Vacation rentals in Pitcher

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Pitcher

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

Tiny home in Oxford

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 327 reviews

⭐Wildflower Country Cottage

🏡 Cozy cottage in the countryside. Gardens galore to explore! 🏘 Less than 5 minutes from town 🎟 Many local attractions including: 🦒 Animal Adventure 🏎 Northeast Classic Car Museum 🥾 State Parks, and hiking trails 🚶‍♂️Enjoy an afternoon in the gazebo or take a stroll around any of the many garden paths. 📕 See our guidebook for our favorite local attractions and eateries. ℹ️ Please check out our other listing: Lakeside Reflections https://airbnb.com/h/lakesidereflections

Top guest favorite

A tiny A-frame cabin is surrounded by snow-covered trees, featuring a cozy porch adorned with festive decor. A comfortable seating area with soft cushions sits nearby, accompanied by a fire pit that adds a warm glow to the winter scene.

Tiny home in Marathon

5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Hoxie Haven | Glamping in the Gorge |

Nestled by a stream at the foot of a hill, alongside Hoxie Gorge State Forest and near the head of Hoxie Gorge Trail & Finger Lakes Trail; only 9 miles from Greek Peak Ski Resort & Cascades Indoor Water Park, this tiny house A-Frame is a year-round glamping escape you don’t want to miss. This unique and cozy space is ideal for couples or possibly small families if you don’t mind being close. Equipped with a mini fridge, toaster oven/air fryer, microwave and kuerig. On site full camp bathhouse!

Top guest favorite

A clean and well-lit bathroom features a white sink with a stylish cabinet beneath. A modern toilet is positioned beside it, and a large mirror reflects the space. A framed artwork and a small potted plant add subtle decor against the neutral walls.

Apartment in Greene

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

New Downtown Greene Apartment *no cleaning fee!*

This spacious one bedroom apartment overlooks peaceful downtown Greene. A quaint little village known for its unique shops and chic restaurants. This apartment gives you 1000+ sqft of a home away from home, equipped with all the amenities: washer/dryer, full kitchen, living room, bedroom, & off-street parking. This beautifully designed, modern apartment is perfect for the business traveler or family staying for recreational purposes. One bedroom with a pullout couch & air mattress, sleeps 6.

Superhost

A cozy chalet is set against a backdrop of lush green fields and rolling hills. The structure features a red exterior and a sloped metal roof, with a pastel sky showcasing hints of pink and orange at sunset.

Home in Cincinnatus

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 49 reviews

Cozy chalet, at Unwine Vineyards.

Unwind at Unwine Vineyards is on 50 acres in central NY wine region. Joel and Mary have over 3000 young grapes and are owners of a wine and art gallery in PA. This cozy chalet is close to many attractions including Greek Peak, and the central NY wine tours. The home is spacious and sleeps 6 people, with all the modern amenities. Explore our beautiful property with trails that lead to a pond and through the vineyard with vistas. You will find everything you need for your home away from home.

Top guest favorite

A bathroom is showcased with lavender walls and soft lighting. A ruffled shower curtain hangs elegantly in the shower area, while a vintage-style mirror frames the sink and faucet. A small countertop is present, accompanied by a decorative hand soap dispenser.

Home in Cortland

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Adorable 2-bedroom home

Adorable home built in 1890 and renovated in 2019. Easy on/off from I-81, centrally located in New York- making it a great location to stay while visiting multiple colleges in one trip. Including SUNY Cortland, TC3 (~15min), Syracuse University(~30 min), Cornell (~30 min) & Ithaca College (~40 min) *Walking distance to: SUNY Cortland Downtown/Mainstreet Cortland Starbucks Several amazing local restaurants & a grocery store. Great local ski options including Greek Peak and Labrador Mtn.

Top guest favorite

Apartment in Oxford

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 632 reviews

Breezy Meadow

My place is close to Oxford and Norwich NY .You’ll love my place because of Country living at its finest pond,stream, 20 acres,nature trails spectacular views from every window. Brand new beautiful custom kitchen with stainless steal appliance. Spa like bathroom. The price is based on double occupancy any additional guest will be charged $40 per guest per night Dog fee is $30 per dog maximum 2 dogs. Second sleeping space has no door w/2 twin beds bathroom is in between the 2 sleeping rooms

Top guest favorite

A flowing stream is depicted, surrounded by dense greenery and natural foliage. Water rushes over rocks, with soft currents creating gentle ripples. Fallen branches can be seen along the banks, enhancing the untamed natural scenery of the area.

