Vacation rentals in Conestoga

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Conestoga

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

The two-story farmhouse features a classic red brick exterior with a covered porch. Large windows provide ample natural light. A sprawling tree is situated nearby, complemented by lush green grass that surrounds the home, adding to the serene rural ambiance.

Farm stay in Conestoga

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 174 reviews

Cozy Hilltop Farmhouse

Our cozy farmhouse is your home away from home! This Lancaster county farm is nearly 100 acres of rolling hills and will provide you with a peaceful farm atmosphere with amazing sunrises and sunsets! Perfect for a romantic getaway. There is 1 bedroom with a queen size bed, attached full bath. 1 pullout couch in living room. 1/2 bath on first floor. Come experience the rich heritage of Amish country while checking out the many nearby Lancaster attractions. Also, say hi to our 23 beautiful hens!

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area features a high, wood-paneled ceiling and a prominent stone fireplace, providing warmth and ambiance. Multiple large windows allow natural light to brighten the room, while comfortable seating arrangements encourage relaxation and conversation.

Cabin in Millersville

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 120 reviews

Waterfront Terrain- Relax, Unplug, Enjoy!

This 2,000 sq. ft. House is perfect for families looking to RELAX and UNPLUG in the countryside of Lancaster County while still being close to major attractions. This cabin is nestled between two hills, making it the most serene spot in the area. You will enjoy hearing the gentle rustles of the creek or spot a deer, or eagle! Play ping-pong in basement or lounge in open concept living room with your favorite beverage can also be experienced when you choose to stay at the Waterfront Terrain!

Guest favorite

A rustic brick cottage is surrounded by lush greenery and a well-maintained yard. A covered porch features rocking chairs, inviting relaxation. Warm sunlight filters through the trees, casting a serene atmosphere on the home, which showcases a steeply pitched roof and multiple windows.

Home in Conestoga

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

The Conestoga Cottage (hot tub; close to city)

The Conestoga Cottage is a delightfully rustic, three-bedroom retreat nestled in the peaceful village of Safe Harbor, surrounded by beautiful acres of wild countryside and only 18 minutes from downtown Lancaster! The Cottage boasts a farmhouse style kitchen, a dining room filled with natural light, a large living room with a fireplace, three beautiful bedrooms, a front porch, a rear yard for the kids to play in, hot tub and private patio, as well as access to nearby trails and the river park.

Guest favorite

An outdoor seating area is presented with two dark wooden adirondack chairs positioned around a stone fire pit. A scenic view of the Susquehanna River and hills is framed by trees, with a soft sunset glow illuminating the sky.

Cottage in Pequea

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 168 reviews

Charming River view cottage

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. River view cottage is nestled up on a hillside with beautiful views of the Susquehanna river and Pequea creek. Come relax and enjoy the beauty of the outdoors, the magical sunsets with multiple outdoor seating areas, flower gardens and an outdoor fire pit. The cottage is tucked back in on 5 acres allowing for full privacy. The cottage was built in the 1950s and has a unique, charming character for you and your family/friends to enjoy!

Guest favorite

The cabin's exterior features a rustic stone chimney and a front porch with a single black chair. Lush greenery surrounds the cabin, enhancing its natural setting. The building is designed with earthy tones, and multiple windows allow light to illuminate the inviting space within.

Cabin in Holtwood

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 240 reviews

Beautiful Creekside Cabin

The beautiful cabin is a nature lover's paradise with a babbling brook that offers solace for the body and soul. It is a retreat that will allow you to do social distancing while you feel the presence of God as you relax and take deep breaths! This home has a master bedroom with a queen bed, and a second bedroom with a single trundle bed. This renovated cozy cabin is tucked away in the heart of Lancaster County and is great for married couples, solo adventurers, or quiet retreats.

Guest favorite

An inviting interior space features a spacious bed with red bedding and a cozy gray sofa. A small dining area is arranged with a circular glass table and two chairs. Natural light enters through a window, enhancing the warm wood accents throughout the room.

Guesthouse in Lancaster

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 773 reviews

Cottage at JoValley Farm

A thoroughly modern private cottage with kitchenette alongside our 1800s stone farmhouse on 11 acres with meadow, woods, walking trail, pond, & creek along Conestoga River. 10mins to downtown, 15min to outlets and Sight Sound Theatre, EZ access to tourist centers. Less than 10 mins to Millersville Univ. Vey quiet surroundings away from traffic. Outdoor deck use. We are a vegetable and flower farm. We are following all state and AirBnB standards for cleaning and sanitizing.

