Cabin vacation rentals in Otisco Lake

While the access road is not for the faint of heart and more closets/clothing storage is needed, the cabin was very clean, well-stocked and organized. There were plenty of movies to choose from and a big firepit to enjoy. The property manager, Mike, was very responsive, knowledgeable and helpful. All in all, the cabin is a lovely place to spend a few days relaxing and enjoying the incredible view.

One of the best we stayed. Awesome playroom and hot tub. Beds were super cozy. Really impressed

It was a beautiful little cabin with everything you could need and want! The breakfast they delivered was delicious! It was an all around easy and peaceful stay!

My partner and I enjoyed our stay here at the Finger Lakes! The location was perfect - no more than 15 minutes from many great activities, wineries, and restaurants, yet the space is in a rural setting that is peaceful and quiet. Loved hearing all the birds in the morning! The space was clean when we arrived. I have a food allergy so having access to such a clean kitchen saved a lot of time and stress! The kitchen was generally well stocked but note there is no microwave. Also, the hot tub specifically was also extremely clean! The bed was very comfortable, on the softer side. Would recommend others stay here!

It was a very beautiful place to stay and great for the price, the weather wasn’t cooperating fully but because of how cozy it was we didn’t really notice!

Great stay, a very cozy place!

This place is beautiful looks even nicer in person than on the pictures . It’s very peaceful and fairly easy to find they left little notes around the house to find extra linens toilet paper etc which was a very cute touch . has a lot of stuff to do outside and inside it is the perfect little get together cabin the host is very nice helpful and attentive with any questions you may have through the stay definitely recommend

The Mill Creek Cabins were perfect for my bachelorette weekend! Sara and the Mill Creek crew were incredibly friendly, responsive, and proactive with all communications. The cabins were exactly as described and were very cute and accessible. The breakfast delivered every morning was delicious and very much appreciated- it was a great little start to each morning! I highly recommend staying at any of the cabins while visiting the Finger Lakes- I definitely plan to be back in the future!

We traveled from Indiana, PA to NY, so our son could escort his friends to Whitney Point Prom. We choose Wilma, as it looked inviting & relaxing & to be honest, it far exceeded our expectations. Once we got everyone off to Prom, we were able to relax on the back deck, watching/listening to the river. We even had a small fire & the kids decided to skip the After Prom & come crash our peaceful fire. The citronella candles that Charlene provided, was a huge help with the evening bugs along the river. Sunday, we spent all day relaxing on the back deck & got dinner from Magro's. If we ever find ourselves traveling to NY again, we would definitely stay at Wilma again. If it wasn't for our Bulldog missing the other 2 pups at home, we would never have wanted to leave.

Our family of 4 and dog love this cabin- if we had our own, we’d want it to be just like this one. It’s exactly what we need to unplug, live more simply, and connect with nature for a few days. We love the woodburning stove, outdoor kitchen, stringing up our hammocks, and relaxing by or exploring the stream. Rod is a fantastic host!

Great place. Very quiet and secluded. Plenty of firewoood

My experience was excellent from the reservation to checkout. It’s a beautiful location and the home was perfect. It was better than I could’ve imagined. The description and pictures don’t do the property or cabin/cottage justice. It was very clean and we felt right at home. I needed a peaceful weekend away and it did not disappoint! Suzanne was very responsive and helpful. Great place! We’ve already talked about going back for a longer stay.

Karen's cabin was great, clean and had everything we needed for a restful evening. The property was beautiful and we wish we had more time to stay in the area for enjoy the outdoors a bit more. We will definitely stay here at a future date.

The cabin was as advertised and was perfect for a rendezvous with my sisters.

My boyfriend, 4 pups and I enjoyed our stay! We loved the fenced in yard for the dogs and the walk ability of the near by state park beach! The house was clean, well kept and easy to find. We thoroughly enjoyed the balcony off the bedroom.

It was great! First time my wife and I had a weekend alone since the birth of our son, 3+ years ago. The cabin was perfect. Quiet, clean. Close enough to Ithaca for nice dinners out and hiking, but very remote and private. Kathleen was/is a great host.

Great place right on the river! Accurately described and as expected!

Nancy’s cottage was perfect for our little family of 4. We enjoyed card games on the back porch, meals al fresco w a beautiful lake view, and of course roasting marshmallows in the fire pit at sunset. The cottage was intimate and cozy and we hope to return on a regular basis. Thank you Nancy for being inviting and more than accommodating.

This was a dreamy peaceful little place. It was a welcomed relaxing space as I just finished a year of teaching. It looked just like the photos. Had many things that one would need to enjoy your stay. I loved the updated touches and bathroom while still being a rustic cabin. The fire place is so cozy. I would stay here again in a heartbeat.

I was in for a long stay with work. This place was very peaceful and relaxing. Enjoyed the scenery of the lake and nature surrounding the house. House was very clean and up kept nicely as well. Thank you for the stay and absolutely recommend!

I grew up on this lake and I still own property there. Mine needs to be rebuilt so it was great to stay at hers. She has a great spot on the lake. Great fishing right off her docks to. Will stay again!

This has been one of the best experiences that my wife and I have ever had. Edgar was very proactive and thorough in his directions and instructions. The cabin is very peaceful and cozy. We could have stayed forever just reading on the porch or at the table inside by the window. Just about everything you would need is provided or available on the property. We look forward to returning in the future!

We had such a great time here! Heidi’s place was clean and in a great location. We loved utilizing the dock and really appreciated all the personal touches that Heidi left for us!

Pamela’s place was absolutely beautiful! We loved how secluded and peaceful it was. It was close to many different state parks and hiking trails. Pamela was very friendly and provided everything we needed for a peaceful camp like experience! I would recommend this place to everyone!