Vacation rentals with lake access in West Tisbury

The house was as described and located in a very pretty, residential neighborhood. Comfortable for 5 adults, very clean and well equipped. A short walk took us to the pond. It was very peaceful with mallards and a couple of swans. Would rent this house again.

Absolutely amazing stay for a family trip this memorial day weekend! Such a great house, gorgeous decor, sparkling clean, serene view of the lake. The setup is perfect for multiple families- 2 bedrooms and full bath on top floor, two bedrooms and full bath on main floor and master bedroom and bath with comfy living room in basement. We used the grill and that was great too! Definitely will be returning in warmer months when we can use the outdoor space more! Thank you Dar!!

I had high expectations coming in, but this home exceeded them by far. The interior is spotless, the condition is great, you could see that the owners put a lot of effort into it with lots of nice little touches to improve utility and aesthetics. Eugeniya was super helpful the entire time, she and Rudy are awesome hosts. I want to point out that the location is also very nice. We liked the town, the restaurants, the beach (15-20 minutes drive), Mashpee Commons. Santuit pond is wonderful and provides some nice fishing spots. The big pleasant surprise was the Santuit Pond Reserve, it’s in walking distance and provides tons of great hiking opportunities. There are many other attractions nearby, I recommend visiting Heritage Museums & Gardens in Sandwich (20 minutes away). Overall we had the best time, I highly recommend this place!

Great location with east access to Madaket and an easy drive to town, or the bus route. I highly recommend taking a walk down the path to the 40th pole beach, which is a great place for kids (often no waves) and often protected from high winds. The deck off the kitchen and primary bedroom was the perfect place soak in the sun and the outdoor shower is as comforting as a spa.

This is an absolutely beautiful rental and location. Cleanest, most pristine location we have been to. Appliances and bathrooms are glimmering. Host is immediately responsive and kind. 10 out of 10 in all respects.

We stayed in your lovely cabin by the lake for three days at the end of May 2025. My family and I have been renting homes through Airbnb for the past ten years whenever we travel. Based on our previous experiences, the cabins we rented in Switzerland were, in our opinion, the best in terms of cleanliness, providing everything a family might need, and clear instructions. However, I must admit that this place surpassed all of that and deserves to be considered the best Airbnb experience we’ve ever had. Everything was available—even the smallest details—so thank you from the bottom of our hearts 🙏🏻

Susan and Gerry's place is a wonderful place to stay. It is clean, modern, well equipped and is in a beautiful setting. Their home is in a central place that allows you to access all the sites that the Cape has to offer. It is to get to the quaint town of Sandwich or access the wonderful beaches of the National Seashore. They provide a beach pass that allows free access to some of these beaches. Their home is a quiet setting with access to walking trails and a local pond with beach access. This is our second year at their home and we are looking forward to spending time next year. Quickly sign up for this place if you can!

The house lived up to our expectations from the pictures. It was quiet and peaceful with restaurants and groceries within 10-15 minutes. Everything we could have needed was provided and we had a lovely stay in this beautiful home.

probably the best airbnb experience I've ever had. Jean was a fabulous and responsive host and the airbnb was very well stocked and super comfortable. Loved the porch!! Would 100% return.

This was a perfect little spot we could escape to for the long weekend! We could have our dogs which was a huge plus for us and plenty of space to walk around for them - although it is on a small country road - it's not busy traffic wise at all which is great. It's an 8 min drive (or uber - easy to get) to downtown falmouth so you're super close despite feeling super private in nature. Would absolutely recommend.

Bill and Trish were amazing hosts, and they made sure the place was exceptionally clean. They even had fresh flowers for us when we arrived.

Kathy was a wonderful host and the place was amazing. I will simply say I did not want to leave!

Irie by the Lake was fantastic. The home is not only beautiful and perfectly designed and decorated, but it was the cleanest vacation rental I’ve ever stayed in. Carol was super responsive and helpful. We are already planning to return.

The accommodation was lovely and the location was great. Highly recommend!

Great host. Nice location. Great communication

Wow, where to start. Kristin went above and beyond to accommodate us and we ended up getting married here! A wild rainstorm/ nor'easter came in so our beach elopement wedding plans had to be changed... not being from the area we had limited back-up options. Kristin kindly allowed us to do our small ceremony on the beautiful back deck. Even if all that didn't take place, her home would have a special place in our hearts because it's so tranquil and beautifully designed. Cherry on top, the bed was super comfy and kitchen well equipped! We had everything we needed for the week. Kristin's daughter gave us great recommendations too for local spots to eat. Highly recommend a stay here!

Carol is a great host. We had a small issue with the front door screen locking up and she came over right away and let us in. She is very responsive and responsible. I forgot my medication when I left and she was kind enough to mail it back to me immediately. She has a been a great host and I hope more hosts are like Carol. It rained the whole time we were there so we did not get a chance to check out the lakes around there but I am sure they are great. There is a mall near by with bowling so we did that instead. Thank you Carol for everything. Cheers

Beautiful cottage with a cute outside area. Close to a park and a small beach. Super friendly neighborhood tucked away from the noise. Absolutely adorable homely place!

Leah responded to my booking request within minutes. This was so important because our previous reservations fell through. This was a last-minute booking and I’m so thankful that I was able to find such a wonderful location. Everything that was in the listing was accurate and we felt right at home after an easy check-in process. I cannot thank Leah and Brandon enough for their willingness to let us rent their beautiful cottage last minute. The home is fully stocked with anything that we may have needed. It was a little chilly, but the space heaters were enough to get us through the chilly nights. My kids and I were able to watch Halloween movies on the TV while gazing at the full moon from the skylight above in the living room. I’m looking forward to going back to Massachusetts in the future. There are so many different things that this town and surrounding towns offer.

Perfect layout and location for our annual visit to see my dad who lives across the pond!

Don and Jennifer were wonderful hosts! My friends and I wanted a cozy and quiet weekend at Cape Cod and their cabin was lovely and charming! Don was very responsive and was very quick to answer any questions we had, along with providing us with suggestions for activities during our trip! They made us feel very welcome and we would definitely love to come back to the cabin if my friends and I return to Cale Cod!

Cute AirBnB in a very quiet neighborhood. Highly recommended it.

We had such a peaceful and relaxing stay! The setting was incredibly serene, and we felt completely at ease the entire time. All of the amenities, especially the boats and kayaks, were very accessible, and we used them throughout our stay — it really made the experience special. We also loved spending cozy nights around the campfire, which added such a warm and memorable touch. There was so much for the kids to do, and they had a fantastic time as well! The host was so kind and welcoming, and communication was very easy from start to finish. Everything was thoughtfully prepared, and it made for a truly wonderful getaway. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a quiet, fun, and family-friendly escape!

Very cute cottage in a great location. Very peaceful !!!