Superhost

The charming entrance of the cottage features a covered porch with wooden pillars and two chairs. A welcoming door is flanked by decorative shutters and a simple wreath. Landscaping includes flower beds and a stone pathway leading up to the porch.

Cottage in Conestoga

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 375 reviews

Safe Harbor Cottage

This newly remodeled, quaint and cute cottage is sure to please! With over one acre of land to enjoy, beautiful sunrises, a deck with a grill ready to go and of course a HOT TUB to relax in! Enjoy staying among the beautiful countryside of Lancaster County, but a few miles from Lancaster City! Many area attractions listed below for all to enjoy! *Turkey Hill, Enola Low Grade and Columbia Rail Trails *Spooky Nook *Sight and Sound Theatre *Lancaster Central Market

Top guest favorite

A charming blue cottage is set against a backdrop of greenery. The entrance features a dark blue door adorned with a decorative wreath. A spacious deck is visible, framed by trees and a small landscaped area with a potted plant.

Cottage in Conestoga

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Creswell Cottage/no pets

This quaint little secluded cottage. Enjoy beautiful sunrises. Sit on the deck and watch the deer, turkey, rabbits squirrels, and plenty of birds. You can even hear bullfrogs croaking from the neighbors water garden. No pets allowed Enjoy staying among the beautiful countryside of Lancaster County Area attractions include- -turkey hill/enola low grade and Columbia northwest rail trails -site and sound theater -the Fulton theater -Lancaster Central Market

Top guest favorite

The historic farmhouse is set against a vibrant sunset, showcasing a blend of orange and purple hues in the sky. A stone pathway leads to the porch, framed by lush greenery and a tranquil yard, creating a serene ambiance.

Farm stay in Willow Street

5 out of 5 average rating, 282 reviews

Spring Haven Farm, 1800s Farmhouse On 82 Acres!

Relax and unwind during your stay in a charming 1860's historic stone farmhouse on 82 acres, with a wraparound porch for enjoying the surrounding farmland views and wildlife. This is a perfect spot for a romantic getaway, family vacation, or a "home away from home" to work remotely. Come experience the charm of the farmhouse and the peacefulness of the farm. We hope you find rest here, in the heart of Amish country. *Discounts For Longer Stays*

Top guest favorite

A warm living area features a gray sofa with decorative cushions and a wooden coffee table, surrounded by natural light. A kitchenette with white cabinetry and a dining table sits in the background, accentuated by green plant decor and inviting, neutral tones.

Home in Willow Street

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 155 reviews

Life in Lanc

Life in Lanc is located on the outskirts of downtown Lancaster City, just 15 minutes from the city square, Millersville, and from Strasburg and Amish country. This townhome was just built in 2020, and the Airbnb basement portion was finished in 2022, giving this space a new clean and fresh aesthetic. While the rest of the townhome is lived-in by us, the owners, all of the space you are booking is completely private.

Guest favorite

The exterior of the property showcases a well-maintained, single-story home surrounded by lush green grass and light landscaping. A large tree stands prominently in the front yard, with two chairs positioned on a small patio area, inviting relaxation in a peaceful setting.

Home in Conestoga

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

3-bedroom house in quiet area bordering park

This beautiful property in Conestoga, PA borders Silver Mine Park which has a creek, soccer and baseball fields, and hiking trails. Located 10-15 minutes from Lancaster City, ~20 minutes from many popular (Amish-related) tourist attractions, ~10 minutes from the Pequea boat launch, and ~18 minutes from the Pinnacle Overlook this is the perfect property either for an action-packed vacation or a peaceful, relaxing one.

Guest favorite

A modern ranch-style home features a front porch with steps leading to the entrance. The lawn is lush and green, with trees providing shade. Adjacent structures can be seen in the background, contributing to the peaceful rural setting.

Home in Conestoga

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

The Safe Harbor House/with a view

Discover serenity at our remodeled Safe Harbor ranch home, boasting the most beautiful country view. The backyard beckons with outdoor adventures—hiking and biking trails await. Inside, modern elegance harmonizes with the rustic charm of the countryside. Immerse yourself in comfort and natural beauty, where every detail of this ranch-style retreat invites you to savor the essence of southern Lancaster living.