Vacation rentals with a hot tub in North Eleuthera

Great location and amenities, had everything we needed, can't wait to visit again!

It's hard to describe Paradise, but if I had to picture what it would be like it would be Cayo Loco! The beach and the water were the prettiest I have ever seen (and I have lived in Hawaii). You can walk for miles and not see anyone. To me there is nothing better than sleeping with the windows open and having the sound of the ocean waves lull you to sleep. Plenty of great things to do and wonderful places to eat. Our host would give us updates everyday with suggestions which was so helpful! They went above and beyond to make our stay the best it could be. Other than the amazing beaches, the most memorable experiences we had were with the people of Eleuthera. The culture there is to be welcoming, kind and considerate to everyone. They truly love and respect their island and want you to feel at home there. We can't wait to return and hope to stay longer this time.

Can’t say enough about Cayo Loco. The views from the patio are astonishing. Anna and Jeremy were extremely accommodating and made us feel very comfortable right off the bat. Any time we had a question our host or Anna was available to help us. We honestly could’ve spent several days just exploring the coastline right at the cottage if we didn’t venture out to see more of the island. Highly recommend Cayo Loco and will hopefully return soon!

Just got back from our second stay at this amazing property. We loved it so much last year we couldn’t help but come again! The photos are great but don’t do it justice. Seeing it in person I was blown away. The amenities and the view make this place super special. We love to explore the surrounding areas during the day and relax at “home” in the late afternoon and evenings. Great place for a morning coffee and even better place for a sunset meal. If you are fortunate enough and have the opportunity to stay at this property… DO NOT HESITATE!! For reference, it was myself, my husband and three teenagers for the week. We all loved it just the same!

Amazing property with cool amenities. Very clean, cozy, and convenient. The host and property manager were great and really made the stay enjoyable! Highly recommended.

The stay was definitely amazing private clean and comfortable I’ll be back 🥰

Our stay at Cayo Loco was truly amazing. Off the beaten path, in a private paradise. Yet close enough to town for groceries, restaurants, etc. The accommodations were just right - all details covered, the location unbeatable. Loved the views from every window all day long, the chaise lounge on the porch, the outdoor shower, the beach.

Where to start… this place is truly special. If you’re looking for a fancy resort this isn’t it, but if you want your own private insane white/pink sandy beach, local charm, and serenity this is your vacation. We were there 6 nights and saw one other person on the beach the entire time. We walked on the private beach 2 miles every morning followed by a swim in the ocean and a shower in the outdoor shower loaded with local shampoo and body wash made by a teacher on the island. We walked to pascals and had dinner and hung out with Sammy, and searched for other beaches only to realize ours was the best. It rained and we played cards inside our romantic cottage and listened to the waves. This is a special place and we will be back.