Vacation rentals in Sugar City

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sugar City

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1

Guest favorite

A spacious sleeping area features a large bed with soft linens and multiple accent pillows. Two bedside tables hold lamps, providing a warm glow. Sheer curtains frame the window, allowing natural light to enhance the light green walls and wooden floor.

Cottage in Rexburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 385 reviews

Garden Loft - Beautiful, Private, Country Setting!

We live on 14 beautiful acres with walking paths, groves of trees, a beautiful pond, and horses and cows all around us. During your stay, you will enjoy the quietness of the country, but quick easy access to town, Walmart is just 7 minutes away. The Loft is cozy with a wonderful view out every window. It is the perfect home base for your day trips to Yellowstone, the Teton Valley, Jackson Hole, Yellowstone Safari Park (1 min Away), Bear World, the St. Anthony Sand Dunes, or visiting BYU-Idaho.

Top guest favorite

The inviting entrance features a covered porch supported by stone columns. A wooden door with a window is complemented by two seating chairs. Decorative pumpkins add a seasonal touch, while a well-manicured lawn can be seen in front.

Home in Rexburg

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 331 reviews

Luxurious Modern 3-Bed 2-Bath Home near BYU-Idaho

Enjoy a luxurious stay at our farmhouse-style cottage conveniently located near many Rexburg amenities (BYU-Idaho, Hospital, Smith Park, LDS Temple, Waterpark). Perfect affordable home base for adventures to Yellowstone, Grand Teton, Jackson, and Targhee. Recently finished with modern touches, the spaces are all on one level and include a well-stocked kitchen, comfortable beds, clean bathrooms, and a spacious back deck. Our amazing on-site property managers live in a separate basement apartment.

Top guest favorite

The kitchen is equipped with sleek black and stainless-steel appliances, including a microwave and refrigerator. White cabinetry and a light countertop create a bright space. A window provides natural light, and a small plant adds a touch of greenery to the countertop.

Home in Rexburg

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Cozy home near BYUI/ Yellowstone

Relax with the whole family at our cozy home near BYUI. This Upstairs Unit is newly renovated with high-end appliances and finishes. This 3 bed 2 bath home also has a spacious back yard and garage. The home is on a quiet cul-de-sac and is close to a large park. Main street Rexburg is just 2 minutes away with lots of shopping and food. It is a great place to rest between Yellowstone, bear world, Jackson hole, and Targhee. It has a 2 car garage to park in to keep your car out of the snow or sun.

Top guest favorite

A spacious bedroom is highlighted by a large bed with neutral bedding. A window allows natural light, and two closets are visible, one with shelves and books. Soft décor complements the inviting atmosphere, and light wood flooring adds warmth to the space.

Home in Rexburg

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 184 reviews

Cozy Stay Near National Parks & BYUI - Sleeps 6

Start your dream vacation with a stay in this amazing main-level duplex! Just a short drive from destinations such as Yellowstone and Teton National Parks, Jackson Hole, and Island Park. Use this home as your base camp while experiencing world-class fishing, hiking, biking, skiing, and other endless adventures. Located in central Rexburg in a quiet neighborhood. Perfect for visiting family or friends! 1 block from Smith Park. Hospital, dining, and shopping close. We look forward to seeing you!

Guest favorite

Guest suite in Sugar City

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 404 reviews

Suite with Private Entrance Garage and Theater

Welcome! We believe you will enjoy this private guest suite, with 3 beds, family room with movie theater and dining area, fridge, coffee machine, microwave (NO kitchen). This suite is centrally located for easy travel to Jackson, Yellowstone, Grand Targhee, Bear World, Craters of the Moon, and the Sand Dunes. We can be found just off HWY 20 and not far from HWY 33. We are just 4 minutes from Rexburg, Idaho with BYU-Idaho, Walmart, and many restaurants. We know you will have a memorable stay.

Superhost

A blue-clad home is set against a backdrop of soft clouds and greenery. The house features multiple sections, with a spacious front yard that includes a well-maintained lawn and a pathway leading to the entrance.

Home in Sugar City

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

The Sugar House-BYUI, Natl Parks

Country living only 5 minutes away from Rexburg! NO CLEANING FEES when you stay here! Come stay at the Sugar House and enjoy your own country paradise. With BYU-Idaho, Yellowstone, Teton National Park, & more only a short drive away, you'll be surrounded with plenty of things to do. Comfortably accommodates 8 people and 1 baby. (Pack 'n Play & high chair included) Stocked with plenty of amenities for you to use & tons of parking for your convenience. Just look for the house with the lights!

