Waterfront vacation rentals in Treasure Cay

Super nice place to stay.

Our family had the best time staying here in Treasure Cay! The condo was adorable and very clean and stocked with everything we needed. The dock slip was perfect for our boat. We loved walking across the street to Bahama Beach Club and even played pickleball on the nearby courts. All of the neighbors were super friendly as well. We can’t wait to stay again on our next trip!

This place has a great location. Walking distance from the cultural park and it overlooks the water. It was extremely clean with lots of space.

Great place to tour around with awesome views. Coco Bay was spectacular with Turtles, Rays daily as well as boat dock to utilize made it very handy. Locals were very welcoming and accommodating. We will be back!

Fantastic spot and location! The bay is literally steps away from the home. I would recommend the space for anyone looking for a relaxing place to rest with a full kitchen and a beautiful beach. Ps: walk to the dock at night, the stargazing is amazing!

Samuel’s place was perfect for me. Away from the town, tucked away in a tranquil neighborhood with beach access within walking distance. Since it’s not in the town, and because of the damage from the hurricane, make sure to stop at one of the grocery stores in Marsh Harbor before going to the AirBnB. Decaffeinated coffee and basic food seasonings were complimentary. Cutlery and cookware present. Very clean and the furniture was comfortable. The photos didn’t do it justice. I look forward to staying there again.

Tina's place is affordable and convenient. I booked a last min stay and was lucky enough to reserve this gem.

This place is amazing. Perfect for a few days in the abacos especially if you have a boat. The house was amazing and everyone on the island was so friendly. Molly is a great host and would always answer for anything we needed. I will definitely be staying here again and would recommend it to everyone looking to get over to the abacos.

We really enjoyed our stay. Not only did it meet our expectations, it exceeded. Our hosts were gracious and responsive. And the all the little extra amenities like extra sunscreen, soap, and spices for cooking were really nice as well. It will be on our list of favorites for a next trip!

The place was amazing, the hosts were awesome. Had a little hick-up, a water pipe was leaking outside - so no damage; and they were very quick to get it fixed! Things happen and its how they are addressed and taken care of... 5 STARS. There was a little beach, just south of the resort on the main road. This had a little peninsula and a cove of water - perfect for the kids to play on the peninsula / island (depending on the tide). The water was shallow enough for our 2, 3, and 4 year old's to go in and play, stand up and parents to relax. Excellent sandy area for the older kids and adults too... the BEST BEACH EVER !!

I will definitely rent this home again in the future. Thank you for all your help me communication Christy.

Our family had a great time here. House was amazing and extremely comfortable. Design was top notch! Location was cool, with immediate water access. Only change I would have made is to plan for a boat rental. It was a little limiting only having a golf cart, so we ended up renting a car (which was only $80 a day), but a boat would have been the best.

Heaven on earth. The most perfect white sand beach is a 5 min walk away, the home was beautiful with top of the line finishes and amenities, and it was quiet and peaceful. Perfect for a couples getaway or family vacay, I cannot recommend Treasure Cay and Reagan’s place enough. I’ve stayed two places now in Treasure Cay and I will always check Reagan’s home for availability first when I return to this magical place.

Absolutely perfect location in New Plymouth! Beautiful views and much to do within walking distance! Will definitely stay here again!

My husband and I thoroughly enjoyed our stay! This is the perfect place with all the essentials!

This is our second stay at the Parrot House and we had a great time. Perfect spot if you have a boat, our 36’ Invincible fit perfectly and there is water access at the dock. There is a resort restaurant in walking distance as well as a convenience store! Margo is always a pleasure to communicate with and checked in on us frequently. We will be back!

This was our second girl’s trip in the exact same unit. Kellie is friendly and responsive. The unit is clean, comfortable, and spacious. The beds are comfortable. The towels are soft and clean. The views of the beach are wonderful. Coffee on the lanai was a peaceful part of the day. The kitchen had all the tools to make meals. We will be back!

My family and I really loved our stay. We are a family of six and one of our kids is an infant. The resort had a pack and play we were able to rent, which was convenient. The unit was very clean and really nice and had a great view of the ocean. The staff at the resort was extremely friendly and they helped us coordinate everything like Taxi to the ferry boat, golf cart rental and local recommendations. The beach is insane, one of the best beaches I’ve ever seen in my life. Would recommend this stay to anyone!

Paul was very flexible in working with us to make sure stay was enjoyable!

Awesome place to stay!! Paul was very responsive. Great little spot. Beautiful beach just steps from the front door!! Definitely would recommend and will be back.

We loved our stay in Treasure Cay. The view was breathtaking. Treasure Cay beach is the most beautiful beach you will find. It feels like a private beach because you see so few people on it. The condo was very cute and clean. The beds were comfy. We will definitely stay there again.

Alan’s condo is very convenient and the dock was right outside the door, with dock lines available for use. Everything in the unit was fresh and new. I would highly recommend, especially if you come by boat, or plan to rent a boat from Treasure Boat Rentals.

We had an amazing stay at Matthew’s beautiful condo in Treasure Cay. It was super clean, comfy, and had everything we needed. The beach is literally just steps away – white sand, clear water, and barely anyone around. Great spot to relax and unplug. Matthew was friendly and helpful too. The pool area and the bar/restaurants were also steps away, with great service. Would definitely come back!

This condo is beautiful! I honestly hate to even explain how wonderful it is for fear that it won’t be available my next visit! Treasure Cay itself is absolutely beautiful ! The people are so warm and friendly ! Even more so than some of the other islands ! Which is saying a lot! Krystal at check in was wonderful so sweet and kind and always available if we needed anything. Restaurants on site are convenient and great food. Outdoor dining ocean front! We sat outside in the evenings and did not get one no see um bite at all! This is a wonderful condo and Treasure Cay is amazing ! I’m already ready to go back!