Vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Horse Thief Lake

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A spacious living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the room. Comfortable seating options, including brown armchairs and a cozy couch, surround a round coffee table. The dining area has a long table, and sliding doors open to a private deck with outdoor seating.

Cabin in Custer

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 187 reviews

★Nature Stay with Views Like No Where Else★

This home is magazine worthy and one of a kind! Modernly furnished to an excellent standard. It is the ideal retreat for a secluded & nature-bound stay. You can open the windows and let the sounds of the creek make you feel like you are in paradise. It is Conveniently located near Mount Rushmore, Crazy Horse, Custer State Park, and other major tourist destinations. It's less than 5 minutes to Hill City! We believe it is the ultimate location to immerse yourself in the beauty of the Black Hills.

Top guest favorite

A scenic view showcases the cabin nestled amongst tall pine trees, surrounded by expansive green meadows. A winding gravel driveway leads to the property, with a seasonal pond visible in the foreground, reflecting the clear blue sky.

Home in Hill City

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 248 reviews

Cabin on 20 acres w/ horses, goats, mini donkey

Enjoy country living close to town! Two bedrooms w/ queen size beds and loft w/ queen size pullout sofa allow you to comfortably sleep 6! Just 4 miles from downtown Hill City. Sits on 20 beautiful acres surrounded on 3 sides by Forest Service! Enjoy beautiful surroundings - a seasonal pond outside your cabin (water level varies), horses, mini donkey, mini goats and chickens. Enjoy private setting with the convenience of the owners just 1/4 mile up the driveway to take care of your needs!

Guest favorite

The rounded exterior of the lodge is crafted from wood, featuring a unique entrance door and a circular window. Set against a clear blue sky, the structure is surrounded by grassy land, with trees in the background, creating a serene outdoor setting.

Hut in Hermosa

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Elkview Lodge

Furnished with a King bed, coffee-bar, and breakfast table. Private outdoor seating area with lighting, gas and wood fire pit. Wood avail to purchase. Restroom-guest fav, a few minutes’ walk and located in a shared building, not in unit, pictures in listing. AC in summer (June 1) and electric heater in winter. Non aggressive dogs allowed. No bathroom in unit! Self-check in. Directions are sent the morning of arrival. If your unit requires a passcode, that will be sent upon booking. No WIFI

Superhost

A large lodging building is shown, featuring a combination of wood and stone exterior. The front showcases a spacious deck with wooden railings, surrounded by trees. A garage door is visible on the left side, contributing to the rustic, natural atmosphere of the area.

Guest suite in Keystone

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 381 reviews

Wild, Wild West Experience

On 10 private acres in the heart of the Black Hills, this airbnb offers the best of both worlds—just 8 minutes to Mount Rushmore and 15 minutes to Rapid City. Surrounded by thr National Forest, it’s the perfect home base for exploring the area's sights and scenic drives. After a day of adventure, unwind where you can soak in the views, spot deer wandering through the trees, and enjoy the quiet sounds of nature. It’s the perfect spot to relax, recharge, and plan your next day in the hills.

Top guest favorite

A rustic lodge is nestled among trees, featuring a wide front porch with wooden beams and an American flag. The entrance is framed by large wooden doors, and the landscape includes a gravel path leading up to the building surrounded by greenery.

Cabin in Keystone

5 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

GlassLodge, SD Bucketlist to Stay

This unique place has a style all its own. Leave the busy world behind and become part of the wildlife and natural surroundings this unique lodge has to offer. All the rooms feature several windows so you can enjoy the views of granite outcroppings and majestic trees in every direction. The great room has 14 foot ceilings, a giant wood burning fireplace and floor to ceiling windows on three sides. Glass Lodge is stocked amenities. This lodge is located only miles from Mount Rushmore!

Guest favorite

Aerial view of a house situated on a hillside, showcasing surrounding lush greenery and rolling terrain. The expansive skyline of Rapid City is visible in the distance, bathed in soft evening light, while winding roads lead through the scenic landscape.

Home in Rapid City

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Castle in the Sky

Are you looking for a luxurious, unique place to stay? This house sits overlooking Rapid City with incredible skyline views, every evening is as picture perfect as the glowing city lights. This unique house is a fun mix of eclectic and fancy. Originally built as a local builder's "Coup de Grande", he ended up only finishing the guest house. You will find high-end finishes mixed with eclectic choices. We promise this will be one of the most memorable places you'll ever stay!

