Vacation rentals in Stillwater Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Stillwater Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

Chalet in Pocono Pines

Hot Tub+Fire Pit | Game Room Lake Naomi Golden Owl

Slow mornings, kids already in play mode, and evenings that don’t need planning. A family chalet in Lake Naomi designed so kids stay busy and parents actually relax. ✴️✴️✴️What families love most✴️✴️✴️ ⮕ 3-min drive or easy bike ride to lake, pool & clubhouse ⮕ Hot tub + fire pit for easy, low-effort nights together ⮕ Game room (pool, ping pong, arcade = hours of built-in fun) ⮕ Two separate hangout zones so everyone has their own space Tap the ❤️ to save us and choose your favorite season

FamilyValuePool

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Top guest favorite

An outdoor deck features comfortable lounge furniture in shades of blue, surrounded by lush greenery. A stock tank pool is seen, offering a relaxing spot. Soft gravel pathways lead to various seating areas, creating a serene outdoor retreat on the property.

Home in Stroudsburg

Simply Serene: Wild West City/Escape Room/4 Acres

✨IT'S ALL ABOUT FINDING THE CALM IN THE CHAOS ✨ & making memories .. 🌿4 ACRES OF PRIVACY, TRANQUILITY & WILD WEST CHARM 🌿4 COZY BEDROOMS • 3000+ SQ FT OF PURE FUN 🏡Unique Custom Designed Retreat in the Heart of the Poconos - Stunning Nature & Wildlife yet Minutes from All Major Poconos' Attractions 💖Perfect for Any Group Size - From Romantic Getaways, to Family Reunions, Special Occasions, OR Relaxing with Friends & Loved Ones ⭐Over 100 Indoor & Outdoor FUN Activities for All Ages ⭐

LocationValueCheckout

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 202 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Penn Estates

Enchanted Forest Escape | Hot Tub | Movie Screen

A truly unique stay in the Pocono Mountains, home to rolling mountain terrain, breathtakingly beautiful waterfalls, thriving woodlands, + 170 miles of winding river. Created with the “ultimate night in" themed experience, guests can sip wine under the stars in a private hot tub, + enjoy movies on their own 135" movie screen equipped w/ the world's first LED 4K gaming projector. Enjoy themed bedrooms and experience a stay where the forest takes you away as you stay in ultimate comfort + luxury.

LocationValueParks

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 263 reviews

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Pocono Summit

Private Lake front, hot tub, kayaks, bikes, fish

Very cozy and private Lake House a charming 3 bedroom and 2 bathroom house nestled in the heart of Pocono mountains. This beautifully appointed home offers the perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and relaxation. Imagine relaxing in wood burning hot tub with a lakeview, kayak, paddle boat, paddle board, fire-pit by water and much more. House is located few minutes from Kalahari waterpark and SPA. Mount Airy Casino and golfing is also very close by. Walmart, ShopRite and Starbucks near by.

LocationValueGrill

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

Top guest favorite

A castle-style retreat is showcased, featuring a whimsical dragon statue and a large chess set in the foreground. A tranquil pond with a fountain is visible, alongside a magnificent castle structure designed with classic stone elements and a welcoming entrance, all set amidst lush greenery.

Castle in East Stroudsburg

Pocono Castle: Dungeon Escape Room & Private Pond

Sleep in a Fairy Tale at Pocono Castle! Live the dream in this 2,300 sq. ft storybook retreat, where you’ll sleep like royalty in a real fairy tale castle. Unwind in luxury with a bubbling hot tub, a cedar sauna, and endless magical touches. Dress up as Kings, Queens, or Knights and explore the grounds, featuring a private one-acre pond & maybe you’ll catch a Golden Fish! With enchanting bedrooms, outdoor adventures, and unforgettable charm, this is the OMG getaway you’ve been waiting for!

LocationValueLayout

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 481 reviews

Top guest favorite

The contemporary log chalet is illuminated at night, showcasing its elaborate facade decorated with festive lights. The spacious balconies and numerous large windows are visible, reflecting a warm glow. A circular gravel drive surrounds the home, enhancing its inviting appearance.

Chalet in Tannersville

Whispering Creek Retreat

Nestled in nature with a serene creek flowing behind, this European chalet features 5 bedrooms and 4 baths, perfect for families or groups. It offers a fully equipped kitchen, dining area, cozy living room with a fireplace, game room, sauna, outdoor firepit, and grill. Perfect for reunions, bachelor/bachelorette parties, or wellness retreats, it’s close to waterparks, ski slopes, state parks, wineries, casinos, and shopping. Enjoy comfort, luxury, and adventure in one unforgettable retreat.

