Vacation rentals in Rum Cay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Rum Cay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1

Guest favorite

A stone structure is positioned in a manicured lawn surrounded by tropical plants. The structure is composed of rough stones, with a decorative gray vase placed nearby. Lush palm trees and greenery create a serene atmosphere against a bright blue sky.

Cottage in San Salvador

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Petit Paradise Sandy Point, San Salvador

Typical two Storey Bahamian beach cottage in a beautiful tropical garden 100 feet from the crystal-clear ocean. The modern, European style downstairs apartment (appr. 700 square feet) features a contemporary white master bedroom, a spacious living room with a fully equipped kitchen corner and a bathroom with two sinks and with a shower. There is a large wooden outside deck for barbecue and dining. The house has a sliding door to view the ocean and the beautiful sunsets. The perfect place to relax and to enjoy the ocean. WIFI is available free of charge.

Warm sunlight filters through the leaves of a tree overlooking the sandy beach. Footprints lead toward gently lapping waves, while the sun sets on the horizon, creating a serene coastal view with soft colors in the sky.

Home in San Salvador Island

Beach Home on Extraordinary Secluded Beach

Enjoy the most incredible beaches around this island; our beach home is simple and comfortable, with air conditioning for evenings. The beach out our front porch is magnificent ... you can walk 1/2 mile to the end of the beach and never see anyone else. Take an evening and go to the Club Med if you want a fancy buffet and bar. The people of San Salvador are friendly and welcoming. You can go to a different beach each day for a week. This will quickly become your favorite place in the world!

A spacious deck overlooks the calm ocean waters, framed by swaying palm trees. The scene captures the bright blue sky and the natural greenery below, creating an inviting outdoor space ideal for relaxation.

Home in Stella Maris

Villa in stella maris - Water front

Experience the ultimate island getaway in our beautifully renovated 4-bedroom villa, situated in Stella Maris, Bahamas. This property has breathtaking ocean views, and spacious living areas Our villa features a unique layout, with 2br/1 upstairs, and 2 lower unit ,ideal for families or groups who want to stay together while still having their own space. Our villa is just minutes from Stella Maris Airport. Plus, you're just a short drive from the world's most beautiful beaches and fishing spots.

A cozy living area is furnished with a rattan couch and chairs, accented with turquoise cushions. A glass coffee table sits centrally, surrounded by large windows draped with blue curtains. Natural light enhances the warm, inviting space, showcasing views of the surrounding landscape.

Cottage in Stella Maris

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Near stunning Cape Santa Beach, WiFi and Sat TV

Our Bonafide Rental Cottage, suitable for couples and small families has gorgeous hilltop views and is the perfect home for an out-island getaway, filled with fun adventure! The cottage is tropically furnished and is very private for those who like their peace and quiet! It is only a 5 min. drive to the stunning and best beach on the island, Cape Santa Maria Beach. Fast Wifi lets you stay in contact with family and work, and TV is great for evening Movies! We are excited to have you visit!

Guest favorite

A wooden deck features two lounge chairs, positioned for ocean views. Lush palm trees and natural greenery frame the scene, creating a tranquil pathway leading to the bright blue waters in the distance.

Home in San Salvador Island

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Bahamas beachfront paradise.

Tropical escape just 3 hrs from NYC! (Daily 45 min flt from Nassau). Come with family and friends and make lifetime memories snorkeling , swimming, grilling, laughing, and enjoying life in our ocean front , 4 bedroom , 2 bath home with a private beach and large deck overlooking the ocean. Drop dead gorgeous location and all amenities provided. Outdoor shower, private chef available, professional cleaning, rental cars available. 10 min from the international airport (where Club Med is)

Guest favorite

A spacious terrace is viewed, featuring two loungers and a side table. The ocean glistens in the distance, framed by lush greenery. Large sliding doors hint at an expansive indoor living area, while clouds drift across a bright blue sky.

Bungalow in Stella Maris

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Two Turtles ocean villa: A new gem on Long Island

Welcome to Long Island..... an unspoiled island paradise. Stella Maris is the perfect location from which to discover this laid back island, to explore endless beaches and to kick back and unwind. Nestled high above the Atlantic in a beautiful island setting, Two Turtles provides breathtaking views over the ocean and palm gardens. The villa was fully renovated in 2021 and combines island style living, inclusive of large outside areas with all modern amenities of a comfortable island home.

