Monthly Rentals in Fire Island Pines

Incredible rental on Fire Island. Great amenities and plenty of clean linens and towels. If it was almost so easy it was like my own house. Everything you would want in a modern kitchen, cozy living room and every bedroom feels private. Fantastic deck and out door spaces. Hosts were super responsive and lovely. Looking forward to coming back. I’ve rented a few others on the island and this was 10/10

Jason’s place was absolutely awesome! The location is perfect - super accessible to the beach with great dining and activities nearby. Jason was a gracious host with excellent attention to detail, including fresh linens and pool access. The space felt very cozy and welcoming. When we had some bad weather (totally out of anyone’s control), Jason was incredibly generous and gave us a free extra day to stay once the sun came out. This kind of thoughtful hospitality really made our trip special. Would definitely stay here again and highly recommend to anyone looking for a great getaway!

Great place to stay. We did get lots of ants at one point if food was left out, including dog food. The place was great overall and we’d stay again.

Absolutely would stay here again, excellent location, super responsive and easy and flexible check-in. Can’t wait to come back!