Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Catron County

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Prod O Lodging Reserve NM Jed & Raine Paulk

JaneRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Peaceful and Beautiful Log Cabin Getaway We had a wonderful three-day stay at this charming log cabin in the countryside. The place was exactly as described—cozy, clean, and beautifully maintained. The peaceful surroundings and rustic charm made it the perfect escape from the city. We especially enjoyed the sunsets! Everything was well thought out. We’d definitely love to come back! The driveway was a little too sandy for our Harley, so Raine let us use their Jeep ,to go up and down the Driveway!perfect twist!

Guest favorite

A gentle stream meanders through the landscape, flanked by lush greenery. Soft grasses and small shrubs are visible along the bank, with a slight elevation where the water flows. The scene captures the tranquil essence of nature in this remote setting.

Home in Aragon

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Aragon Hunting Lodge

LloydRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

We had a very pleasant stay at the cabin. The home is beautiful and everything of being out doors is just amazing. It’s got such amazing views of nature and just a wonderful place to be to sit and enjoy the outdoors. Everything in the cabin was just as described we enjoyed it very much and most of all the kids loved it! We would highly recommend. Most definitely will be coming back.

The spacious living area features a stone fireplace as the focal point, flanked by large windows that offer natural light and views. A comfortable sofa and armchairs are arranged around a coffee table, with a dining area visible in the background.

Home in Pie Town

3 BR Home with deck, balconies, 20 acres

WanniRating, 5 stars2 months ago

We had a lovely weekend in this peaceful cabin. Especially because of the remote location, we very much appreciated all the amenities that were provided (bottled water, shampoo, lots of books/puzzles to choose from, and even Epsom salt for a bath)! It was just what we needed to get away from the city and recharge!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

The exterior of the yurt is shown, surrounded by a snowy landscape. A panoramic view is captured in the background, revealing a vibrant sunset sky painted with hues of orange and purple. The path leading to the yurt appears clear, inviting exploration.

Yurt in Datil

Yurt With a View

The Yurt is an extraordinary refuge from the frenzy of the city. Securely set high (7600ft) among mountains, the views stretch out in all directions backing up to the Cibola National Forest. Elk, deer, coyotes, and many birds share their land with us. The dark night sky is breathtaking. The yurt is off-the-grid lit by soft oil lamps after sunset. We also laid a seven-circuit labyrinth for meditative walking. A hot tub is available up at the house. You are welcome to this place of peace.

A child is seen sitting at a wooden table, interacting with a relaxed orange cat. The vibrant green grass provides a natural backdrop, enhancing the scene of companionship and tranquility.

Ranch in Winston

Geronimo Trail Guest Ranch

Reconnect with nature at this unforgettable off the grid escape. Disconnect and unwind from your busy life! Come by yourself or bring up to 10 people. Either way, you will enjoy our entire farm / ranch with no other guests! Cozy cabins, a rec hall, full kitchen and dining room to make your meals, and outdoor sitting and dining areas. Relax and enjoy the property or hike and enjoy amazing views of the Gila National Forest countryside during the day- 3.3 million acres to explore out our backdoor!

A scenic view of a rural landscape is showcased, featuring a herd of elk grazing within a fenced area. The backdrop includes rolling hills covered with trees and a clear sky, indicating a serene natural setting.

Private room in Reserve

New place to stay

Leggett Ranch Lodge

Enjoy this comfortable & roomy lodge just minutes away from beautiful elk country. Why sleep in a sleeping bag in tents when you can sleep in a relaxing bed just minutes away from the National Forest! We will be brining furniture up in July - opening date August 1st! Pro photos to come. This lodge is also well suited for seminars, retreats, and special family get aways. We also have a cabin with two bedrooms (the Leggett Cabin). If more space is needed to be added on, please let us know.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

An octagonal room features a stunning vaulted ceiling made of reclaimed wood. Natural light floods in through multiple windows, illuminating a spacious bed and a cozy seating area. A small kitchenette and dining space are visible, creating a warm and functional atmosphere.

Tiny home in Datil

Shekinah Hermitage: Peace at the Forest’s Edge

Shekinah Hermitage is at 8000ft. overlooking the Cibola N. F. This unique cabin looks into a canyon to the north, and eastward over the San Agustin Plains. Surrounded by juniper and pinion trees, it is very remote. Windows all around give the feel of being outdoors but the solid structure is immovable in high winds. Inside is all you need including limited solar-battery 120V electricity. There is an attached bathroom with a sawdust composting toilet. Outside a high deck offers stunning views.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

A rustic cabin entrance features large wooden doors with a unique design, framed by log walls. An inviting porch is adorned with a patterned armchair and a small table, providing a welcoming space to enjoy the surroundings. Natural wood beams support the overhanging roof.

Cabin in Luna

Jesse James hideout

Make your escape to this hideaway on the New Mexico-Arizona border – rich in Western history and surrounded by National Forest land. Whether you're seeking solitude or to explore the backcountry of the White Mountains, this is your perfect base camp. You may even find some of Jesse's loot hidden in the hills! It's perfect for hunters, star-gazers, and adventure seekers, complete with Starlink internet. Property is 150 acres of private land and butts up to Nat'l Forest. The hiking is amazing!