A view from the balcony features a sandy pathway leading to the beach, with vibrant turquoise waters visible in the distance. Lush green vegetation frames the landscape, and a few scattered clouds drift across a bright blue sky.

Home in San Salvador Island

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Grotto Bay Beach House

It's the pink house at the top of Grotto Bay - the closest house to the beach! Relax in your private getaway, where every room provides a view of the bay, and the path to the beach is steps from your door. Feel the soft white sand between your toes as you explore the beach in search of shells, or head straight for the refreshing water of Grotto Bay. There's a reef a few feet off shore where you can try out your snorkeling skills, or you can swim out a bit further and explore the grotto.

Top guest favorite

An open-air lounge area features comfortable white seating arranged around a wooden coffee table. A serene view of the Atlantic Ocean is visible in the background, framed by lush greenery. A colorful throw and sandals are casually placed on the wooden floor.

Villa in Stella Maris

5 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Rock Hill: Modern Beach House w/ Resort Access

Far from the crowds... Close to perfect! ROCK HILL sleeps up to 10 guests in 3 suites and 1 bunk room. INCLUDES access to the Stella Maris Resort pools, beaches, bars, and restaurants; all within EASY WALKING distance. Just steps away! If you’d like to really spread out… consider also renting the neighboring ISLAND VILLA with its private pool. It’s literally right next door. Check us out on social media (RockHill_Bahamas) to see the experiences that await you on this amazing island.

Guest favorite

An open living area is showcased, featuring a wooden dining table surrounded by white chairs. A comfortable seating arrangement is visible, with natural light filtering through large windows. A swing chair is positioned nearby, contributing to a relaxed atmosphere. A dog is seen in the background.

Cottage in Stella Maris

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Half Moon Cottage - Ocean Views in Stella Maris

Ocean & Sunset Views. Fun 2-Bedroom Cottage Home with fully functional kitchen and large open living area. Large closed in Deck off front for spectacular sunsets. Look-Out Tower. Goats, Chickens, Cats, Dogs. ** Two-Bedrooms with comfortable King Beds in each. Cottage is perfect for maximum four (4) persons. Hi-Speed Wifi/Internet. ROKU/Netflix TV & DVD Surround Sound w/ small Library. ** Two (2) Kayaks and Two (2) Stand-up Paddles available. (Rental Car needed to transport.)

A vibrant blue exterior of a two-story building is highlighted, featuring large windows on both floors. A welcoming entrance with double doors is framed by a covered porch, complemented by a pathway leading to the door. Surrounding greenery adds to the serene setting.

Home in Cockburn Town

4.67 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Peggy's House

Secluded Beachside Bliss! Wake up to ocean breezes in this private 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom escape just a 1 minute stroll from the beach. Enjoy a spacious open layout, a chef's kitchen, and a serene master suite with a spa-like jetted tub. Large windows flood the space with natural light, offering stunning coastal views. Whether you're lounging indoors or exploring the shoreline, this island retreat is perfect for relaxation, adventure and unforgettable memories.

A spacious soaking tub is positioned near an open doorway, revealing sweeping views of the Caribbean Sea and the sky above. A wooden tray rests on the edge of the tub, showcasing a candle and a decorative stone.

Home in Stella Maris

4.74 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Stunning Sunset Ocean Views

Enjoy a special September - November rate.... As one of the few Stella Maris properties affording sweeping panoramic views of the incredible sunset over the Caribbean and magnificent vistas of the north end of Long Island, The White House Long Island is the perfect setting for relaxing and unwinding from the world. The estate is situated in a botanical setting within the Stella Maris Resort area and is a 4 minute walk to the main restaurant and beach.

A wide, sandy beach stretches along the shoreline, meeting the calm, turquoise waters of the sea. A clear blue sky is dotted with a few fluffy white clouds, creating a serene atmosphere. The scene conveys tranquility and natural beauty.

Home in Glinton's Settlement

Amos Lakeview House

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space, where you can enjoy the beautiful sunset by the lake or take a few minutes drive to Cape Santa Maria Beach. You can also visit restaurants nearby, the food is delicious and the natives are warm and friendly. There is also within a 2 mile drive a few island attractions such as the Columbus Monument and the Newtons Cay Bridge both nestled by the seaside.