Vacation rentals in Fire Islands

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Fire Islands

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

An aerial view captures a beach house surrounded by other residences, with a sandy beach visible in the distance. The outdoor areas feature multiple decks and lounge spaces, complemented by greenery and beach access nearby, creating a welcoming environment for relaxation.

Home in Ocean Beach

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Beautiful beach house-OCEAN VIEW

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful, beautiful beach house! Steps from Ocean!!! Every bedroom has A/C, outdoor dining and relaxation. Oceanview from deck! Features -Upgraded WIFI -Biycles -Beach chairs/Umbrellas -Sleep 8 comfortable -Living Room, Dining Room, Outdoor deck (lighted), outdoor lounge area with umbrella, Best location!! Steps from beach and close to shopping, town, restaurants! Watch the ocean and have a cup of coffee! Have a great family vacation at our beach house!

LocationFamilyWalkability

Top guest favorite

Home in Lindenhurst

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

New Redesign Luxury Apartment

Experience a memorable retreat in Long Island at our stunning luxury apartment, just under 45 minutes drive from JFK. With 30 years of experience, we offer a perfect blend of modern elegance and comfort for families and friends. Accommodating up to four guests, our spacious apartment invites you to relax and explore nearby picturesque beaches like the famous Jones Beach. Plus, vibrant New York City is only an hour away by train, offering Broadway shows and world-class museums. Don’t miss out!

FamilyLocationSleep quality

Guest favorite

A serene waterfront view captures a calm river lined with greenery. A boat is docked at a wooden platform, with additional boats visible in the distance. Vibrant yellow flowers frame the foreground, contrasting with the rich greens of the landscape under a clear blue sky.

Home in Oakdale

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

Riverfront Retreat in Oakdale

Forget your worries at this beautiful riverfront location in historic Oakdale. Gorgeous landscaped yard, open and covered outdoor spaces, gas fire pit, fish pond, dock, outdoor shower, covered hot tub, 4 bedrooms, large L/R and kitchen, close to Connetquot Park, fishing,kayaking,Bayard Arboretum, shopping, restaurants ,bars,and Fire Island ferries. Owner has use of lower level apartment and garage, shared dock space. Just added 2026, waterfront woodburning stone firepit w/large seating area!

LocationFamilyAmenities

Top guest favorite

A wooden deck extends toward a multi-level home set amidst lush greenery. Stairs lead to the entrance, which features railings and a large window, surrounded by trees and grass, contributing to a natural setting.

Home in Fire Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Fair Harbor, Fire Island sunny 3 bedroom

Newly renovated home steps from the beach, the bay and the ferry. Extra high ceilings with sunlight streaming into every room. After a day at the beach, enjoy the large outdoor shower, grill and lounge area. Take a glass of wine and portable speakers to the clawfoot tub or indulge in the rain shower. Get some exercise with four new bikes and beach games or ping pong, foosball, air hockey and darts under the house. Two extra twin mattresses for guests with crisp white linens. Fast Wifi.

LocationFamilyOutdoor spaces

Top guest favorite

A wooden dresser with several drawers is positioned against a wall. A round tray with decorative items sits on top, complemented by a tall vase containing dried flowers. A large mirror reflects the space, and a purple curtain drapes beside the dresser.

Apartment in West Babylon

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Comfy 1st Floor Convenient Abode

Our Main Street West Babylon home, located on the 1st floor, is perfect for all guests. Perfectly situated for exploring Long Island's best attractions, minutes from Belmont Lake State Park, Babylon Village & a short drive to Jones Beach, Robert Moses State Park, and the Hamptons. 2 comfortable bedrooms with plush beds & 2 bathrooms with fresh towels & essentials. Cozy living room with smart TV & Wi-Fi. Fully equipped kitchen with appliances and cookware. Backyard with a patio and parking.

FamilyValueKitchen

Top guest favorite

An outdoor deck is seen featuring a spacious octagonal hot tub. It overlooks a calm canal bordered by green grass and trees. Nearby boats are docked, and the tranquil water reflects the clear sky, creating a peaceful atmosphere.

Home in Oakdale

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

Waterfront Round House View

A unique little beach house on the south shore of long island with the most beautiful view. The house is located on a canal. Dock is available! **We have Paddle Boards, Surf Boards and 3- 2 person Kayaks onsite for you to use during your stay. You can get to the Great South Bay by paddling to the mouth of the canal. And you can get to Fire Island by hiring a Water Taxi to pick you up! The octagon house was built in the 1970s. It's recently been refreshed with all new beds & linens.

