Vacation rentals in North Brother Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in North Brother Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Superhost
Private room in Harlem
4.79 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews

Lux. Bedroom in Historical Home/shared backyard

Immerse yourself in history and style at Hamilton Heights! Stay in our exclusive one guest bedroom with on suite bathroom, nestled in a historic townhouse on the most charming street in the Hamilton Heights District.Just steps from Alexander Hamilton’s Grange,enjoy perks like a complimentary bottle of Prosecco or wine,plus a pet-friendly space. Relish the unique charm of shared spaces and create lasting memories. Book your historic escape now and experience the perfect blend of past and present!

Top guest favorite
Private room in Jackson Heights
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Best location w/ parking, 10 min to LGA & subway

Hi awesome! 👋 Our home offers a private bedroom, onsite parking, bathroom, shared living room & kitchen. Great location: - Walking distance to subway trains E, F, M, R & 7 lines (0.3 miles, about 7 mins walking) - LGA airport (1.6 miles, about 10 mins drive) - JFK airport (11.5 miles, about 40 mins drive) - Manhattan (15 mins on express train or 25 mins on local train) - Walking distance to groceries, restaurants, shops, and nightlife. We live in the house so will be onsite to assist you

A cozy sleeping area is presented with a spacious bed dressed in white linens. A woven pendant light hangs above, while a small table displays a vase of greenery. Soft shadows are cast across the bedding, enhancing the serene atmosphere.
Apartment in Bronx
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 81 reviews

Sunny Apartment on Saint Mary’s Park

Stay in a clean, comfortable apartment in Mott Haven, a residential Bronx neighborhood across from Saint Mary’s Park. A home base for guests who want space, value, local food, and easy train access to both east and west sides of Manhattan. The space includes a full kitchen, quiet ductless AC/heat, comfortable mattresses, and access to a garden patio. Nearby are locally owned restaurants and bars within a 5–20 minute walk, including Mexican, Peruvian, Puerto Rican, and American food.

Guest favorite
A vibrant living space is defined by a rich teal wall adorned with various plants. A grand piano sits next to a bookshelf filled with books. Bright yellow armchairs flank a wooden coffee table, complemented by a soft area rug.
Private room in Bronx
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Sunny, colorful duplex with many plants

This spacious home is as comfortable as you can get in NYC. We have tons of space, amenities, sunlight, and plants. We are two blocks from the express trains (2 and 5), about 25 minutes to Midtown Manhattan. The South Bronx is the home of hip hop, is multicultural and is home to "real New Yorkers." It's not shiny skyscrapers and hipsters, but it's where real New York culture resides. We are registered and approved to host by NYC. Here is our registration number: OSE-STRREG-0000001

Guest favorite
Loft in Harlem
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 93 reviews

1 Min to Subway: King Bed, Luxe Airy Space + Patio

Welcome to Vintage Luxe, a stunning 1894 landmark in Sugar Hill restored into a luxurious boutique! This charming unit includes an accent fireplace, bay windows, a king bed, high-speed WiFi, a dedicated workstation, and a fully equipped kitchen. Step outside to your private patio—a rare NYC luxury. With a prime location just 1 minute from the metro and close to Yankee Stadium, this space is perfect for couples, families, or groups seeking a central and elegant stay.

Top guest favorite
A cozy bedroom features an antique brass bed with soft bedding adjacent to a wall of bookshelves filled with various literature. A decorative mirror reflects the room's warm light, while a vintage-style fireplace complements the eclectic decor. A colorful area rug enriches the floor space.
Guest suite in Washington Heights
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Elegant Uptown Historic District Garden Suite

Your pied-à-terre on Sugar Hill in the Jumel Terrace Historic District. Formerly a rare bookshop, the garden suite resounds with Harlem Heights' history from the Founding Fathers thru the Founding Brothers to our vibrant now. Think privacy, quiet, autonomy and a garden in bloom. Short walk, one subway stop, to NY/Columbia-Presbyterian. This is a two family house. Fully compliant with NYC short term rental laws. Hosts discretely present during your stay.

Top guest favorite
Townhouse in Edgewater
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

NYC Skyline View• Sleeps 8 • 2 level Private Patio

🍳Complimentary Continental Breakfast & Coffee Bar Bring your whole crew. Designer loft fits 8 guests with NYC skyline views, a private patio with Fire Pit - everything you need to settle in and explore for a weekend, a week, or the entire World Cup. 🏆 FIFA WORLD CUP 2026 Getting to the FIFA match is a breeze! Total cost ~$28 per person ➡️ 2-minute walk to the bus stop ➡️ 20 minutes to Port Authority ➡️ hop the official shuttle straight to MetLife.

Top guest favorite
Home in Riverdale
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Stylish Guest Suite in The Heart of NYC

Experience luxury in the upscale Riverdale neighborhood in our spacious, sunlit guest suite. It features a beautifully designed private bathroom and a fully equipped kitchen. The queen-sized bed and dedicated workspace create an ideal setting for relaxing and unwinding in your perfect city retreat. The house is a charming Dutch Colonial home; the suite is on the second floor with a private entrance via a walk-up staircase.

Top guest favorite
Apartment in Fairview
5.0 out of 5 average rating, 22 reviews

Designer King 1BR Near NYC | Free Parking, & Gym

Welcome to a luxury apartment featuring curated furnishings, neutral tones, statement lighting, and high-end finishes, this space is intentionally designed to feel upscale, calming, and a hotel like effect with the comfort of a home. Perfect for business travelers, couples, and NYC visitors looking for an elevated stay just minutes from Manhattan 📍 Unbeatable Location | Near NYC & Major Attractions

Guest favorite
Apartment in Harlem
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 19 reviews

Private Manhattan Retreat | Sauna, Yard + King Bed

Imagine spending the day exploring Manhattan, walking by the Hudson River, grabbing coffee, seeing the city, then coming back to your own private retreat. You step inside, relax in the sauna, put on a movie, stretch out on the king bed, or sit outside in the backyard on the hammock or swing chair. It's cozy, romantic, and peaceful, the perfect place to slow down and enjoy a special New York stay..

Guest favorite
A cozy office space features an exposed brick wall with wooden beams overhead. A light-colored sofa is positioned next to a glass coffee table. Natural light filters through sheer curtains, while shelves display decorative items and framed prints. A potted plant adds a touch of greenery.
Townhouse in Astoria
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Modern Industrial Cozy NYC Loft

Very unique and one of a kind space in a 100 year old exposed brick townhouse, with Mid-Century Style, exposed beams, massive ceilings, all new modern finishes, appliances, and state of the art technology. This home also offers a massive backyard with outdoor living space, seating area, dining, grill, and privacy for time to relax, unwind, and enjoy some downtime with your friends and family.

Top guest favorite
Private room in Harlem
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 283 reviews

Charming

Located in Central Harlem in a Brownstone close to subway stations and buses. The famous Apollo theater in close proximity also Central Park. Famous eateries close by (Sylvia’s , Red Rooster). Experience live authentic jazz just around the corner at Paris Blues Club.

Popular amenities for North Brother Island vacation rentals