Places to stay in West Milford

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

A cozy living area showcases a dark sectional sofa, complemented by decorative pillows. Natural light filters through two windows with simple curtains. A wooden barn door adds charm, leading to a workspace furnished with a wooden desk and chair.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 189 reviews

Cozy home in the Village of Greenwood Lake

Adorable country retreat under an hour from NYC - perfect for a romantic couples getaway or a family of 4. Located in the village, our quaint cottage is walkable to everything; Restaurants, bars, grocer, cvs, bagels, bus stop and even the public beach!! Minutes away from TONS of local attractions; drive-in, skiing, renaissance fair, wineries, shopping, lake activities, orchards, creameries, parks, Appalachian trail, spa, rafting, golf, water park, & so much more. Pets welcome! Permit #21-07603

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

A designated coffee station is displayed, featuring a turquoise coffee maker and a matching toaster. A sign labeled 'COFFEE' is positioned beside them, along with a colorful patterned fabric covering the wooden table surface.

Cabin in Vernon Township

Mountain Creek Views Guest Suite

Guest suite/private side entry. Host lives upstairs. If you would like to have the host absent, there is a fee of $40 per night. Escape to our modern mountain retreat with breathtaking views and easy access to outdoor adventures - 2min to the Appalachian Trail - 8min to Mountain Creek - 10min to Warwick drive-in movie theatre - Hiking trails all over And when you're ready to relax, you'll have a comfortable and inviting space to call home. We take pride in providing exceptional hospitality.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

An open living and kitchen area features a spacious couch and a wooden coffee table centered on a round area rug. Modern kitchen appliances and bar stools are visible at the counter, while natural light streams in through the skylights and windows, illuminating the warm wooden floors.

Home in Greenwood Lake

Aster Place

A beautiful and cozy home nestled in the Forest Hills section of Greenwood Lake, just over an hour outside of New York City. Boasting nearby activities in each season, including wineries, skiing and lake activities, this is a perfect year-round retreat. located 1/2 mile from our quiet community beach allows for a serene daily chill by the water. Town center is a short drive away, or 15 minutes from all that Warwick has to offer, you will enjoy this perfect setting for your lakeside getaway!

The kitchen features a wooden island with a quartz countertop, surrounded by stainless steel appliances. A large window allows natural light to enter, illuminating the modern cabinetry and sleek finishes. The wooden accents create a warm yet contemporary environment.

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 226 reviews

Get some R&R at the Rustic Retreat!

The Rustic Retreat is centrally located, 2 bedroom 1 bath cozy cottage is just what you've been looking for in this lake community. There is a 3-6 car driveway, newly renovated kitchen, open floor plan in the dining & living room, new shed bar/ fire pit, & sleeps 7 (Q in Master, F Sofa Bed Couch, T Bunk Beds, F Air Mattress). Located about 3 mins from Greenwood Lake and 10 mins from Warwick, many activities for your perfect getaway! IG @Rusticretreat22 Short Term Rental Permit # 21-0422

Cottage in Vernon Township

A fire pit surrounded by arranged stones is featured in the foreground, with flames dancing above a bed of logs. Tall trees create a natural frame, while a glimpse of the lake is visible through the foliage in the background, illuminated by soft evening light.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Rustic Chic Lake view cottage 50 miles from NYC

Cozy lake view cottage 50 miles from NYC. Nestled in nature with swimming, fishing , hiking and biking with beautiful lake views. 5 beaches to choose from. Lovely walking or jogging around the lake, Appalachian trail nearby. Highland Lakes is a very scenic, peaceful area easily accessible. 3 of the best golf courses in the US , Mountain Creek water park and resort minutes away.Apple and pumpkin picking comes fall. Beautiful village of Warwick NY is nearby with restaurants and shopping .

Cottage in Greenwood Lake

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 344 reviews

Luxury Cottage with Spectacular Lake Views

Ultra Chic Cottage set high above Greenwood Lake with Private beach and lake front community access. Minutes away from Mountain Creek Ski Resort, Spa & Water park, Mt. Peter Ski & Tubing, Warwick creameries, breweries & vineyards & apple picking. 1 BR, 1 Bath, play/office/common room. Huge wrap around fenced in deck with Mid century modern fireplace allows for scenic dining, lounging and around the fire gatherings. #LakeViewCottage_GWL Town of Warwick Short Term Rental Permit #33593

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 322 reviews

A spacious bathroom is showcased, featuring a claw foot tub with an elegant chrome faucet. A modern glass shower enclosure is visible, along with a wooden vanity and mirror. The floor displays a patterned tile design, and the walls are painted in calming shades of blue.

Guest suite in Chester

Adorable Guest Apartment in Victorian Mansion

This lovely 3rd floor private apartment is in an 1883 Victorian Mansion in Blooming Grove, NY for 1 - 6 people. It is beautifully furnished, has luxurious beds, so let us know if you need one, two or three bedrooms! The apartment has a private entrance, a claw foot tub, French door shower, and a kitchenette with sunny breakfast nook. It's freshly renovated and spacious. You will have to take 2 staircases. Our land has a nice view of a field of wildflowers, and our neighbor has cows.

