Skip to content

Vacation rentals in Long Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Long Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Tiny's Hurricane Hole  - Sea Grape BEACH Cottage
SUPERHOST
Entire cottage · 2 guests · 1 bed · 1 bath
Tiny's Hurricane Hole - Sea Grape BEACH CottageBahamas "Clean & Pristine" Certified. Cute little beach club on a quaint family island SEA GRAPE COTTAGE = TOES IN THE SAND VACATION. Close to restaurants and services. You’ll love this place because of the cleanliness, coziness, the location, and views. Tiny's is good for couples, solo adventurers, business travelers, families (with kids), and furry friends (pets).
Kooters Comfy Studio with Kingbed, Sea View & Deck
SUPERHOST
Entire loft · 4 guests · 2 beds · 1 bath
Kooters Comfy Studio with Kingbed, Sea View & DeckThe moment you open the front door of Kooters Vacation Rentals, you will enter vacation mode as you see the calming views of the mangroves where you will witness amazing birds and beautiful fish in their natural habitat. Enjoy the spectacular sunsets. You will fall asleep listening to the sound of the sea. CAR RENTAL Kooters' Car Rentals will be available to our guests at an additional cost. Please ask about this option when booking your stay with us for a great rate.
New Listing Tiny's Hurricane Hole - Palms Cottage
SUPERHOST
Entire cottage · 2 guests · 1 bed · 1 bath
New Listing Tiny's Hurricane Hole - Palms CottageBRAND NEW - THE PALMS COTTAGE Beach Chic King 1 Bed Room with Gin Blue Sea Views . . . just steps away from toes in the sand relaxation or enjoying a cool drink in the tropical breeze at Tiny's beach bar and grill (ranked one of the 10 top beach bars in the Bahamas). A PICTURESQUE LITTLE BEACH CLUB ON A QUAINT FAMILY ISLAND IN THE SOUTHEASTERN BAHAMAS.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

  • Homes
  • Hotels
  • Unique stays

Popular amenities for Long Island vacation rentals

  • Kitchen
  • Wifi
  • Pool
  • Free parking on premises
  • Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Long Island

  1. Entire bungalow
  2. Stella Maris
Two Turtles ocean villa: A new gem on Long Island
G$55,456 per night
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Stella Maris
Half Moon Cottage - Ocean Views in Stella Maris
G$25,112 per night
  1. Tiny house
  2. Turtle Cove
Off grid tiny home at Dean's Blue Hole
G$15,695 per night
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Stella Maris
Home living by the Ocean
G$36,622 per night
No reviews yet
  1. Entire villa
  2. McKann's Settlement
Entire Home - Private, Tranquil, Ocean Front
G$78,475 per night
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Salt Pond
Studio Apartments with Beach
G$18,834 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Clarence Town
Shukeena:Place of Peace & Happiness
G$34,529 per night
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Long Island
Tangerine Sunsets Long Island Pinta
G$20,717 per night
No reviews yet
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Long Island
**NEW LISTING** Cozy 2 bed/2 bath cottage
G$25,112 per night
  1. Entire cottage
  2. Whymms Long Island
“Mermansion” - Private beach Boat Rental Included
G$60,687 per night
  1. Entire residential home
  2. Long Island
Beachfront Home in Miley!
G$60,687 per night
SUPERHOST
  1. Entire rental unit
  2. Stella Maris
Apt for rent, walking distance to pool & beach!
G$19,880 per night

Your guide to Long Island

Welcome to Long Island

A literal paradise for divers, anglers, and sailors, Long Island is the hidden gem of the Bahamas. Known as the most scenic island in the entire country, it boasts brilliantly colored coral reefs, picturesque beaches, and oceans teeming with life. Here, island life prevails, dictated by the rolling ocean, with the main activities including sailing, fishing, scuba diving, free diving, and snorkeling. You’ll need a few hours’ rest and recuperation between adventures, probably sunbathing in the balmy temperatures.

This secluded oasis offers 80 miles of lush, untamed greenery and unspoiled sparkling waters. The east coast features rugged cliffs and endless caves, while the quieter west coast offers expanses of white sand and turquoise sea and some of the world’s most beautiful beaches. Adventure awaits divers at Dean’s Blue Hole, the second deepest underwater sinkhole in the world. Foodies won’t be disappointed either: The island’s best-known delicacy, conch, is a delicately flavored seafood available in every form imaginable. Just 45 minutes from Nassau by plane, Long Island offers a laid-back and authentic Bahamian vibe that you can’t help but love.


How do I get around Long Island?

Getting to Long Island is easier than you may think. For many travelers, it’s just two flights away. Lynden Pindling International Airport (NAS) in New Providence is the most likely destination for international arrivals. From there, it’s a 45-minute hop to one of the island’s two airports, Stella Maris (SML) and Deadman’s Cay (LGI). Once on Long Island, visitors can rent a car or use a local taxi service to get around. Navigation is easy, with just one main road, the Queen’s Highway, running the length (around 80 miles) of the isle. For an even more relaxing way to get around, visitors can opt for a guided boat tour taking in the island’s hidden beaches.


When is the best time to stay in a vacation rental in Long Island?

Not far above the equator and smack dab in the middle of the Caribbean Sea, Long Island offers warm tropical weather all year long. Temperatures generally stay within a narrow band of warm but not too hot, as is typical of a Caribbean island. Even on “chilly” nights, a long-sleeved shirt will suffice — no need for a winter coat here! The best time to visit for warm-weather activities is between late November and mid-May, while the peak travel season ranges from mid-December to mid-April. The low season is more humid and cloudier, but visitors willing to risk a little more rainfall will find the island even more tranquil than usual. Be aware that the Atlantic hurricane season ranges from June through November. The island does fall within the hurricane belt, although serious storms are rare.


What are the top things to do in Long Island?

Dean’s Blue Hole

Perhaps the island’s biggest draw is Dean’s Blue Hole, the second-deepest underwater sinkhole in the world, which plunges to an awe-inspiring depth of 663 feet. With exceptional visibility, divers will love this paradise with its incredible untouched reefs and vast variety of tropical sea life. Travelers not wishing to descend into the depths can safely enjoy the beauty of the blue hole from the waist-deep surrounding water, and the sheltered nature of the bay makes it ideal for novice swimmers and kids.

Saint Mary the Virgin Anglican Church

For lovers of history, Long Island features the oldest church in the country. Now a romantic ruin, the vast stone building is thought to have been built by the Spanish in the 17th century. The picturesque structure makes the perfect backdrop for an island sunset.

Hamilton’s Cave

The largest cave system in the Bahamas, this complex of passageways, some more than 45 feet wide, features a host of stalagmites, stalactites, and other fascinating rock formations. The caves are also home to a bat colony that comes alive around dusk. The property’s owner provides a guided tour and flashlights to ensure you don’t need to worry about getting left behind in the dark.