Vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A vibrant sunset paints the sky in shades of orange and pink, silhouetting the surrounding pine trees and snow-covered landscape. The horizon features rolling hills, creating a serene and picturesque backdrop for the tranquil scene.
Home in Custer
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Custer Blue Bird Haven in Beautiful Valley Setting

"Bluebird House -guests have entire house-3 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, 2 living rooms, a full kitchen with a good dishwasher. There’s a Kitchenette in the lower level. Also, a Gas Fire Pit on lower level deck- available to guests, UNLESS Fire Danger’s high- will be removed. There’s a total of 3 queen-sized beds & 4 single beds, in the new expanded Blue Bird Haven, which can sleep 10 guests. Basic de'cor- relaxing! Enjoy Incredible sun sets & solitude in the beautiful Black Hills “Valley” setting!

Top guest favorite
Chalet in Lead
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews

Spearfish Canyon Skye lodge

Skyelodge is located in the heart of Spearfish Canyon. Located on a cliff wall . A 750 Sq. Ft. apartment on the top floor of a private vacation home. Spearfish Falls and Roughlock Falls one mile away can be accessed by hiking trails. FANTASTIC VIEWS! ( DEER, ELK, BALD EAGLES, PEREGINE FALCONS, OSPREYS, VULTURES ARE YOUR NEIGHBORS) HIKING, BIKING, ROCK CLIMBING, PHOTOGRAPHY, TROUT FISHING, OR JUST HANGING OUT. THE STARS AT NIGHT. GREAT COUPLES RETREAT!

Top guest favorite
A modern living area is presented with a brown leather sofa and two green chairs. A round coffee table sits in the center on a patterned rug. Art prints adorn the walls, and large glass doors provide views of the surrounding trees.
Home in Spearfish
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Spearfish 2bd1ba/Bonus RV Spot

Brand new modern cabin on private acreage nestled in the pine trees. Enjoy a quiet stay 10 minutes from Spearfish. -1 Bedroom w/ queen bed -1 bedroom w/ king bed -Full Bathroom -Washer/Dryer Starlink internet is provided which allows for remote working and streaming services on the TV. Traveling with someone with a camper? A bonus RV spot is located next to the cabin with full electric/water/sewer hookups for an extra fee. Please message before booking for camper pricing details/restrictions.

Guest favorite
An inviting interior showcases a spacious living area with wood accents. A serene view of two bedrooms is visible in the background, featuring cozy queen beds. A rustic charm is highlighted by the wooden beam accent wall and decor, enhancing the cabin's welcoming atmosphere.
Cabin in Keystone
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

The Notch Cabin - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Notch Cabin is part of Hinterwood Inn & Cabins, situated 60 ft. from National Forest. Enjoy hiking and wildlife sightings from your front door! The cabin has 2 bedrooms, each with a queen bed, a queen murphy bed in the living room, a bathroom with a shower (no tub), and an apartment size kitchen w/ essentials. Custom built by the owners, enjoy the beautiful wooden accent wall, pine slab table, and vaulted ceilings. Includes a private deck with a gas grill, private fire pit area, and more!

Top guest favorite
The loft features a cozy sleeping area with a spacious bed dressed in a light blanket. Bright pillows add a pop of color. Natural light fills the room from a large window with red curtains, and a smaller window enhances the airy feel. A decorative feature stands nearby.
Loft in Lead
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 683 reviews

Harley Court Loft

Cozy loft in the Lead, SD. Moments from downtown, but secluded. Minutes to outdoor activities, skiing, snowshoeing, hiking, biking, or snowmobiling. Winter months, all wheel / 4 wheel drive vehicle is a must!! Close to restaurants, brew pub, and night life!! Kitchenette: microwave, coffee maker, toaster, hot plate, (with pans), and small frig. The loft has electric heat and portable AC. There are 18 steps to get to the loft, for two people. Not kid proof. No pets accepted.

Guest favorite
Cabin in Custer
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 199 reviews

★Nature Stay with Views Like No Where Else★

This home is truly one-of-a-kind and straight out of a magazine! Beautifully modern and furnished to an exceptional standard. Open the windows and let the soothing sounds of the nearby creek transport you to your own private paradise. Located close to Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse Memorial, Custer State Park, and many other top attractions, you’re also just under 5 minutes from Hill City. We truly believe this is the ultimate spot to fully experience the breathtaking beauty of the Black Hills.

