Vacation rentals with lake access in Allegany County

Find and book unique lake access rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated lake access rentals in Allegany County

Guests agree: these lake access rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A view of the cottage from the grassy hillside, showcasing its wooden exterior and metal roof. A picnic area with benches is visible by the water's edge, surrounded by trees, with a path leading down to the lake. The tranquil setting emphasizes nature's beauty.

Cottage in Belfast

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

The Samrose Lake Cottage

This vintage cottage is nestled in the peaceful hills of Allegany County and Amish Country. This charming waters-edge cottage is on a small lake. Motor boats not allowed, making it a peaceful destination that allows you to enjoy all that nature has to offer. It has a two level deck facing the lake where you can experience gorgeous sunsets. Perfect for Canoeing, kayaking and fishing. Peddle boat and SUP on premises. Lots of shops nearby or hiking on the Genesee Greenway Trail. Come be our guest!

Top guest favorite

A lakeside cottage features a combination of painted wood siding in muted colors. The structure is framed by lush trees, with a gentle slope leading to the water. A covered boat dock is seen to the right, all of which is reflected in the calm lake surface.

Cottage in Cuba

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

This is 40

This is 40. Cuba Lake cottage with unbeatable views and direct lake access. Make wonderful family memories year round in this classic home. Built as a simple fishing and summer vacation space, it's been updated to serve today's families with comfortable bedding and furniture, LED dimmable lighting with USB ports throughout , a brand new dishwasher and a 55" smart TV. Three good sized bedrooms and a brand new pull out sofa bed mean that the whole family can enjoy this cozy cottage on the lake.

Guest favorite

Chalet in Belfast

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 79 reviews

Chalet in the trees

Leave the world behind and be 1 with nature in comfort and style! This beautiful chalet sits on 100-acres! Relax by a bonfire, stargaze, enjoy coffee on the porch, birdwatch, fish, swim, enjoy kayaks, peddle boat, flat bottom boat or explore the walking trails. Next to 2,000 acres of State Forest, 30 min to Letchworth State Park, 10 minutes to Angelica, 40 min to Ellicottville, 30 min to Swain Skii Resort, 30 minutes to Tall Pines ATV park and 10 min to Rushford Lake! So much to do and enjoy!

Top guest favorite

The charming lake house features a welcoming porch with a white railing, surrounded by lush greenery and colorful landscaping. Steps lead up from the well-maintained lawn to the entrance, framed by trees that create a serene atmosphere.

Home in Cuba

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

North Shore Lighthouse Charmer

Relax and unwind in this charming lake house on the desirable North Shore. Living space is open and airy with large windows that frame breathtaking views of the lake. Features a fully-equipped modern kitchen. Bedrooms that are thoughtfully appointed with plush bedding. Wake up and enjoy fishing off the dock, cocktails on the large deck as you watch the sunset over the water, and gather around the fire pit in the evening for s'mores. This property offers the perfect setting for your vacation.

Guest favorite

Home in Caneadea

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Sunset Cottage Oasis. Lakefront w/ Private dock!

Relax with the whole family at Sunset cottage! Our charming cottage has 3 beds and 1 bath. You will enjoy DIRECT RUSHFORD LAKE FRONTAGE and have access to the dock where you can fish, tie up a boat or take a swim in beautiful Lake Rushford. You will enjoy watching the lake come alive in the morning with a cup of coffee, or a nice glass of wine for a direct view of the sunset over the lake in the evening. Enough lawn space to play any game imaginable and easy access down to the lake.

Guest favorite

Cabin in Caneadea

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Indian Lodge on Rushford Lake

Stay in a very unique original log cabin on Rushford Lake. Built in 1939 by Sanford Hubbard as originally 1 of 30 Arts & Crafts cabins on the lake. The cabin has been lovingly restored, and will be a very unique experience. Keep in mind this is a cabin, so there are some “rustic” qualities. This cabin is lake front, with new stairs leading down to the shoreline and dock. Kayaks and paddle boards are available for your use. This is a great place to make family memories!

A spacious deck is featured with a private hot tub surrounded by scenic views of Cuba Lake. String lights hang above, offering a welcoming atmosphere. A picnic table is visible, and the nearby shoreline adds to the area’s tranquil setting.

Home in Cuba

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Cozy Lakeview Cottage w/ Hot Tub

Cozy cottage overlooking Cuba Lake with beautiful lake views, a private hot tub on the deck, and a fire pit for relaxing evenings. Just a short drive to Ellicottville and Holiday Valley Ski Resort. In the winter, enjoy skiing, snowmobiling, and ice fishing. In the summer, take advantage of lake activities like boating, jet skiing, and swimming. Extra parking available for a boat or trailer. A peaceful, all-season getaway with rustic comfort and plenty to explore nearby.

Guest favorite

A rustic cabin is nestled among tall trees in a lush green landscape. Sunlight filters through the foliage, casting gentle shadows on the grass. A picnic table is visible nearby, creating a serene outdoor gathering space.

Cabin in Belfast

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Rustic River Cabin | Sleeps 8 | Letchworth Falls

Welcome to Over The River Through The Woods Rustic Cabin #1, your tranquil riverside retreat in Belfast, NY! This off-grid studio cabin, handcrafted by local Amish artisans, offers a serene escape for up to 8 guests. Nestled just 500 feet from the Genesee River, this peaceful getaway is perfect for families and nature lovers seeking to unplug and reconnect with the great outdoors. ⭑CONTACT US FOR SEASONAL DISCOUNTS⭑

A white, single-story house is set against a backdrop of tall trees and green grass. Blue lounge chairs are arranged on a patio, alongside a charcoal grill. Windows adorned with dark green shutters provide natural light to the interior, with flower boxes adding a touch of color.

Cottage in Cuba

5 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Charming Lake House

The house is situated on the north shore of Cuba Lake. Summer activities include fishing, swimming, paddle boarding, and kayaking. In the winter enjoy ice fishing, access to snowmobile trails, x-country skiing. Minutes from Seneca casino, 30 minutes to Holiday Valley/Ellicottville and Letchworth state park. The town has many stores and restaurants. Wonderful lake access for both summer and winter fun!

A partial view of the property is captured under a canopy of evergreen trees, with glimpses of Cuba Lake visible in the background. The tranquil water reflects the sky, while the surrounding greenery adds a serene touch to the setting.

Home in Cuba

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Lake View Guest House

While not directly on the lake, this idyllic, lake view, pet friendly property is just across the lake road with a commanding view of Cuba Lake. Conveniently located within easy walking distance to Cuba Lake Marina, Carpies restaurant (less than 5 minutes walking), yacht club, and public boat put-in (.7 miles). There is plentiful parking in a circular driveway for all of your cars, boats and toys.

A spacious dock area is shown with multiple seating options, including a mix of cushioned and wooden chairs arranged to face the water. The calm lake is visible in the background, framed by a lush green hillside. The outdoor space invites relaxation with scenic views.

Cottage in Cuba

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Beautiful lakefront 4-bedroom cottage

Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun. Beautiful great room with lake views that opens to an outdoor entertainment area steps from the lake! Three docks provide lake access and an open yard leaves plenty of space to enjoy the outdoors. Close to Ellicotville, Holiday Valley Ski Resort, Letchworth State Park, and so much more!