Guest favorite

A small wooden cabin with a blue roof is surrounded by greenery. Flower boxes are placed under the window, complemented by rustic decor elements such as an old wagon wheel and metal barrel. The peaceful country setting is highlighted by the dense trees in the background.

Home in Keystone

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Hill top Cabin. #4

Small cabin, 2 miles from Mt.Rushmore and walking distance to Keystone, SD shops. Just a queen bed, AC, refrigerator, shower and deck overlooking Battle Creek, 30 feet below. Scenic views of surrounding forest hilltops and canyon. We also have another cozy cabin #5 if this cabin isn't available or if you'd like to book both for a party of 4, just click on our host (Diane's) photo to see both cabin listings. Seasonal openings. June 1- Oct. 11. Not open winter months.

Top guest favorite

A covered porch is displayed with two wooden chairs positioned in front. Large glass doors reveal a spacious dining area and kitchen, featuring dark cabinetry and modern appliances. The floor appears polished and reflects the warm lighting from overhead fixtures.

Home in Hill City

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Hill City Hideaway on the Mickelson Trail

Location, location, location. Hill City is located in the center of the Black Hills and this house is within walking distance of the best parts of Hill City. 40 feet to the world famous Mickelson Trail, 1/2 a block to the 1880s steam train, and 3 blocks to the best restaurant in South Dakota. This home is not too big and not too small. Whether you are doing a couples get away, traveling with kids or your friends this home may be "just right" for you.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a modern guesthouse displays a blend of wood and stone accents, framed by a well-maintained lawn. A small tree and a rock landscaping feature are visible, while the sky above showcases a clear evening hue.

Farm stay in Rapid City

5 out of 5 average rating, 218 reviews

Luxury Ranch Stay

Be our guest on 40 private and fully gated acres. From all windows of the house you can watch 2 horses and cattle grazing through the meadow. The evening sunsets are magical with deer & turkeys wandering through. Relax under the stars at our fire pit (all supplies provided). Let your kids run wild with water guns & a water fall pond to refill at! Located right off HWY 16 makes you only 10 minutes to downtown Rapid City and 20 minutes to Mt. Rushmore!

Top guest favorite

The A-frame cabin is framed by tall pine trees, showcasing a blend of wood and metal in its exterior design. Warm lights illuminate the structure, highlighting the large windows and inviting entrance. A stairway leads to the deck, enhancing accessibility to the cozy retreat.

Tiny home in Custer

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Modern A-Frame Cabin Next to Custer State Park

Enjoy this spacious modern A-Frame Cabin. Located just 5 minutes to Custer State Park. Experience views of the Needles Highway and Black Elk Peak while you drink your morning coffee! You will have access to the entire house all to yourself! Great area to hike, bike, see the fluffy buffalo. Just a two minute drive to downtown Custer. This area has great ATV and kayak, trail ride rentals near by! Feel refreshed when you stay in this rustic gem.

Top guest favorite

An inviting interior showcases a spacious living area with wood accents. A serene view of two bedrooms is visible in the background, featuring cozy queen beds. A rustic charm is highlighted by the wooden beam accent wall and decor, enhancing the cabin's welcoming atmosphere.

Cabin in Keystone

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

The Notch Cabin - Hinterwood Inn & Cabins

The Notch Cabin is a brand new cabin at Hinterwood Inn & Cabins situated just 60 ft. from National Forest, making hiking right out your front door easy. This cabin has two bedrooms each with a queen bed, queen murphy bed in the living room, on bathroom, a beautiful beam accent wall, barn doors, wood floors, apartment size kitchen, a private deck with a gas grill, private fire pit areas, and more! All brand new!

Top guest favorite

A modern tiny cabin features reflective walls, blending into the surrounding nature. Tall trees and a blue sky are mirrored on the surface, creating a seamless connection with the forest. The cabin's structure is set among rocky terrain, emphasizing its unique design.

Tiny home in Lead

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Mirror Cabin in the Black Hills

You'll love this unique and romantic escape. This tiny mirror cabin, REFLECT+RECONNECT, is nestled in the serene beauty of the Black Hills of South Dakota. It creates a rejuvenating and memorable experience. This unique retreat is designed to offer you a chance to disconnect from the hustle and bustle of everyday life and reconnect with the special person in your life, yourself, and the surrounding nature.