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

The Greenwood Lake A-Frame: Perfect Lakefront View

Escape to a hip and cozy A-Frame cottage nestled right on Greenwood Lake, NY. Just over an hour drive from New York City, soak in the serene lake view, the quiet, and this unique retro modern A-Frame space. Perfect for a romantic couple’s getaway! Kick back and relax, listen to some tunes, read a great book, write your novel, sip your coffee, get creative, do some yoga stretches and enjoy time away from your day-to-day. Easy access to nearby beach, hikes, skiing. STR Permit # 33549

Top guest favorite

A vibrant piece of artwork featuring sunflowers hangs above a wooden table. An orange juicer, a blue teapot, a navy kettle, and a white bowl of oranges are neatly arranged, showcasing a mix of colors and textures.

Apartment in Warwick

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 396 reviews

Warwick Village Apt w Off St Parking

2 minutes to Warwick Village Farmers Market Our lovely apartment has earned 5 star reviews from over 300 guests. You'll love this private suite w private entrance Large kitchen, bedroom & stunning sun room loaded with plants Loved by gardeners, bicyclists, runners, artists, writers, diners, & shoppers. Visit Brew Pubs & Wineries, Woodbury Common, West Point, Catskills, Mt Peter, Mountain Creek, Heated bathroom floor & large shower Beautiful gas stove 300 MBPS Washer & dryer

Top guest favorite

A lakeside deck is showcased with several lounge chairs arranged for relaxation. Light red chairs contrast with the wooden deck, leading to a calm lake view surrounded by trees. A ladder is visible, providing access to the water, enhancing the serene lakeside atmosphere.

Home in West Milford

5 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Lakefront, Indoor Hot Tub, Snow Sports, 1 hr NYC

Escape to a truly unique private lake getaway located just 1 hour from New York City, and just minutes from dozens of attractions, activities, and restaurants. Zen Xcape is a recently renovated lakehouse retreat located atop a mountain in Northern New Jersey that has the rustic charm of a contemporary American lake house, the simple elegance of an Asian inspired spa, and the stylish flair of a New York City loft. Township of West Milford STR Permit LIC. NO. 2023-035

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 297 reviews

A family stands outdoors near a horse-drawn carriage. Two adults and two children are present, with the adult holding a child. The background features brick buildings and shop signage, adding to the lively street atmosphere.

Guest suite in Warwick

Suite on Longhouse Creek

Beautiful one bedroom private suite with comfy queen size bed. The suite includes a sitting room, overlooking the creek, full bath, coffee nook with small refrigerator, microwave and Keurig coffee maker. Coffee is provided. A spiral stair leads you to the private deck with a french door entrance. Enjoy your coffee sitting at the lovely bistro set overlooking the longhouse creek. Feel free to use yard seating by the creek. Town Permit # 33316

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 146 reviews

A spacious Jacuzzi is positioned beside a large window, offering unobstructed views of the lake and surrounding greenery. Natural light fills the room through the open window, while the relaxing atmosphere is complemented by the serene water scenery.

Home in West Milford

Large family house on the lake

Spacious, beautiful, and entertaining lakehouse with stunning views of the lake and mountain. It is ideal for a large family but also warm for a couple. Situated on a road-accessible island in the gorgeous Upper Greenwood Lake, this lakehouse offers a private retreat to enjoy nature and quality time with family and friends. Fun relax in both summer and winter at only 1 hr from NYC. West Milford Lic No. 2024-008.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Houses

A space thats all yours, with room for everyone

Cabins

Kick off your hiking boots at these rustic lodgings

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Popular amenities for West Milford places to stay

Self check-in

Gym

BBQ grill

Laptop-friendly workspace

Wifi

Other great vacation rentals in West Milford

Apartment in Vernon Township

An aerial view of a spacious living area is shown, featuring a large sectional sofa and a TV unit. Natural light streams through the skylights and large windows. A dining table with chairs is set nearby, with sliding doors leading to an outdoor deck.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Breathtaking view’s condo

Top guest favorite

Apartment in Vernon Township

5 out of 5 average rating, 40 reviews

Top Floor Appalachian/Minerals DayPass Available

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

A cozy seating area is positioned next to large glass doors, showcasing views of Greenwood Lake. A comfortable blue cushion rests on a red bench, with natural light illuminating the space. The wooden deck outside provides additional outdoor living space.

Cottage in West Milford

Perfect Couple's Getaway! Stunning views of Lake!

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

A gravel fire pit area is surrounded by six Adirondack chairs, providing a comfortable gathering space. The warm glow of the fire casts a welcoming light, creating an inviting atmosphere for evening conversations under the open sky.

Home in Vernon Township

Cozy Highland Lakes Getaway

A minimalist entryway is presented, featuring a black-framed glass door leading to a well-lit living space. A simple bench with a light-colored cushion is positioned against the wall, alongside a tall potted plant. Natural wood accents are noted in the ceiling and flooring.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 90 reviews

Modern Nordic Designed Cabin

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

A charming gray cottage with white shutters is framed by a lush green lawn. Bright yellow daffodils and pink hyacinths bloom in the foreground. The front porch features two yellow chairs, and a rustic wooden wheel adds character to the garden.

Home in Bangor

The Bangor Bungalow - Simple living charm

A cozy living area features wooden walls and skylights that provide ample natural light. A curved, light-colored sofa is complemented by small side tables, while a stone fireplace serves as a focal point. Decorative elements include a vibrant armchair and soft textiles, creating a comfortable ambiance.

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Designer Cabin 50 Miles N of NYC