
Vacation rentals in Hinckley Reservoir
Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb
Top-rated vacation rentals in Hinckley Reservoir
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

Herkimer Hideaway woodland retreat.
A woodland private drive and bubbling brook in front of this unique southwestern design home. Seasonally your senses will come alive with the sights & sounds of nature at its best! See wild flowers, attracting hummingbirds, butterflies, and deer from your deck. Enjoy morning coffee on the deck , a stroll on the private walking trail; or a beverage stargazing by the fire pit. For the adventurer, both the Adirondacks and many famous Herkimer Diamond mines are only a short drive away!

Amazing Tree House on Black River Near Old Forge
Perched in privacy on the Black River is a rustic Tree House designed for adults only who are looking to be off the grid and connect with Mother Nature. Glamping at its best! The very private Tree House is perched on a hill overlooking the peaceful river. The quaint treehouse has five sides of glass and screens to view the river. This is built around trees but you enter from ground level. A power pack is available to charge cell phones and make coffee. Relax by a campfire at river's edge.

Adirondack Luxury Cabin w/HOT TUB &Lake Pond (NEW)
The WheelHouse is a one-of-a-kind luxury stay featuring a 14-foot water wheel flowing over 22,000 gallons daily. Set in a scenic, private location with its own pond and lake access, it blends nature with comfort. Ideal for bird watching, fall foliage, and animal lovers. Enjoy an outdoor hot tub, indoor soaking tub, and kayaking! This property is perfect for romantic getaways, weddings (venue fee), or family stays. Pet-friendly and kid-friendly, located directly on the C-4 snowmobile trail!

Lakefront Privacy with Stunning Views
Welcome to Camp Stardust! A great spot to find peace among nature, in an exceptional setting. Wrapped in windows, the cabin offers panoramic views and frequent wildlife sightings. Enjoy outstanding kayaking with easy access from your private boathouse. IMPORTANT: our amazing housekeeper is available Monday and Friday. We offer Mon-Fri, Fri-Mon, Mon-Mon or Fri-Fri stays. Please request one of these combinations so we can accept your request. On occassion we can make an exception. Thanks!

Lakeview loft cabin on Hinckley Lake
The Lakeview Loft Cabin *** INFARED SAUNA NOW AVAILABLE***. Escape to this serene 3-bedroom lake front cabin in Remsen, NY Comfortably sleeps 6 (up to 8 with a sofa sleeper). Enjoy lake access, a bonfire pit, and a cozy stone fireplace with a gas insert. Perfect for outdoor enthusiasts with easy access to snowmobile trails and nearby ski hills. Whether you're relaxing by the water or exploring the area, this peaceful retreat offers the perfect blend of comfort and adventure year-round.

Collier’s Hideout- A cozy, brookside escape
At Collier’s Hideout you’ll find everything you love about camping the wilderness, blended with comfort in a cozy furnished apartment. Enjoy hiking over 4 acres of private forest, and wind down with the sounds of ‘Mad Tom’ at a brook-side common area providing a Blackstone griddle in a screened in pavilion. Free campfire wood included with your stay so you can enjoy s’mores if you just can’t be pulled away from the peaceful serenity, then retire in comfort in a comfortable apartment.

Your Nest in the Woods Treehouse
Your Nest in the Woods Treehouse is a great place for adults to feel like a kid again and to unwind in the woods or down by the water! A cozy get-away for couples, or small group get together! (The Nest is not suitable children or pets). The tree house has front and back decks. Under the treehouse is a sheltered picnic table area, propane grill, and a wood fire pit and outdoor games. Hang out by the overlook and enjoy the view or follow trail down to Fish Creek water access.

River Retreat: Sauna, Hot Tub, Cold Plunge & More
Escape to the Upstate River Retreat—a haven for wellness and design lovers alike. Relax in the hot tub, rejuvenate in the cedar sauna with a stunning glass front overlooking the river, and refresh with cold plunges & an outdoor shower. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed with ultimate comfort and impeccable style at the forefront. This river-front escape is the perfect destination for a full reset of mind, body, and soul—leave real life behind and return renewed.

Private Tiny House - with Hot Tub & Sauna
Retreat to a luxurious tiny house at the foothills of the Adirondacks, offering the perfect blend of seclusion with nearby restaurants, shops, and activities. High-end amenities, a peaceful atmosphere, and thoughtful details make this more than just a place to stay—it’s a memorable experience. Step out to scenic views, unwind in the hot tub, relax in the sauna, and gather around the fire table, surrounded by tranquility and convenience.

Hot Tub! Riverfront NEW ADK Cozy Cabin B!
Located on the Great Sacandaga River, this brand-new cabin features a hot tub, queen bedroom, bunk room and beautiful river views from the covered porch and patio area with gazebo. Enjoy the riverfront property with picnic area, fire pits and corn hole boards. Nestled in the woods, this vacation destination features plenty of space to relax, play and make memories in the heart of the Adirondacks.

The Boathouse on Fourth Lake
This historic boathouse is a rare find, situated directly in the waters of the popular Fourth Lake in Old Forge. Complete unobstructed lake views from all three sides of the home provide breathtaking sights during all four seasons. Enjoy the spacious dock, the open concept living area, swim in the private sandy bottom waterfront, and bask in the all-day sun provided by the north shore.

Farm stay w/ Alpaca walk included @ The Stead
Welcome to "THE STEAD" @ Lyons Family Homestead. A unique secluded tiny home nestled up on the hill of our 19-acre farm. Surrounded by nature and lots of friendly animals. We created this space as a place to escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. We encourage you to unplug and unwind as you soak in life on the farm here.
Popular amenities for Hinckley Reservoir vacation rentals
Other great vacation rentals in Hinckley Reservoir

Piseco Lake House

Adirondack Escape - Kayaks, Private Pond, Firepit

Big Cat Bungalows at The Haven - Tiger 4

Cozy 4-Bedroom Home in South-Utica

Waterfront country cottage getaway

Sixth Lake Retreat

One of a Kind Downtown Loft. Steps to Everything.

Arthur Acres
Destinations to explore
- Plainview Vacation rentals
- New York Vacation rentals
- Tuckahoe Vacation rentals
- Long Island Vacation rentals
- Montreal Vacation rentals
- Greater Toronto and Hamilton Area Vacation rentals
- Greater Toronto Area Vacation rentals
- Boston Vacation rentals
- East River Vacation rentals
- Mississauga Vacation rentals
- Hudson Valley Vacation rentals
- Jersey Shore Vacation rentals
- Green Lakes State Park
- Glimmerglass State Park
- Sylvan Beach Amusement park
- Enchanted Forest
- Chittenango Falls State Park
- Turning Stone Resort & Casino
- Colgate University
- Utica Zoo
- Adirondack Animal Land
- The Farmers' Museum
- Verona Beach State Park
- McCauley Mountain Ski Center
- Snow Ridge Ski Resort
- First Lake
- National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum





