Pet-friendly vacation rentals in Eleuthera

Our stay at Island Vibe was probably the best place we have ever stayed. The view was beautiful, the home was very clean, cool and had plenty of toys and beach needs. All we had to bring was our clothing, everything else was provided. I was especially impressed with Aubry and how helpful she was from arranging our taxi from airport, water taxi to island, had a golf cart waiting for us on the dock, and arranged a car rental later in the week. Any questions or problems, we could count on her to answer or solve them. We would definitely rent this home again and again.

Jodi’s place is always five stars! This is my third time back and I will only stay here when I come to Rainbow Bay! Thank you Jodi for being such an amazing host!

We have returned to Deborah’s place three times and it is exceptional. All of our needs and expectations were met and Deborah communicated with us regularly. She was very responsive and has a local couple who are also helpful. We will return.

Three little birds is absolutely magical. The house has so much charm, is decorated with so much love and comforted all our needs. We loved waking up hearing the birds, drinking coffee in the garden and watching the sunset from the roof terrace. The location was fantastic, away from the craziness but literally 5 min walking to get somewhere. The beach access was great, the access to ramora bay beach bar and marina was beautiful and the all the helpful tips from Tim made our stay truly incredible. Ow, did i mention the comfortable beds? And perfectly silent working AC? The spacious kitchen en all the boardgames in the livingroom? 5 stars and beyond❤️

We loved our stay at the view it was a peaceful getaway and just as advertised. We would definitely stay here again.

Great location on a great beach. Fantastic beach amenities, floats chairs, etc. Super nice folks at check in. House was super clean. Location close to everything.

Loved the location and the peace and quiet. Loved the new quartz countertops. Had great stay, would stay again.

Watercolour provided a lovely way to enjoy Harbour Island! The location was right in town, near docks and groceries. The various outdoor spaces provided plenty of options! Jessica was very helpful and responsive. The home had the charm of an old home, and we didn’t come expecting pristine, but everything worked well and it was a great value. We came with teens who loved having their own space with bathrooms.

We had a wonderful time at the property – so secluded and close to the most beautiful beach – the dock was wonderful to just sit out and watch the sun set and the turtles swim by. The home was clean, and the pool was nice – this was just what the doctor ordered. Violet and Charles are very nice and always accommodating – great team.

Location, Location, Location. Unreal. The house is dated and needs work, the power goes out sometimes and you might lose hot water. If you are looking for the Ritz Carlton, this isn't it, but if you want a once-in-a-lifetime experience, highly recommend it. The access to the water, sound of the atlantic ocean crashing in the background and beautiful wildlife all around you. We will return. Brenda was a great host and made it her job to ensure we had a great time.

My family and I absolutely loved our stay at Unicorn Cay. The house is incredibly spacious and comfortable, with a lot of old world charm. The pictures don’t do it justice. We enjoyed the pool, but even more we loved driving the golf cart down the private path to the beach, which was absolutely gorgeous. The beach chairs, kayaks, paddle boards, etc. were tons of fun for us all. The bedrooms and bathrooms were very comfortable, and the kitchen was really well equipped. Would highly recommend and I hope to return!

We had a wonderful time staying at Tops House! It is bright and airy, clean, well-appointed and a great location. I don't think the pictures really show how nice the home is. It was a great choice for us. Joy and Dom were very helpful when we needed anything including recommendations for best beaches and where to get fresh fish. Highly recommend!

I used this for my make up artist and hairstylist to stay at for my wedding. The ladies got ready here. Very spacious and clean home. Ms. Candi was easy to contact.

Gorgeous - as always! Beautiful airy house with enough bedrooms (and bathrooms!!) to keep us out of each other's hair when needed. The pool! And ability to walk right out the yard and over to the beach. THE OUTDOOR bathroom and SHOWER- still my favorite thing about the house after multiple trips. It's just a PERFECT place to stay when you have 2+ people. Centrally located, private as can be while still right in the middle of it all. And Rachel is, as always, an impeccable host!

We had a wonderful time at Fond Memories. Dom met us at the house to check-in and show us around the property. He informed us about the area and suggested several nice beaches and great restaurants. The home was very relaxing and close to several restaurants and a grocery store. We will definitely be returning to this property.

Wonderful place to stay

Shawn was a great host . Very accommodating to our minor request . Great location. Will definitely book again .

We really enjoyed the house. Loved sitting on the front porch having our breakfast watching the local chickens and ducks wander thru the yard. Also the view to the ocean was great too! There was a little bit of traffic (mostly golf carts) but it gave us time to people watch along with the animals. We also liked that the house has little nooks to relax in. The beach gear was a great asset having to rent everything would add up. All in all a great trip!

Great location. Very affordable for Harbor Island. Host was very responsive. Thoroughly enjoyed our stay and hope to return soon.

Dear Alejandra, Thank you for accommodating our proposed booking dates. Self check in was a breeze. We took a leap of faith in selecting our vacation at Coco Plum Hill since you had no reviews. You explained that the renovation of the villa had just finished in April and the listing on the platform had just being uploaded. Wow…so delighted to have been your first guest. The pictures do it no justice. Both main bedrooms have a balcony with spectacular Caribbean views. The kitchen is so well equipped and the furniturings are stylish and comfortable. The outdoors felt like a boutique hotel…lounge areas galore around the house and on the beach. I especially liked rocking on the hammocks while nodding away looking at the turquoise waters. We were 3 couples and we really enjoyed using Coco Plum as a base to explore all that Eleuthera has to offer. Anyone that is considering…run to book this recently renovated property in North Eleauthera. It far exceeded our expectations.

We had an absolutely perfect stay at Gena’s beach cottage on the beach! It was ideal for our small family—cozy, well-equipped, and exactly as described and pictured. The location is unbeatable. We practically had the entire beach to ourselves, and the view was simply stunning. One of the highlights for our son was finding over 80 sand dollars right out front—pure magic. Communication with Gena was seamless from start to finish. We couldn’t have asked for a better spot. Highly recommend and would return!

Loved the house was perfect for our family - will be back 💖

This is my 2nd stay with Anna and this trip was even better than the last. The house is just as pictured. Anna is very responsive and the check in process was easy. The house has all the amenities needed for your stay. Very clean and the view is amazing. Looking forward to my next visit.

Great place right on the water!! The patio was great to sit outside and look out over the ocean. We will definitely stay here again. Wally responded quickly and was very accommodating. Thank you