Cottage in Oxford

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 374 reviews

Beaver Palace Studios and Estates relaxing getaway

Your total getaway from the city and/or hectic life. We offer a very private and personal space for you to unwind and relax Everything on the property is handmade/built by owners. The grounds are very private. There is an abundance of wildlife and 50+ acres of private grounds to explore. Both owners are artists and world travelers. This stay is casual, relaxing and a real get away from it all. Hosts just down the lane for any assistance. Please book accurately # of people and # of pets.

Guest favorite

The exterior of a two-story house is shown, featuring white siding and green shutters. A neatly maintained yard is visible, with blooming flowers and trimmed hedges along the driveway. A red barn structure can be seen in the background, complementing the residential setting.

Guest suite in Cortland

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Conveniently located private suite in Central NY

Clean, comfortable, one-bedroom suite located in one of the best areas of Cortland! Only a 5-min walk to Yaman park where you can sit down for a nice picnic, swim in the beach area, fish, or kayak in the Tioughnioga river. Easy commute to Syracuse 40 mins or Ithaca. Located 40mins to 8 golf courses, and 4 ski resorts. Walking distance to grocery stores, laundromat, coffee shop, restaurants, a fitness center, bus route, and city owned rental bikes all located within just a few minutes.

Top guest favorite

A large, welcoming sign displaying 'The Farmhouse by Trinity Valley' is set against a backdrop of lush greenery. A stone planter at the base holds vibrant pink flowers, adding color to the scene. Rustic barns are visible in the distance, blending with the rural landscape.

Farm stay in Cortlandville

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

1820's Quaint Rustic Farmhouse

Beautiful, spacious, two-bedroom private suite. The Farmhouse is located on 50 acres of farmland in our beautiful river valley. We are directly off the Cortland I-81 exit and are 30 minutes to Cornell, Ithaca and Syracuse. We are conveniently located near Greek Peak and other local ski areas. Great location for professors, parents, students, outdoor enthusiast and anyone exploring the Finger lakes! We hope you enjoy your stay and come back again.

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor view features a pathway of brick leading to a wooden dock extending into a calm lake. Lush green grass frames the scene, with trees lining the opposite shore and clouds casting gentle shadows under a bright sky.

Cabin in Plymouth

5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Cozy piece of paradise!

Peaceful, cozy, newly renovated cottage with 100 feet of private lakefront property. This sweet cottage is surrounded on two sides by state land and on the other side by tall pine trees. Enjoy beautiful sunsets over the lake. A fire pit is also on-site, but firewood is not supplied. Firewood can be brought in, or there are some bundles available for a small fee. There are two kayaks there for your use.

Guest favorite

A stone fire pit encircled by gravel is surrounded by four outdoor chairs on a grassy area. Soft lighting from solar lamps enhances the space, creating a cozy setting for gatherings. Surrounding trees provide shade and a natural backdrop.

Home in McDonough

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

Foxy Trails

Tucked in the hills of McDonough, Foxy Trails is the perfect spot for a weekend getaway. The country ambiance is perfect for those who just want to relax and unwind from their busy lives. There is lots of state land around; great for hunters or hikers. Very convenient in the winter time for snowmobilers. Snowmobile trails are just down the road. Hosts are just up the road if you need assistance.

Top guest favorite

A quaint cabin structure is nestled in a verdant landscape, surrounded by tall trees. The exterior features a warm wooden façade with multiple small windows, a gabled roof, and a covered porch. Lush grass and natural stone pathways lead to the entrance.

Tiny home in Cincinnatus

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

A Cozy place with Vintage notes

Welcome to the top of MT Roderick located in Cincinnatus, NY. A secluded & private home located on 6 acres of tranquil woodlands where you can reconnect with nature & yourself. A place of solidarity. Here, you will find a quaint home with a loft, access to an outhouse, fire pit & sunsets. Enjoy the night skies, moonlight & wildlife.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Pitcher vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Pitcher

A compact bathroom features a toilet and a small sink beneath a wooden mirror. A shower enclosure is visible in the background. Neutral wall tones complement the functional design.

