting family in Rocky Point for Christmas and chose Melissa’s property as our place to stay. Melissa was very communicative, check in was super easy and we felt right at home on her property. Would definitely consider staying here again. Thanks Melissa!

Jim’s place was an absolute gem for my inaugural trip to Black Rock! The Loft is incredibly spacious and equipped with everything you could possibly need for a perfect stay. From the moment I arrived, I was impressed by the meticulous cleanliness, attention to detail, and beautiful furnishings. Jim's communication was top-notch, making the entire experience seamless. One of the highlights was the extensive music collection, perfect for setting the mood during my downtime. The bed and furniture provided a level of comfort that made it hard to leave. Nestled on a serene, tree-lined street, the location couldn’t be better; it’s just a leisurely stroll away from delightful restaurants, charming shops, food markets, and more. I can’t wait to return for another stay whenever I’m in the area!

We had a fabulous weekend at this lovely cottage. Located on a remote peninsula surrounded by the glistening water we couldn’t have asked for a nicer experience. The amenities were both convenient and thoughtful. Although we chose to dine out, the kitchen was very modern with upscale appliances and an espresso machine. We did bbq on our last night and had a great end to our 4 night stay!

One of the best air bnbs we’ve had the pleasure of staying. Was even more comfortable, spacious and well appointed than the photos portray. Walking distance to the three villages historic museum and so close to port Jeff and the university. Everything we needed and more, and Lise was incredibly thoughtful and accommodating. Stayed with two small dogs , so easy. Love this historic home!

Great place for a long weekend. Plenty of spots within walking distance and the beach was perfect

Wonderful place to stay with everything you need for a fire island getaway! Was very responsive and helpful with any questions we had. I always look forward to staying at this house!

I grew up near here so I know just how magical it is. It did not disappoint with its beauty of LI sound. I also live in a cottage up the north end, and embrace all things others might seem quirky…. We loved them!! Amazing place!!

The cottage is as pictured. Very clean with everything I needed. The area is beautiful for walking on the beach or the streets around the cottage. WiFi was strong throughout the cabin for working. Thanks Bert for your attention and listing this cottage.

The beach house was great. Instead of being on a road, it was on a green commons area that gave it a really relaxed neighborly feel. It was a very easy and pleasant 1 minute stroll to the beach, where was a great pastry and shop, and restaurant, and some simply amazing views. Deb's communications were also great and check in went amazingly smoothly. Also the town of New Suffolk itself is quite charming, and is a perfect base for exploring vineyards, beaches, hiking trails and whatnot.

Erin’s place was perfect! We did a girls trip to fire island over memorial day weekend, it was the perfect size for 3 of us. Erin’s place was situated about a 30 min walk from the Ocean Beach, and super easy to get to from the Ocean Bay Park (I think?) Ferry Station, so it was super easy to get to. We had such a lovely weekend exploring the island, and could easily get to other parts of the island (i.e. Cherry Grove) by Water Taxi. Erin was extremely helpful with navigation guidance. We would definitely come back again!

We had a great stay at Jonathan's cottage. The location could not be beat - right on the beach. Jonathan was very easy to communicate with and quick to respond. There were a couple of minor hiccups that occurred but Jonathan was quick and responsive. Overall, a beautiful home in a great location.

Deb’s place was very peaceful, comfortable, and well appointed. We immediately felt at home and enjoyed the interesting decor and personal style. It felt like staying in your own bed and breakfast. There were so many places to relax, and the front and back porches were so welcoming. The location can’t be beat if you want to check out the local wineries, farmstands, and great restaurants. An easy walk across the street to Peconic Bay, you can see from the upstairs bedroom. Kitchen was well appointed with everything you would need for cooking. Short ride to markets, farmstands, and Love Lane for shops and restaurants, about 20 minutes to Greenport.

Erin Leigh’s cottage was everything we hoped for and more. She was proactive, responsive, and kind from the start — making sure everything was smooth before and during our stay. The setting is peaceful, cozy, and thoughtfully designed, with unique touches throughout the home. It was the perfect base for exploring both the eastern and western sides of the North Fork — whether by bike or by car. We loved how close it was to town, beaches, and vineyards, yet still felt tucked away and relaxing. Truly a gem. Highly recommend!