Vacation rentals in Sheffield

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sheffield

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor area is surrounded by trees displaying vibrant autumn foliage. Sunlight filters through the branches, casting shadows on a gravel pathway. Two cottages are visible in the distance, enhancing the peaceful forest setting.

Guesthouse in Bradford

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

Timberdoodle Lodge: Kellidoodle Cottage

Enjoy the peace and quiet and night sky of Timberdoodle Lodge at the Kellidoodle or Grammy's Cottage, surrounded by the Allegheny National Forest. It's the perfect place to unwind, relax or play (or even keep in touch or do a little work). Hiking? Over 650 miles of trails are nearby. In winter you can snowshoe or cross country ski on those trails! Fishing? Bring your waders and fishing rod for superb trout fishing on nearby Kinzua Creek, Sugar Run or Willow Creek. See more details below.

Top guest favorite

The cabin's exterior showcases a spacious front porch adorned with comfortable seating arrangements. A grill is positioned to the left, while the well-maintained surrounding greenery complements the inviting entrance. Large glass doors provide a glimpse into the cabin's interior, framed by the natural landscape.

Cabin in Sheffield

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Rocky Bottom Retreat in the ANF

Rocky Bottom Retreat is an updated, cozy cabin that sits directly on the South Branch of Tionesta Creek. It is located at the end of a quiet, dead end road w/ 2 BRs & 1 BA, stocked kitchen, indoor fireplace, storage area for gear, laundry, front & back porches for listening to the creek and taking in mountain/forest views, plus a fire pit & grill. Minutes from hiking, game lands, ATV trails, and world class fishing. Come relax in this peaceful waterfront cabin in the ❤️ of the National Forest.

Guest favorite

A new cabin is surrounded by lush greenery, sitting directly beside a gently flowing stream. The building features a green metal roof and a welcoming front porch with steps leading to the entrance. A fire pit is positioned nearby, enhancing outdoor relaxation.

Cabin in Sheffield

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Just Beautiful - 2 bedroom camp with loft!

Brand new 2022 build on a Pennsylvania Class A and Stocked trout stream. Minutes from countless pristine streams, Chapman Dam Lake and the beautiful Kinzua Reservoir. Walk directly to public hunting lands and over 500,000 thousand acres of national forest. Allegheny national forest ATV and snowmobile trails a short drive away. North Country Trail. Mountain Biking Trails. Kayaking. Endless outdoor recreation and a beautiful place to rest and sleep at night. Covered parking for vehicles or ATVs.

Top guest favorite

A charming riverfront home is set against a serene backdrop, featuring lush green lawns and tasteful landscaping. Two white swans are seen gracefully near the water's edge, adding a touch of nature to the picturesque setting.

Apartment in Warren

5 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

The River House

Come relax in our beautiful riverfront home conveniently located within 10 minutes of downtown Warren. We have created a private two-story, two bedroom retreat within the main home, separate entrance and amenities included. Take in the beautiful views of 2024's River of the Year & The Allegheny National Forest while enjoying your morning cup of coffee on our private dock. Hop on a bike or take a scenic stroll along the river and finish the evening cozied up by the fire under the night sky.

Top guest favorite

The kitchen features high ceilings and large windows, allowing natural light to illuminate the space. A modern island with seating is complemented by sleek cabinetry and a farmhouse sink. Scenic views of the surrounding area are visible through the windows.

Cabin in Irvine

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 122 reviews

Riverbend Cabin~ Allegheny Island Wilderness Area

Located at the end of a quiet lane, with a stunning view of the Allegheny River, our riverfront cabin is the perfect getaway to relax with family and friends. Nestled right between Tidioute and Warren, our cabin is close to many sites within the National Forest: Buckaloons, Heart's Content, Rocky Gap, etc. There's also a great view of Crull's Island, a 96 acre paradise within the Allegheny Wilderness Area. Be on the lookout for heron, osprey, waterfowl, deer, and the amazing bald eagle!

Guest favorite

A rustic cabin exterior is shown, featuring a wooden façade and a welcoming front porch with a ramp. The porch is equipped with a sturdy railing, providing access to the entrance. Surrounding grassy areas and trees enhance the cabin's country setting.

Cabin in Kane

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Bear Creek Cabins #1

Cozy cabin located in a country setting next to Bear Creek Wines. Located in the heart of the Allegheny National Forest and an excellent location for your outdoor adventures or weekend getaway. Just a short drive to many local attractions including: Brush Hollow Hiking/Ski Trail, Marienville ATV Trail, the Ridgway Rifle Club, the Clarion River (Pennsylvania River of the Year), Benezette Elk Viewing Area (1 hour drive), Kinzua Dam/State Park, Cook Forest State Park, and many more!

