Places to stay near Tarpon Bay Beach

My Sea Shack~ 1 minute to beach, SH Club, G-Cart

Let "My Sea Shack" be your home away from home while you recharge your mind, body and soul on our island oasis, North Captiva! We are an unspoiled, low-key tropical paradise off the coast of Southwest Florida. This means that our beaches are uncrowded, and tourists and traffic are just a mainland memory! Leave your car and your cares at the marina because this island is only accessible by water taxi, boat or private aircraft. Each day, after exploring our paradise (by provided golf cart), let this spacious property welcome you back. Our new stilt home was built in 2018 and is ready to meet all your vacation needs! It features 2 bedrooms and a pull-out couch which will comfortably sleep 6. The master’s over-sized king bed will provide a nightly hug and a warm place to dream. Not tired quite yet...put on some tv and fall asleep while watching your favorite show on the flat screen. The 2nd bedroom can accommodate 3 people eaily with a comfy queen bed and twin. This room also has a flat screen making it a little easier for guests or little ones to doze off. In the morning, start your day off with your cup of coffee or tea on our sprawling deck. Relax and unwind in this comfortable home away from home! Spend your days on our beaches or stay as busy as you’d like with four on-island restaurants, two bars, kayak rentals, fishing charters, private chefs, cabana rentals, craft making opportunities, bicycle rentals, sunset cruises and our favorite - island hopping charters! My Sea Shack also comes with resort like amenities…take a dip in the community pool, play a game of tennis, enjoy priority seating at Safety Harbor’s restaurant -> On The Water or bring your private boat and have access to a boat slip (small daily fee applies). What makes this property TRULY SPECIAL though is the fact that it is only a 2-minute walk to Safety Harbor’s private beach entrance. This beach is so secluded, you will feel like you are on your own private beach. Choose your itinerary, let us take care of the rest~ your next adventure on North Captiva awaits. HOW TO GET TO THE ISLAND AND HOUSE Island Girl Charters has a ferry that runs from Pine Island to North Captiva. At the marina, you can leave your vehicle there. The boat crew will load up your luggage and groceries onto the ferry and you will be on your way..the actual ride is only about 20 minutes long. Many times you will see dolphins trailing behind as you make your way to the island. Upon arriving at the Safety Harbor drop off, our conceirge service will pick you up and load your belongings onto a trailer. If this is the first time, they will be happy to give you a quick tour before taking you to the house. The conceirge service will also take you back to Safety Harbor upon departure. INCLUDED~ Water osmosis system Wifi Netflix, disney +, hulu, amazon prime DVD player Blue-ray player 6 beach chairs Umbrella Beach towels Beach games Sand toys Pickle ball set Grill Propane tank Pack & play Highchair All spices Courant pizza maker (for frozen pizzas) Mixer Can opener Toaster Coffee maker Blender All kitchen cutlery Blowdryer T-fal cookware Vacuum Cleaning supplies Laundry det pods Hand soap Dish soap Toilet paper Paper towels 1 bottle of wine

Right on the Beach with the Best Views and Rates!

Sanibel Siesta looks amazing! Immaculate beachfront, 2BR, 2BA w/garage, nicely updated beachy unit at sand's edge. Amazing views of the Gulf with 5 star ratings! 3-day min. Sustained min. damage from Hurricane Ian. New hurricane windows, freshly painted with ELEVATOR IN BUILDING! Discount for weekly/mo. rentals. BR 1: King bed, en suite, smart TV. BR 2: 2 twin beds, smart TV. Qn. sofa bed in LR. Pool, golf course, bikes, laundry on site. No food or condiments stored in unit. May allow small dog.

LUX Villa w/ Private Salt Water Pool, Lanai, Canal

Are you looking to swim, relax outdoors, fish and take in beautiful sunsets on a wide gulf access canal? If so you will fall in love with this stunning newly constructed custom built home! The 2750 square foot home is bright & airy with two main bedroom on-suites & a separate family wing! The gourmet kitchen, dining room & great room open via large sliders to the lanai & pool w/ views of the canal in much desired SW Cape! Beach inspired villa! Large captains walk & Tiki! Check out our reviews!