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

An illuminated wooden staircase is seen ascending into the cabin. Small lights line the edges of the stairs, providing subtle visibility. The surrounding area is shaded by trees, creating a serene atmosphere during dusk with soft natural light filtering through.

Cabin in Quemado

Quemado Lake, Unit 15, rural home.

800 Sq. Ft. cabin in gated National Forest community, 1 mile from Quemado Lake. A water tank behind the home attracts elk some evenings. The bedroom features a dual-adjustable King-Size mattress, fitted with Giza Dreams sheets, and a comfortable sleeper sofa in the common area. "City" water, dishwasher, washer & dryer, 700 Sq. Ft. dog run and 500 Sq. Ft. deck. Comfortably furnished, with lots of windows and a sliding door to the deck. Keyless entry. FedEx and UPS delivery.

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

A unique outdoor fixture is displayed, constructed from a wire cage filled with smooth stones. The top features a sturdy wooden cap with a handle. A small level is attached, indicating a focus on balance and functionality in the design.

Tent in Catron County

Lose Yourself!

Spring is great for fishing, and from September to mid-October, you can listen all night to the bugling of mature bull elk in this unique place. Sleep in luxury on a California King-sized bed, featuring flannel and luxurious sheets, a heavy down comforter, and pillows. Although a work in progress, it currently features a full-size fridge and a converted sauna serving as a water closet. Electricity and internet. Please ask any questions before booking.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Catron County fireplace rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

House rentals with a fireplace

A cozy living area features two dark leather sofas positioned around a decorative area rug. Natural light enters through two large windows adorned with wooden blinds. A small wooden table and decorative items add character to the space, complemented by a wall-mounted artwork.

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Henley Ranch in Reserve, N.M.

JenniferRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Lovely home in a great setting! We were just passing thru for the night but this would be an awesome place for a longer stay too. Highly recommend!

Two large trees provide shade in the foreground, framing a ranch house with a sloped roof. A picnic table is positioned nearby on a grassy patch. Open fields and distant mountains are visible in the background, highlighting the spacious rural landscape.

Home in Aragon

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Aragon Ranch in Unit 16D

LindseyRating, 5 stars5 months ago

Beautiful home! It was peaceful, quiet and comfortable! We felt right at home, and the animals were the cherry on top! The whole family fell in love with Feisty!

A rustic cabin entrance is highlighted by a wooden deck, featuring a small table with four chairs and a grill nearby. A welcoming sign stands adjacent to the door, framed by landscape views of surrounding trees and hills.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Prod O Lodging Reserve NM Jed & Raine Paulk

JaneRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Peaceful and Beautiful Log Cabin Getaway We had a wonderful three-day stay at this charming log cabin in the countryside. The place was exactly as described—cozy, clean, and beautifully maintained. The peaceful surroundings and rustic charm made it the perfect escape from the city. We especially enjoyed the sunsets! Everything was well thought out. We’d definitely love to come back! The driveway was a little too sandy for our Harley, so Raine let us use their Jeep ,to go up and down the Driveway!perfect twist!

Guest favorite

The cabin is nestled within a lush green meadow, surrounded by pine forests. Its wooden exterior features a sloped roof, and large windows reflect the natural landscape. Fenced areas and trees dot the foreground, enhancing the serene country setting.

Home in Aragon

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Aragon Hunting Lodge

LloydRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

We had a very pleasant stay at the cabin. The home is beautiful and everything of being out doors is just amazing. It’s got such amazing views of nature and just a wonderful place to be to sit and enjoy the outdoors. Everything in the cabin was just as described we enjoyed it very much and most of all the kids loved it! We would highly recommend. Most definitely will be coming back.

A modern kitchen is highlighted with wooden cabinetry and a decorative backsplash featuring colorful tiles. An island with barstool seating complements the dining area, which contains a wooden table surrounded by matching chairs. Natural light streams in through a large window.

4.64 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

3 bdrm/3 bath Beautiful Vacation Rental House

RebeccaRating, 5 stars7 months ago

this place was quite of spacious and very nice with it was more wheelchair accessible

A spacious living area features high, wooden ceilings and large windows that provide ample natural light and views of the surrounding landscape. A cozy sofa faces a wooden entertainment center, while a dining table is positioned nearby, creating a welcoming space for relaxation and gatherings.

Home in Pie Town

3 BR Home with deck, balconies, 20 acres

WanniRating, 5 stars2 months ago

We had a lovely weekend in this peaceful cabin. Especially because of the remote location, we very much appreciated all the amenities that were provided (bottled water, shampoo, lots of books/puzzles to choose from, and even Epsom salt for a bath)! It was just what we needed to get away from the city and recharge!

The kitchen features modern appliances, including a stainless steel refrigerator and a gas stove. Light wood cabinets are complemented by green fabric accents. A dining area with a dark wooden table and chairs is illuminated by pendant lighting, with large windows providing natural light.

DarrenRating, 5 stars3 months ago

Casa Rosa-a beautifully spacious home in Reserve

this house is a great place to stay not far from access to the San Francisco River, less than an hours from white water catwalk area in Glenwood. Great accommodation and spacious for a large group of people. I recommend this place to anyone looking to stay in the area.