ValueLocationCleanliness

Guest favorite

Home in Centerport

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

The Harbor House: Beachfront Home 1 hour from NYC

FEATURED #1 on Refinery29's "11 Best Beach Houses Near NYC" Welcome to Long Island’s iconic Gold Coast! Wake up to sweeping waterfront views and, if you’re lucky, catch a glimpse of our local bald eagle family soaring overhead! Explore nearby gems like the Vanderbilt Mansion & Planetarium, Caumsett State Historic Park Preserve, Del Vino Vineyards, and the lively Paramount Theatre. Stroll through Downtown Huntington or Northport Village for boutique shopping, great restaurants.

ValueLocationHeating

Top guest favorite

The exterior of a charming cottage displays a white facade with dark blue trim and a welcoming front door. A well-manicured lawn featuring stepping stones leads up to the porch, surrounded by colorful flower beds and greenery.

Home in Patchogue

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Hamptons Style Cottage close to everything!

Hamptons style cottage home is family friendly with a wonderful, fully equipped, kitchen to cook-in and spa inspired marble bathroom with huge shower and soaking tub to relax in. Rear patio with nicely landscaped yard shaded or unshaded by a large retractable awing. Located in Patchogue on a quiet block just a short walk to the fire island ocean ferries, restaurants, town's bustling main street, local bay beaches, and parks. Perfect for a weekend getaway or an extended stay!

LocationFamilyHospitality

Guest favorite

An open-roofed porch features a large table surrounded by six chairs, with a sun umbrella providing shade. An outdoor BBQ unit and a cozy seating area create an inviting space for gatherings, all complemented by bright natural light and wooden elements.

Home in Bay Shore

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Kismet Fire Island Beach House (2025 upgrades!)

60’s modern/retro, award-winning (design) house. 45 secs to beach. Spacious, clean, social- well suited for groups and families (up to 10 max please, 8 is ideal). We've been doing a lot of improvements this winter! Fabulous retro mid house, open-roofed porch. BBQ, Outdoor shower, Hardwood floors, lots of light. 3 minutes from the ferry/ restaurants, but on a quiet street. Appliances and mattresses regularly replaced. Professionally cleaned weekly

LocationValueIndoor spaces

Guest favorite

Home in Stony Brook

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Harbor House Stony Brook Village

Welcome to The Harbor House — a stunning luxury home nestled in the heart of Stony Brook Village. This beautifully custom-built retreat features a private pool, hot tub, sauna, and gym for the ultimate relaxation and comfort. Walk to the charming village center filled with shops, restaurants, and beaches, or reach Stony Brook University and Hospital in just minutes. Perfect for families or groups seeking a modern coastal escape with style and space.

FamilyValueWalkability

Guest favorite

An aerial view captures the coastal area, showcasing a sandy beach stretching along the shoreline. A cluster of homes is visible near the water, with boats scattered in the bay. The horizon features a mix of blue sky and distant landforms.

Home in Bay Shore

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 69 reviews

The Coastal Cottage-Entire Home 3 beds/1 bath

Relax with the whole family or friends at this peaceful place to stay that’s close to it all!! 4 surrounding restaurants in walking distance. ( captain bills, Nicky’s on the bay, fat fish and swept away) Down town Bay Shore with tons of shopping, restaurants and night life. Fire Island- just a 1/2 hour boat ride away with ferries in walking distance or a short Uber ride. Robert Moses State Beach- 15 minute drive.

FamilyLocationPool

Guest favorite

A cozy living area features a small dining table set for two, a comfortable cream-colored sofa adorned with decorative pillows, and a matching ottoman. A workspace with a desk and chair is positioned nearby. Light curtains frame the window, and greenery adds a refreshing touch.

Home in Bay Shore

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Sundown Escape Near SouthShore University Hospital

Cozy, modern space perfect for relaxing or working remotely. Features a comfy armchair, small workspace, dining table for two, and a coffee bar. Bedroom includes a queen bed with LED lighting, TV, mirror, bench, ALEXA, and closet with storage. Bathroom has a walk-in shower, complementary shampoo, conditioner, and body wash. Close to hospitals, colleges, shops, and main roads.

LocationFamilyNearby