Guesthouse vacation rentals in Eleuthera

Find and book unique guesthouse rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated guesthouse rentals in Eleuthera

Guests agree: these guesthouse rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Private room in Central Eleuthera

TrelaSands Beautiful Newly Renovated Ocean Front!

Trela Sands upstairs suite is a beautiful newly renovated 3 bedroom 2 bath ocean front property located in Palmetto Point South, 10 minutes from Governors Harbour. Trela Sands open floor plan includes a well stocked kitchen and bar area, large dining and living rooms were the Caribbean Ocean can be seen through out. The property sports 3 outdoor showers, grills and beautiful screened in porches that protect you from biting pests. The wifi is so good that you have service on the beach.

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Rainbow Bay

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

Li'l Mooncliffs - Your Special Caribbean Retreat

Newly renovated studio apartment conveniently located mid-island in the popular Rainbow Bay. The cottage is perched 60ft. on the cliffs overlooking the Atlantic Ocean. Less than 1/2 mile on the beautiful Caribbean side is Rainbow Bay Beach with clear, calm turquoise water suitable for swimming, snorkeling or just relaxing on the beach with a breathtaking view. Local grocery store approximately 1-1/2 mile away and plenty of local eateries further down Queens Highway in James Cistern.

Guest favorite

Guesthouse in Current

5 out of 5 average rating, 53 reviews

Slow & Easy Cottage #2

Take a break and unwind at this peaceful oasis. Slow & Easy is a multi unit, waterfront property located between Lower Bogue and Current settlements on the main island of Eleuthera. Locals refer to this area as "Current Ridge". It is situated on the south side of Current Road, right on the water. The amazing views, from the enormous dock/pavilion, are priceless. The shallow, sandy bottom water is perfect for swimming. The cottage is approximately 200 feet from the ocean.

Top guest favorite

Guesthouse in Current

5 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Slow & Easy Cottage #1

Guesthouse in North Palmetto Point

New place to stay

The Peacock Casita

This unique place has a style all its own. Set in Palmetto Point in the Eleuthera Island region, the Peacock Casita is on the Coral Sunset property. It features a patio with garden views. The cottage is a 1 bedroom, 1 bath, living room with a smart TV, and a fully equipped kitchen. The air-conditioned unit is 1.3 km from North Palmetto Point Beach, and guests benefit from complimentary WiFi and private parking on site. Separate laundry room located on the property.

Guesthouse in Tarpum Bay

4.68 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Fantastic One Bedroom Cottage with Bayfront Views

Bayfront views abound on this cute guest house. Walk out your front door to Tarpum Bay's beach and steps to restaurants, bars, and grocery stores. Enjoy miles of bayfront beach! This cute guest cottage is located in Tarpum Bay, Eleuthera. It is known as a quaint and quiet fishing village where the locals still bring in their catch of the day. Minutes away from the Atlantic with its magnificent coral reefs and miles of beach with no one else for miles.

Guesthouse in Dunmore Town

Original Tickled Pink

Tickled Pink can accommodate up to 5 individuals in two cozy and chic guest-rooms, both with ensuite washrooms. This pleasant cottage also has a large airy kitchen & living area and a charming front porch. Additional features include tv, wifi, ensuite laundry facilities and air conditioning. Tinkled Pink is the prefect island getaway for friends or family, and offers all the comforts and amenities to make you feel at home on this idyllic little island.

Superhost

Guesthouse in Dunmore Town

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Flamingo Cottage Garden Retreat

Welcome to Flamingo Cottage, a charming sanctuary on the tranquil Harbour Island. Perfect for a romantic getaway or a solo retreat, this enchanting one-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage invites you to unwind and immerse yourself in paradise. Flamingo Cottage is more than a vacation rental—it’s your personal slice of paradise. Create unforgettable memories and experience the enchanting beauty of Harbour Island at Flamingo Cottage.

Superhost

Private room in Governor's Harbour

Delightful Bahamian Room + Pool

Experience Bahamian charm in this renovated home. Your room, one of two upstairs is above a coffee and gift shop, and is centrally located in Governors Harbour. Please note the potential for morning bustle from the shop! This spacious room features an en-suite bathroom and is just a short walk from restaurants, a grocery store, and a pink sands beach (1 mile away). On warm days, enjoy the shared pool and island breeze.

Private room in Airport Beach

Outpost Eleuthera Guesthouse

Home of Inst of Ecological Field Studied, hosting US high school students for week long eco adventures. Featured on Fox News 30 min special. Featured in coastal Living Magazine Dec. 2007 Home to cast and crew in Mathew Mcconahy's Fools Gold. Location of TV comedy series This is Paradise. Host with 35 yrs experience will assist with planning your day and provide local inside tips .

Superhost

Private room in Rock Sound

5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

The Pilot House - Historic Guest House - Room #2

A quiet, centrally located retreat in the heart of Eleuthera. Set among tropical gardens, our hotel-style rooms offer a peaceful stay for business travelers, island hoppers, and anyone seeking rest and simplicity. Private, comfortable, and just minutes from nearby settlements and essentials — the perfect base to explore Eleuthera at your own pace.