Guest favorite

A serene landscape features a gently flowing creek surrounded by lush greenery. Trees with fresh leaves create a vibrant canopy overhead. A wooden bridge crosses the creek, adding a natural touch to the tranquil setting.

Cottage in Warren

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 381 reviews

The Edy

Nestled in the Allegheny National Forest along the Allegheny River. A cozy home with nearby fishing, hunting, historical landmarks, cross country, skiing, hiking, biking, antique shops, boating, and kayaking/ canoeing. Moments away from adventures nearby including the Kinzua Dam where the Alleghany River is poured from. Peaceful & quiet for relaxation. 😊Pets are permitted an additional cleaning fee is charged. “Must” notify us if planning on having a pet with you on your visit .

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area displays a mix of rustic and modern elements. A comfortable brown leather sofa and a stylish armchair are arranged around a soft area rug. The kitchen features stainless steel appliances and a decorative backsplash, while large windows allow natural light to brighten the space.

Home in Kane

5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Camp Black Cherry Rock

Discover tranquility at Camp Black Cherry Rock in Kane, Pennsylvania. This charming Airbnb features two bedrooms and a sleeping loft, perfect for up to six guests. Located steps from the Allegheny National Forest, it's a haven for nature lovers. Enjoy hiking, exploring the forest, or relaxing by the fire pit under the stars. The cabin includes a fully equipped kitchen, a cozy living area, and all modern amenities. Experience a peaceful retreat in this serene, secluded setting.

Guest favorite

The cabin is nestled beside the river, surrounded by lush greenery and large trees. A spacious deck is visible, featuring a canopy for shade, with views of the water and nearby natural landscape, reflecting a peaceful outdoor atmosphere.

Cabin in Tidioute

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Riverfront Cabin w/ amazing views! Summer!

A camp with a million dollar view and only one other camp on the other side of the stream and wooded area. Bring your family and friends to camp out, cook out, go fishing, canoeing or kayaking. Children can play in the stream beside the camp or on the jetty, or even walk across the Allegheny to the island to play and explore. A fun, relaxing retreat for years of memories. This is a 4 season cabin so come and experience the Lehmeier's lodge during the various seasons.

Top guest favorite

A comfortable living area is presented, featuring a gray couch adorned with decorative pillows. A wooden coffee table with a stone inlay sits in front, while a floral lamp and an armchair are positioned nearby. Natural light filters through two windows dressed with sheer curtains.

Cottage in Warren

5 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Cozy Cottage

Looking for a quiet getaway? Relax & enjoy the comforts of our 700 sq-ft Cozy Cottage! Perfect for couples & small families - this home is situated on a private half acre in the heart of Warren County. Comes fully-furnished with 1 queen bed (sleeps 2), 1 pull-out couch (full size - sleeps 2), a den with loungers, TVs, and an outdoor charcoal grill and fire pit. Located minutes from town, 20 minutes from the Kinzua Dam, 40 minutes from Lakewood, NY.

Top guest favorite

A serene view of the Allegheny River is presented, showcasing calm waters reflecting the blue sky and fluffy white clouds. Lush green grass lines the riverbank, with a tree providing shade nearby, while wooded hills rise in the background.

Cabin in Tidioute

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Gracie's Great Getaway

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place located on the Allegheny River. Stay for hunting and fishing trips with friends. Bring your boat and launch it right in front of the cabin. Get your supplies at the local Trading Post (fire wood, groceries and more). Bring your ATV and enjoy the trails only a few miles away from the place. You have more guests? No problem if you like to put up a tent or two. ( ask the host for details ).

Top guest favorite

A charming cabin is set in a wooded landscape, featuring a red metal roof and large glass doors that open to a deck area. Two Adirondack chairs surround a fire pit on a gravel base, inviting relaxation amidst nature.

Cabin in Russell

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Secluded Egypt Hollow Cabin

Escape to a serene cabin near the Allegheny National Forest in Russell NWPA. Perfect for travelers and couples seeking a relaxing getaway surrounded by nature. 1 Bed. 1 Bath. Private Cabin Enjoy a stream, fire pit, and private driveway. Explore hiking, biking, and all types of boating nearby. Enjoy local businesses downtown Warren. Host available for questions and recommendations. Book your getaway now!