Top guest favorite

The modern lodge features a dark exterior with large windows and a stone fireplace at the front. A spacious wooden deck extends from the entrance, providing a welcoming entryway. Surrounding trees frame the lodge, enhancing the natural setting.

Farm stay in Rexburg

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 194 reviews

LittleWoods Lodge + Private Forest & Hot Tub

Relax and unwind in the trees---The Littlewoods Lodge in Rexburg is the perfect blend of modern and stylish surroundings. Nestled in your own private forest, you are close to town and various attractions (easy access from hwy 20, right on Yellowstone Bear World Road). The outdoor space boasts a fire pit, wood benches, picnic area, gas grill, edison lights, and hot tub. Newly constructed modern lodge has soaring ceilings with 2 bedrooms, stone fireplace, walk-in shower, and stocked kitchen.

Top guest favorite

An open living space features a kitchenette with light blue cabinetry and a granite countertop. A dining area is created with two white stools positioned at the counter. A spacious bed with a patterned blanket is set against a large window with natural light filtering in.

Tiny home in Sugar City

5 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Ninette’s She Shed

Discover the gorgeous landscape that surrounds this place to stay. We are 1:15 from the West Yellowstone west entrance and Jackson Hole Wyoming. We are also 45 minutes from Teton Teton National Park. In the winter you can drive 45 minutes to get to the Grand Targhee Ski resort. The resort has amazing powder to ski on in the winter and incredible scenic hikes to discover in the fall and summer. This tiny house is perfect for 2 people. Brand new 500 square feet of comfy country living.

Guest favorite

A spacious sleeping area is highlighted by a large wooden bed frame with a comfortable mattress. Two bedside lamps provide soft lighting, while a bench is positioned at the foot of the bed. Natural light filters in through the nearby window, complementing the open layout.

Apartment in Rexburg

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 314 reviews

Spa Jetted shower & soaker tub Modern Studio

This open & refreshing modern studio apartment is a block from Porter Park & 3 blocks from BYU-Idaho campus. The moment you walk in the apartment you feel the soft light from the huge windows & wonder... is this really a basement? You’ll find a luxury bathroom outfitted with body jets, rain shower & deep soaker tub filled by waterfall spout. The bed is wonderfully comfortable with fluffy breathable topper. You can even snuggle up to the fire or enjoy your favorite shows on the smart TV!

Top guest favorite

A comfortable living space is shown, featuring a large flat-screen TV mounted on a light-colored wall. Two brown reclining chairs and a plush sofa are arranged on a soft carpet. A wooden dining table for four is positioned near a window, allowing natural light to fill the room.

Home in Rexburg

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

Bev's Place

Welcome to Bev's place, where you can enjoy a great night stay in a wonderful location just 10 minutes away from BYU Idaho, 1 hour and 20 minutes to Yellowstone and 15 minutes away from the St. Anthony sand dunes. You will enjoy a country living feel in this spacious two story home located just north of Rexburg. With parking available on site you can bring your toys and enjoy recreating in the beautiful surrounding areas that South East Idaho has to offer.

Top guest favorite

The guest suite is shown in a charming exterior view, featuring light-colored siding and a gabled roof. A well-maintained lawn with green grass and blooming flowers is visible in the foreground, alongside a tall evergreen tree providing a natural border.

Home in Rexburg

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

Country Cottage Guest Suite

This cozy 1 bdrm, 1 bath guest suite is attached to our family home but has a separate locked entrance and offers complete privacy. Our quiet country neighborhood is located in beautiful Idaho farmland. Enjoy jam from our garden and a stroll to the neighborhood lake. We're 15 min from BYU-Idaho, 1.5 hrs from Yellowstone NP, 1.5 hrs from Jackson and Grand Teton NP, 15 min from sand dunes and about 1 hr from Grand Targhee Ski Resort.

Top guest favorite

Condo in Rexburg

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Cozy 2BR Near BYU-I | Sleeps 8 | Family-Friendly

🌷 Welcome to your cozy Rexburg getaway—perfect for spring escapes & summer adventures ☀️ Enjoy a bright, family-friendly ground-floor condo near BYU-Idaho. Sleeps 8 with 5 beds. Minutes to campus (great for graduations), easy no-stair access, and close to Yellowstone & Grand Teton day trips. Clean, comfortable, and fully stocked—your ideal home base for exploring Eastern Idaho. ✨ Book your stay today!