Guest favorite
A modern kitchen features dark cabinetry and high-end appliances that complement a spacious island. A round wooden dining table with upholstered chairs is surrounded by natural light streaming through the windows, while stylish bar stools offer additional seating at the counter.
Home in Rapid City
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

Modern Luxury Bungalow steps from DT Activities

Right in the heart of downtown, just a quick 5-minute stroll to restaurants, shops, and coffee spots, this modern, luxurious bungalow features a queen-size bedroom, a full kitchen with high-end appliances, and a dining table with cozy club chairs for ultimate comfort. Its prime location offers easy access to all the main routes leading to anywhere else you might want to explore in the Black Hills. Private parking & glowing reviews praise both the home’s quality and exceptional guest service.

Guest favorite
A spacious hot tub with lights is positioned on a wooden deck, surrounded by a protective wall. Snow covers the steps leading to the tub, while a small side table is visible next to it. Warm ambient lighting highlights the tub's inviting surface.
Cabin in Sturgis
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 249 reviews

Pet friendly 2 bedroom log cabin with hot tub.

This beautiful large 2 bedroom cabin nestled right outside of Sturgis SD can comfortably accommodate several guests, as it has 2 bedrooms as well as 2 living rooms. One of the living rooms has 2 fold out twin beds. 7 person hot tub! patio furniture as well. This cabin gives you the privacy you need yet the comforts of being 5 mins from a grocery store. Gorgeous views of the Black Hills. Fully furnished home. BBQ grill. We have a few different airbnbs and the cabin is completely private.

Guest favorite
The exterior of the cabin showcases a green facade with light trim and a welcoming porch area. A central door with a decorative panel is flanked by a large window on one side. Surrounding grassy areas and trees contribute to the natural setting.
Cabin in Rapid City
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Relax at Luxury Aspen Cottage at Black Elk Resort

Welcome to your getaway in the Black Hills with rustic charm and modern amenities. This 2-bedroom cabin offers a tranquil retreat where you can immerse yourself in breathtaking views and serene surroundings. Boasting two inviting bedrooms, a convenient kitchenette, our cabin is fully ADA compliant, ensuring accessibility for all guests. With all the comforts of home and the capacity to accommodate up to 6 guests, the “Aspen” cottage promises a rejuvenating getaway amidst nature’s embrace.

Top guest favorite
An open-concept living space features a modern kitchen with wooden cabinetry and white appliances. A dining table for four is positioned next to a cozy seating area with a stylish chair and gray couch. Natural light fills the room from a skylight above.
Apartment in Rapid City
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

118 Main - Apt. 6

Central down town location? Check! Private covered parking? Check! Washer and Dryer? Check! A hard to beat base camp for a South Dakota adventure. See the Black Hills and Badlands by day, park the car and walk to restaurants and entertainment for the evening. Bring your mountain bike and hit the urban trails, or make your way to the bike path along Rapid Creek for a peaceful in town ride. 1 bedroom apartment will sleep 4, that is 2 people on the bed and 2 on the sleeper sofa.

Guest favorite
An elegant guest house showcases a unique design with large wooden doors and stone details at the entrance. The exterior features a mix of dark siding and shingle roofing. Surrounding greenery and a rocky hillside complement the peaceful setting.
Home in Rapid City
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews

Castle in the Sky

Are you looking for a luxurious, unique place to stay? This house sits overlooking Rapid City with incredible skyline views, every evening is as picture perfect as the glowing city lights. This unique house is a fun mix of eclectic and fancy. Originally built as a local builder's "Coup de Grande", he ended up only finishing the guest house. You will find high-end finishes mixed with eclectic choices. We promise this will be one of the most memorable places you'll ever stay!

Top guest favorite
The log home features a welcoming exterior with a prominent flag and a covered porch. The structure is surrounded by a lush green lawn, leading to a backdrop of tall trees. A stone wall adds natural texture to the landscape.
Apartment in Hill City
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Burro Burrow - Basement Apartment on 8 Acres

Walk out basement of log home. Sits on partially wooded 8 acres. Walk/ride to nearby national forest access. Mickelson trail minutes away. Approximately 2.5 miles from Hill City, short drive to Mount Rushmore, Keystone, 1880 Train, Sylvan Lake, Needles Highway, and Custer State Park. You can't ask for a better location with seclusion, space, wild turkey and deer, and stunning star filled night skies. An ideal place to unwind and let the kids explore!

Popular amenities for Horse Thief Lake vacation rentals