Vacation rentals in New Wilmington

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in New Wilmington

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

The rustic cabin is framed by trees and features a welcoming porch with seating. Large front windows allow natural light to fill the space. A gently sloping yard leads to the entrance, providing access to the inviting outdoor area.

Cabin in Andover

4.77 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Cozy Cabin (Ohio side Pymatuning Lake)

Take a step back and make time to create some wonderful memories at our cozy, rustic cabin that was built in early 50s. Hiking/boating/fishing near! Basic cable/HBO/Starz!/Encore HDTV; DVD player. Microwave, drip coffeemaker, toaster,griddle, crockpot, pans, dishes,utensils. Linens,towels; quilts and cozy comforters on beds. Furnace/AC/Woodburner Cozy coffee deck off kitchen. Gas grill; firepit area with seating. Plenty of room to park/plug in boat or pontoon. ☆Not a party cabin. ☆NON-SMOKING.

Superhost

The kitchen is designed with dark cabinetry and a large wooden island, featuring bar stools for seating. Stainless steel appliances are visible, including an oven and a refrigerator. Light reflects off the backsplash, enhancing the spacious layout which connects to the dining area.

Home in Bristolville

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 121 reviews

Clean & Comfy, Sleeps 8, Boat Trailer Parking

Enjoy this quaint and homey ranch in a peaceful rural setting. 2 nice bedrooms and 2 full baths. Although the floors are not level and nature keeps trying to reclaim the landscaping, we work hard to make it super clean and comfy. All the necessities are provided for a great stay. Circular drive will park several boat trailers. Our 5 star reviews are not because we try to compete with a 5 star hotel but because we give you exactly what we promise, a clean, comfortable "home away from home."

Guest favorite

Home in Grove City

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

GC & SR #1 Premier Air B&B! Safari, Outlets, Amish.

Mallards Landing: The areas #1 Premier Air B&B! Luxury, beauty and comfort in every room! Enjoy breath taking views & wildlife including Deer, Ducks, Geese, & a family of Cranes in the yard daily. Exotic Safari animals' feet from the driveway entrance. 8 min or less from GC & SR and all of their amenities. Colleges, Outlets, local restaurants, Brewery, Amish and more. More than a place to stay an experience your entire family will never forget! Ask about our new relaxation / Theater room!

Superhost

A well-lit entryway showcases a wooden staircase with a floral wallpaper runner. A decorative chandelier hangs overhead, illuminating the space. An arched doorway leads to a softly furnished room with light-colored furnishings and a fireplace visible in the background.

Home in Butler

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 92 reviews

Weekly discount. Pet friendly. Walk to dine/shop.

Luxurious & spacious home one block off Main St. with 3 master suites. Sleeps 8. Each suite features a King Bed. One suite offers a sitting area, one an attached Living Room, & one an attached living room with queen sleeper sofa & two arm chairs. Each suite comes with private bath. All bedrooms offer Smart TVs & additional TV's in living rooms. Free WIFI. Amenities including a formal dining room, kitchen, billiard room, sitting room, & speakeasy/lounge. There’s an outdoor deck w/ seating

Guest favorite

A welcoming entryway is highlighted by a large television displaying a warm fireplace scene. Natural wood paneling adorns the walls, complemented by a patterned rug. A comfortable chair is placed beside the entrance, creating a cozy atmosphere for guests.

Cabin in Cortland

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Cheerful Cabin-Sleeps 5 - lake views + relaxation

This unique place has a style all its own. This adorable cabin is located steps away from Mosquito Lake, bars and restaurants, bait shops, public boat launch and minutes away from lovely wineries. Perfect for small families or couples. This cabin has been professionally designed and updated. Relax on the deck and listen to live music during the summer months. The sleeping space is a loft separated by a wall. Queen bed on one side, double bed and a single up top on the other side.

Top guest favorite

A private deck area is visible, featuring a woven chair and a patterned rug. Beyond the deck, a green lawn extends towards a distant blue house, framed by trees. Clear skies are overhead, enhancing the tranquil outdoor setting.

Cottage in Mercer

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Charming Farm Cottage

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful homestead cottage nestled among mature pines. Scenic views and tasty natural treats abound on the guest house of this 6 acre homestead. Enjoy an evening by the wood stove or watch the sunrise from the pet friendly deck. Ask about lawn games or access to pool and spa attached at the owners' residence down the lane. Located minutes away from fishing lakes, colleges, state parks, game land, and Downtown Mercer. Easy access from I-79, I-80.

Guest favorite

An outdoor deck area features a dining table surrounded by four metal chairs, set against a backdrop of lush greenery. The space is illuminated by natural light, creating a serene environment that connects with the surrounding trees and landscape.

Home in Warren

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Serene Retreat Near The Grand Resort

Welcome to your spacey and eclectic oasis, nestled conveniently near The Grand Resort! Sink into luxurious bedding and let the dreamscape surroundings transport you to a world of relaxation. The outdoor area is a true gem, featuring a lush garden and a variety of seating options that invite you to unwind and bask in the serenity. Whether you're sipping your morning coffee or enjoying a glass of wine under the stars, this space offers a perfect balance of nature and comfort.

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen features white cabinetry and sleek granite countertops, complemented by stainless steel appliances. An island serves as a central workspace, and ample overhead lighting enhances the inviting atmosphere. The flooring in a subtle dark tone adds a contemporary touch to the overall design.

Home in Monaca

5 out of 5 average rating, 48 reviews

Rivers Edge 2.0

This stylish place to stay is perfect for anyone needing a very spacious and comfortable atmosphere. This house is on the best street in town quiet yet right in the center of everything. A short walk to everything. Three blocks from river access. Modern and completely remodeled with granite counter and custom cabinets. Very large primary suite with a second master suite as well. There is a half bath and full laundry. This house has large windows and a private driveway.

Top guest favorite

Home in Columbiana

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Charming Home Walking Distance to Main Street!

Welcome to Your Home Away From Home! Experience relaxed country living in our newly renovated haven. Walk to local attractions like Birdfish Brewing, Generations Café, R’s Pizza Place, and Hogan’s Baking. Explore Main Street for unique shops and restaurants. Enjoy outdoor activities at Firestone Park with its pool, courts, and more. Conveniently just a 2-minute drive to Route 11. Enjoy the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience. Book your stay today!

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Mercer

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 62 reviews

Mermaid Inn romantic house on the lake

Gorgeous house on the private lake with King master suite and minutes away from shopping (Prime Outlets), dining ( large restaurant selection), wining (winery) and skydiving ( local airport one mile away) , the house has beautiful woods for hiking and private lake for kayaking and fishing. Located only 5 min away from Rt79 it feels like it’s completely removed from hustle and bustle of modern life. Fully equipped kitchen and beautiful views

Top guest favorite

Home in New Wilmington

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Cozy country home sleeps up to 9 guests

Fully renovated home. Sleeps up to 9. Luxury bedding and appointments, full kitchen. Basement has separate television and couch as well as ping pong and foosball tables. Perfect for couples' getaway, weddings, funerals, college parent days and fishermen plying our amazing area trout streams. Close to Hermitage, New Castle, Butler and Youngstown. One hour to Pittsburgh and 1:30 to Cleveland, Akron and Erie.

Top guest favorite

Cabin in North Bloomfield

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Caroma Lake Cabin- Perfect Family Getaway

If you are looking for a great secluded vacation with a change of scenery or a relaxing getaway to unplug, this is the place you have been looking for. The cabin is nestled in acres of woods and pasturelands and overlooks the lake. Spend the days relaxing, fishing and hanging out on the water. A great getaway for family and friends.