LocationValueGrill

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Top guest favorite

The image features a collage showcasing The Bliss House. A cozy living area with a gas fireplace and large TV is complemented by a modern kitchen. A game room with foosball, air hockey, and a pool table is included, along with a relaxing hot tub surrounded by privacy trees and a comfortable home theater area.

Home in Pocono Pines

Pocono Family Retreat: Theater, Hot Tub, Game Room

Welcome to The Bliss House at the Pocono Mountains. Our recently built home from the bottom up in modern styling is sure to please. We have it all to make wonderful memories including private hot tub, home theater with surround sound, gourmet kitchen, luxury accents, high-speed Wi-Fi, and game room (pool table, air hockey, poker, and foosball). This home is situated in the beautiful Lake Naomi 5 star platinum rated community. We are centrally located near many nearby attractions. Book now!

ValueFamilyDecor

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Top guest favorite

A two-story home features a combination of light siding and stone accents. A welcoming porch with wooden railings extends across the front, while two garage doors provide convenient parking. Lush green grass surrounds the property, framed by trees in the background.

Home in Pocono Summit

Spacious Family Retreat | Game Room+Hot Tub+Sauna

Welcome to your spacious Poconos family retreat—perfect for fun and relaxation! Unwind in your private outdoor sauna, soak in the hot tub, or enjoy the fully stocked game room. This 4BR home sleeps 10 and is just minutes from Kalahari, ski resorts, and a short walk to the lake. Each bedroom features comfortable beds, a smart TV, and cozy UGG blankets. Plus, the inviting gathering spaces are designed for connection, comfort, and unforgettable stays. We look forward to hosting you!

FamilyLocationBackyard

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Pocono Pines

Romantic AFrame Cabin | Stargaze | FirePit | Grill

Only 2 hours from NYC • 90 minutes from Philly • Easy drive from North Jersey, Scranton & Allentown Welcome to the Romantic A-Frame, our charming hideaway designed for couples, solo travelers, or a small family with up to 2 children. Cozy, peaceful, and intentionally styled, this retreat is all about slowing down, reconnecting, and enjoying simple comforts. When you're ready, you can hit the slopes or the areas hiking trails. Minimum Age to Rent is 25 Township Registration # 021444

ValueFamilyComfort

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Guest favorite

A collage of images showcases various features of the cabin. Elements include a spacious living area with comfortable seating, a game room with a pool table and movie screen, a backyard with lounge chairs and a hot tub, and a community pool surrounded by greenery.

Cabin in Coolbaugh Township

3000+sf Designer Home|HotTub|Sauna|Movie|Firepit

[ SUPER HOST LISTING ] Beach / Community Pool will be open on Memorial Day Weekend "NEW POCONO HOME!" 3000+ sqft including movie room (transformed from garage). 4B 3.5B for up to 12 ppl. Vacation house near Camelback Mountain & Kalahari Resort. Close to the state’s #1 ski resort, highest-rated waterpark, and dozens of year-round outdoor activities, this home truly gives you the reigns to an outdoor paradise. Ski, mountain bike, golf at Mt. Airy, before returning home to create a meal.

LocationValueCheckout

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 216 reviews

Top guest favorite

An evening view of the home features warm light glowing from the windows. Outdoor seating is present on the deck, and a fire pit with chairs is situated nearby in the yard. A covered hot tub is visible, adding to the inviting atmosphere.

Home in Tobyhanna Township

NEW Lakefront Home with Hot Tub

Situated on the water's edge of Arrowhead Lake, this brand new, custom built home offers a unique, luxury getaway for those seeking a stay with all that lakefront living has to offer. Perfectly set up for a romantic getaway for two, The Lakehouse on Arrowhead was created to provide a space for couples to rest and reconnect while enjoying gorgeous lake views from both inside and out. The spacious deck is just steps from your own private dock which allows you to kayak at your leisure.

LocationValuePool

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 153 reviews

Top guest favorite

The A-frame cabin is showcased in the twilight, surrounded by trees and illuminated by soft string lights. A hot tub is situated on a wooden deck nearby, offering a serene outdoor retreat. A barrel sauna is also visible, adding to the relaxation options.

Cabin in Albrightsville

Skiing/Tubing | Sauna | HotTub | Games | Woods

Skiing/Tubing season is almost around the corner! Escape to the "Eclipse", a Scandinavian-inspired modern cabin nestled on .5 acres overlooking endless woods. The Eclipse offers thoughtful amenities such as a striking gas fireplace, a fun arcade console, disc golf, laser tag, and a mouth watering popcorn cart for movie nights. Unwind in the hot tub under the stars or bask in the LED-lit A-frame charm. At 'Eclipse', all stars align for a truly magical stay.

LocationValueDecor

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 215 reviews