Apartment in Cortland

4.68 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

Cozy 1 bedroom, downtown Cortland, NY (unit #6)

AmandaRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

A great location for SUNY Cortland Graduation. Everything was walkable. A very secure building with off street parking. I would recommend

Top guest favorite

The garage space is well-lit with natural light streaming through two windows. Tools and equipment are neatly organized on wall-mounted racks. A small workbench is visible along with a fridge and a ladder. The concrete floor is clean, and a mat is placed near the entrance.

Home in Truxton

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Morgan Hill Haven

KarinRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Kay was very accommodating when our son’s baseball tournament game schedule changed and we asked to change the days around. The house was everything we could have asked for. The owners are the nicest, even coming up to say hi when they heard my boys playing basketball outside. 5 out of 5, would recommend and plan on reserving the house if we have another Cortland tournament!

Guest favorite

Cottage in Smyrna

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Hidden LakeFront Retreat

SuzanneRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

Frederic's home was lovely, but what stood out was the beautiful lakefront with private dock. Frederic was very easy to work with and extremely responsive to all my questions.

Top guest favorite

A light-colored cottage entrance features a yellow door framed by large windows. The wooden steps lead to a patio adorned with potted plants. Surrounding gardens showcase vibrant greenery and blooming flowers under a clear blue sky.

Cottage in Lisle

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Turtle Pond Cottage

MathewRating, 5 stars4 months ago

This cozy cabin was a great setting for a weekend retreat. There is a plenty of space outside to spend the day exploring, in addition to other hiking opportunities a short drive away. And at the end of the day, the comfy couch in front of the wood stove is exactly where we wanted to be. Thank you Ann for being so hospitable and friendly.

Guest favorite

Home in McDonough

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 91 reviews

Peaceful Cabin w/Sacred personal healing space!

JenniferRating, 5 stars10 months ago

We had an absolutely peaceful and lovely stay at Julie’s guesthouse: an oasis for folks who need a break from the chaos of life! The property was stunning, with trails for walking, a pond with a dock, and beautiful nature to behold. We even borrowed a couple of bikes and took a nice ride around the area to Melody Lake. Julie has an incredible barn on her property that is used for yoga and other meditation activities. We were lucky enough to participate in a special sound healing with members of the local community and can’t wait to see what develops there. We plan to return any time we need a getaway + reset. The home itself is immaculate and incredibly cozy. The deck off the upstairs bedroom was perfect for morning coffee and SUPER star-gazing at night. The kitchen is well-equipped and the bathroom is perfect. We can’t say enough about our few blissful days! All of that aside, the best part was getting to know Julie. She is a special person and we are grateful our paths have crossed.

Guest favorite

A bathroom featuring a shower with a clear curtain and a bathtub. A countertop with a circular sink and decorative items is visible. A mirror hangs above the sink, and additional storage can be seen in the area. Light fixtures provide bright illumination.

Home in Cazenovia

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Cazenovia private, bright in-law apt

GloriRating, 5 stars1 week ago

An absolutely beautiful location. Cute and homey basement apartment. Very comfortable. We especially loved the pretty kitty that welcomed us and saw us off as well.

Sunlight filters through the trees, illuminating a serene creek surrounded by lush greenery. The water reflects the warm tones of the sky, creating a calming natural setting. Tall trees frame the scene, offering a tranquil backdrop for relaxation and connection with nature.

Cottage in Greene

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Adorable Cottage in the Woods

RyanRating, 5 stars8 months ago

The Cottage in the woods was exactly what we had hoped it would be, a peaceful getaway from busy life. There were so many things to like such as the friendliness that Amy and Josh displayed, or the chickens and turkeys that kept us company. Speaking of company, Maggie was a fun-loving pup who we threw a stick for and got to walk with. Meanwhile, the house was large but homey and we had lots of fun playing ping pong and enjoying the creek in the porch area. The house was also a bit chilly in the fall, but Amy and Josh were accommodating and had a space heater that made it feel much warmer. I should add that we had the pleasure of visiting during the Applefest a Greene town festival where we got to see 96 artisans and craft tents and enjoy plenty of fall food. Lastly, I just wanted to say that if you are looking to get away and have a weekend or week for yourself or with a partner then this is the place to go!

Guest favorite