Vacation rentals in Port McNicoll

Our stay at Shane’s paradise was nothing short of magical! From the moment we arrived, we were swept away by the breathtaking panoramic views that greeted us—every sunrise and sunset felt like a private masterpiece. The brand-new construction is pristine, blending modern elegance with cozy comfort. The attention to detail is evident everywhere, from the high-end finishes to the thoughtful layout designed for both relaxation and adventure. The amenities here are next-level! Soaking in the hot tub under a blanket of stars became our nightly ritual, while the provided kayaks let us explore the serene surroundings by day. Evenings were spent gathered around the fire pit, sharing stories and roasting marshmallows—a perfect blend of rustic charm and luxury. And let’s talk about the bedrooms: each one felt like a boutique hotel suite, with plush linens, chic decor, and such comfort that we woke up refreshed and ready. This isn’t just a rental—it’s an experience Shane has created magic.

Great stay at the cottage! We were a group of 5 adults and 1 child. Though the start of the week was too windy and cool to enjoy the beach and water sports available, the cottage is comfortable inside for everyone to have space. The kitchen had necessary equipment, pots and utensils for cooking. There is also a lot of amenities closeby for groceries, etc. There is also a good pub in walking distance. The small beach has enough chairs for everyone to relax, and it's sandy so great for kids to play. Due to the winds in the first few days, it was a bit seaweedy. We also had a lot of fun searching for rocks. Keep in mind the water on the bay can be a bit chilly. She did have a kayak, canoe and paddleboard available to use, as well as some floats to use on the water.

We were a group of 6 adults, 2 teenagers and 2 toddlers. Our stay was enjoyed by all! Swimming was great for the kids because there was a large shallow area along side the dock free of weeds! Harpreet's place was clean with ample beds and bathrooms. Weather was fantastic during our stay, so we did not use the hot tub. I have rented a few cottages and a common note of constructive criticism is to make sure the bbq is cleaned for the next renters, that would be a bonus. one other point is that I assume because of the fluctuation of temperature the doors were very hard to open, you really had to push on it. The small kids were unable to open themselves. With that said, the cottage was clean, modern, great layout, I loved the kitchen, just fabulous! Will definitely be back!

We had a great time at the cottage. It was exactly as described and there was everything we needed in the home.

J Nichole’s place is unique. We were looking for a place that was quiet for sleeping, with surroundings in nature, but close to amenities (we were travelling by bike and so proximity was important). What we found at Noel’s Nest was so much more than that — we were invited to join in a Sunday afternoon community musical jam session on premises, with homemade BBQ jerk chicken (Mmmm). The included continental breakfast had lots of fresh fruit, an assortment of breads/pastries, and the kitchen was well appointed with Kuerig coffee, good tea, and everything you’d need to cook your own meals, including spices. The forest setting and views from the porches, clean rooms with nice linens, and personality of J Nichole made our stay exceptional. We are choosy about our travel and we will definitely go back to this special place!

The host is very nice and responsive. The place is very quiet and nice for staying. She provided every necessary things. Good for family of 4 or group of 4

We were 7 adults., Us 2 from Australia visiting sister and her 2 daughters of which one lives with my sister in Kitchener and one who lives in Toronto. The 2 daughters were joined by their partners we hadn’t met so everyone was on their best behaviour and made a great impression on us. We hadn’t met the nieces partners so a fantastic time was enjoyed sitting around chatting, having some wine and whisky. The nieces and their partners used the hot tub the last evening and thoroughly enjoyed the experience. This townhouse was fantastic with everything one needs and more. We can definitely recommend this to any future guests.

Truly a hidden gem! The apartment was as described and more - we immediately felt at home. Excellent bed, comfy couch, fully equipped kitchen even nice towels! Loved the outdoor space complete with BBQ. We have marked this as our landing spot when putting our boat on and out of the water in Midland - will be back for sure! Michelle was a very responsive and kind host.