New Gorgeous Smart Home with Heated Pool on the Ca

Unwind in style in this spacious and modern home. Here's what awaits you: Smart Home Technology: Control lights, temperature, and even the front door with voice commands or your smartphone for a seamless experience. Heated Saltwater Pool: Take a refreshing dip in the sparkling pool, perfect for year-round enjoyment. Dedicated Workout Area: Maintain your fitness routine with a private space equipped for exercise. Freshwater Canal Views: Wake up to calming water views and the sounds of nature.

Waterside Cottage

Enjoy our peaceful little island paradise nestled beneath sprawling oaks and scattered palms just minutes from St James City’s restaurants and bars. Nearly 1/2 acre is yours to enjoy. Watch the manatees and dolphins swimming in the canal while you grill your catch of the day, or your fresh pick of the day from St James Fish House just down the street! Inside enjoy a fresh new contemporary and stylish cottage with everything you will need to make your stay comfortable, enjoyable and fun!

Sundial E304: Gulf Front Sanibel Island Paradise

BRAND NEW - RIGHT ON THE BEACH! Enjoy stunning direct gulf-front views from nearly every room at this relaxing 3BR coastal retreat. This luxury residence was fully renovated to include a custom expanded kitchen, 2 gorgeous bathrooms, and washer & dryer. Top of the line coastal furnishings in every room. The large master bedroom offers spectacular gulf views & a full-size desk in case you need a quiet space to work. WiFi has been fully upgraded to make streaming and video a breeze.

Corner Residence at Pointe Santo de Sanibel

This beautiful corner unit in the highly sought-after Pointe Santo de Sanibel offers a walkout patio just steps from the sand. Enjoy breathtaking direct Gulf views from the spacious patio. Inside, you’ll find two large bedrooms, two updated bathrooms, a modern kitchen with island, and a spacious dining area. Guests can enjoy access to exceptional amenities, including a pool, hot tub/spa, tennis courts, shuffleboard, and social activities—making it the perfect destination.

Relax & Unwind | Loggerhead Cay 302

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway.Relax and unwind at Loggerhead Cay 302 — a bright, beachy end-unit in one of Sanibel’s most sought-after communities. Just steps from the sand, this spacious condo offers coastal charm, a fully equipped kitchen, and all the comforts of home. Enjoy access to a large heated pool, tennis & pickleball courts, beach gear, grills, and more. Hosted by a 5-star Superhost who’s here to make your stay seamless and memorable.

Coastal Chic Island Escape

Just 150 yards from Sanibel's peaceful beach, our home offers unmatched luxury: direct beach access, a heated saltwater pool, private pickleball/tennis court, and sea-view dining. A king suite, additional king bedroom, playful bunk room, and separate apartment provide comfort for all. Perfect for those seeking a serene escape, our home is not suited for loud gatherings or parties. Please help us preserve the tranquility of this special place. 28-day minimum.

Island Beach Club - steps to the beach!

Post Ian Update: We are excited to start welcoming guests back to the island starting October 2025! **Please note that our complex, neighboring units, and/or nearby complexes may still be rebuilding from the hurricane. Do expect some level of noise during your stay depending on dates. The POOL will not be available until January 2026. If you have any questions or concerns, please ask. Thanks for being part of our healing process and supporting the island!

Waterfront 2BR Condo (Fully Updated!) w/ 2 Bikes!

This unit has been updated, including an extended kitchen, granite counter tops, impact windows and doors, ceramic tile and a full bath along with a second half bath. This corner unit allows for outstanding canal views and privacy. Tennis and heated pool are just downstairs. Two bicycles are available. Please note that small construction projects are still taking place on the grounds outside due to Hurricane Ian. Enjoy!

Luxury Canalfront Pool Retreat w/ Upscale Finishes

Beautiful, modern NEW construction home with heated pool, on saltwater canal. Damage-free after hurricane Milton. FUN for families and tranquil for adults; fully stocked with electronic games table, pool toys and floats, outdoor games, arcade games, board games — much to enjoy! Enjoy indoor/outdoor living on expansive resort-style lanai and retreat to stylish finishes & luxe amenities throughout!