Vacation rentals in Put-in-Bay

Wonderful stay in a beautiful home!! Very comfortable and peaceful! We loved our week and all the amenities!!

Had a wonderful week vacation at Island Club at Putin Bay. Nichole was a wonderful hostess!! Made everything about our reservation, check in and entire stay very easy and smooth and terrific communication. Highly recommend.. thanks Nichole!!

We stayed at their beautiful condo for our babymoon! Place was well taken care of, everything was easy to find! Walkable to the ferry and a lot of restaurants! We will definitely be back ☺️

I enjoyed my stay and the way Michelle communicated with me. It was located in a nice quiet area and close to all of the activities that I was interested in participating.

This little cabin is FABULOUS! I love staying in places that feel like home and this definitely fit the bill. The kitchen had every dish and pan you could want. Full size frig, some dry goods in the cabinets, lots of extra blankets. We loved the quirkiness and character!

Perfect for a Bach party. The hosts were very responsive. Quick to get into town. Beautiful home.

The place was amazing; my crew loved the house and the location. We will be returning!

My wife & I had a wonderful stay in Jill's cottage in Port Clinton. The cottage was exactly as described. it was clean, peaceful, comfortable and had everything we needed. Jill was an excellent host with great communication.

Very nice updated place. Host is communicative and took care of us during our stay. Would definitely stay again.

Joni’s place was perfect for what we were looking for! The place was very spacious - with the 1st double queen room being inside the front door, and the rest of the bedrooms upstairs. It wasn’t right downtown, but it was near the ferry which was perfect for us. Theres golf carts available on-site which is what we used to get downtown. The staff on site was very helpful. Joni sent detailed instructions leading up to our stay and was available during our stay. Would definitely recommend!

Quiet and private. Just what we needed to decompress.

Bette than advertised. We stayed here for a fishing trip, we had 4 large boats and pickups. Albert let us park in the grass as needed. There was adequate outlets to charge our boat batteries at night and the garage space was excellent for the storage of our extra equipment, coolers, and gear. Beds are very comfortable, great furniture, and the house is nicely updated and decorated. We will definitely be staying here again!

Lovely view right next to the lake, very spacious home and well stocked kitchen! Would definitely love to be hosted again!

I would recommend the place to everyone. It was nothing but a pleasure to stay there. Oh, and the beds were awesome.

We stay every year & are never disappointed. Very clean & Mary is wonderful to deal with.

It was a great stay! A little cramped but that was expected, Renee was very nice and gave easy instructions. The place was nice and the thing that immediately won me over was the tissues that were in each room. THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THAT. My allergies were acting up crazy when I went to cedar point, but seeing that when I checked in I was celebrating. 5 stars ez. Recommend for a short stay for a very very good location. 👍

Dodge House is a historic property that has been in the family for generations. Weather and age takes its toll, but it has been carefully modernized (central A/C!) for the comfort of guests without it losing its Victorian charm. Wonderful people with lifetimes of stories about the island. Great location just around the corner from downtown, yet far enough away from the fray for a peaceful stay.

super great place..Ann was amazing

We’ve now stayed here twice and have loved it both times. Perfect spot for a lake weekend. The bed is comfy and the shower is amazing! Love sitting out on the deck. It’s nice to be so close to the water and other fun things without worrying about parking. Can’t wait to go back!

All great things, all great things! This was one of our favorites that we stayed so far and we've been in several at this location! Also, this was the first time we fished right there on the water, and it was great fun! Ross was very responsive on a couple quirky questions, nothing impactful, all great! Would stay, again.

I don’t even know where to begin!! I’d rate Chris and Jamie as a 10+ star as hosts and for their property!! Everything was absolutely amazing and Chris & Jamie went over and beyond what was expected! From offering flexibility with a late check to accommodate our needs, detailed check in and out instructions (videos were very helpful and funny too!), coffee/creamers provided and to top it off we were greeted with a personalized message with snacks (the kids loved this 🤪) wishing my daughter and her team good luck at their tournament!! Chris and Jamie were very quick to respond to any questions and provided excellent restaurant recommendations!! The Mario Place was absolutely beautiful inside and has an amazing view of Lake Erie and Cedar Point! Also, the property is within walking distance to several restaurants and entertainment!! Highly recommend renting this and/or any other properties from Chris and Jamie!!! We definitely will be back!!!

Great host, super responsive and easy to work with. Probably the cleanest rental we’ve stayed in! Would definitely come back.

Awesome stay and close to downtown area. Would stay here again.

This tiny house was the perfect place to have a girls get away. It was only steps to the water and provided beach chairs. Very relaxing! Awesome patio and lounge chairs. Great hospitality,host was very friendly.