Boutique hotels in Tisbury

Find and book unique boutique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated boutique hotels in Tisbury

Guests agree: these boutique hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
A historic mansion is illuminated softly at night, showcasing its grand columns and multiple large windows. The surrounding trees provide a canopy of greenery, enhancing the elegant façade. Well-kept gardens frame the entrance, created a serene atmosphere in the evening light.
Hotel room in Yarmouth Port
5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

The Boutique Stagecoach Stop #3

Enjoy bed & breakfast in understated 5 star luxury in Cape Cod's most stunning historic mansion, now a leading boutique hotel in the beautiful Bayside community of Yarmouth Port. Location is central to the main attractions; 10 minutes to Island ferries, whale-watching, the Kennedy's town of Hyannis. Relax in our 2 acres of gardens, overlooking a 100 acre nature reserve. Walk to dinner at one of 3 top restaurants. Explore on foot, Sea Captains Mile, Edward Gorey Museum, the beach, boardwalk ..

Superhost
The charming Victorian Gingerbread house features intricate architectural details, including decorative trim and a wrap-around porch adorned with flowering plants. Large windows invite natural light, and the sloping roofline adds character to the residence.
Hotel room in Oak Bluffs
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Three bedrooms for travel group/excellent location

The charming Tivoli Inn is walking distance to all downtown shops and restaurants, beach, in-season ferry terminals, and public transportation. This listing is 3 bedrooms of 6 bedrooms at the Tivoli Inn with common areas with other guests. There is one full bath. In addition there is a lovely outdoor shower and an extra sink in 1 of the 3 bedrooms. Bring your flip flops to enjoy the outdoor shower! There are 3 full size beds and one twin bed...a total of 4 beds to accommodate 3-6 guests.

The spacious suite features vaulted ceilings with original stained glass windows allowing natural light to create a warm ambiance. A plush king bed is positioned near a seating area with two chairs. A modern bathroom includes a white Jacuzzi tub adjacent to a decorative fireplace.
Hotel room in Sandwich

Inn suite in converted church! Fireplace, Jacuzzi

Stay in a converted 1901 church! The "Saturday" suite is located in such a church, which is now the award-winning Belfry Inn, located in the center of historic Sandwich Village on Cape Cod. King bed, fireplace, Jacuzzi, private deck, original church stained glass and lots of privacy, the suite is a short walk to restaurants, cafes, shops and galleries, historic sites and museums. The beach and famous Sandwich Boardwalk are within walking distance. Continental breakfast is included.

Superhost
The room features a spacious bed adorned with a decorative throw, accentuated by a vibrant yellow pillow. Two wooden chairs are positioned next to a side table, with a lamp and a small vase of flowers adding charm. Natural light filters through sheer curtains.
Hotel room in Woods Hole
4.68 out of 5 average rating, 123 reviews

Treehouse Lodge, Canopy style rooms

This beautiful modern meets classic style property is a 10-minute walk from the beach and ferry to Martha's Vineyard in Woods Hole. Free private parking and free WiFi is available on site. Quick walk to the beach, several restaurants, and most science facilities. Guests can enjoy various activities in the area, including windsurfing, fishing and traveling to Martha's Vineyard. *Note to bookers- We are located on the mainland where you get the ferry to go to Martha's Vineyard*

The small motel features a charming exterior with a welcoming entrance. Lush trees with vibrant autumn leaves surround the property, providing a serene backdrop. The asphalt drive leads to individual rooms, enhancing a private and tranquil atmosphere.
Hotel room in Sandwich
4.59 out of 5 average rating, 666 reviews

Boutique 1950s Cape Cod motel

We are a small 1950s motel in a tranquil setting. You drive up to your room. We offer breakfast, housekeeping, and have guest laundry and vending and ice. Every room has a frig, microwave, coffee and tea service, and bath amenities. We offer suites with kitchenettes but these you book directly with us. You have to be 21 to rent a room, we are no pet-friendly, and 100% non-smoking. There are places to smoke. Office is open 6am-10pm. You can check-in after, just let us know.

A bright room features two spacious beds adorned with sea-themed quilts. Natural light fills the space through large windows, illuminating a small table with two chairs against the wall. Simple artwork hangs above the beds, adding a touch of charm.
Hotel room in Sandwich

Sandy Neck 24 with 2 Queen Beds 1 mi to beach

20-minute walk from the beach. Located in Sandwich, within 6 miles of Sandwich Glass Museum and 7 miles of Heritage Museums & Gardens, Sandy Neck Motel provides accommodations with a garden and free WiFi as well as free private parking for guests. All rooms Flat-screen TV, air conditioning and includes bed linen and towels. *Tripadvisor 2022 Travelers Choice Award Recipient *THAwards 2022 Family Friendly Hotel of the Year *Bookingcom 2023 Traveler Review Award

A spacious lobby area features a cozy seating arrangement with a light-colored sofa and patterned chairs. A large coffee table is centered on a soft area rug, surrounded by warm wooden beams and greenery. Natural light floods the space through expansive glass doors.
Hotel room in Edgartown
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

THE FRANKLIN HOTEL~NEW Pet friendly Standard Queen

Located on Upper Main Street in Edgartown, the Franklin Hotel is a short stroll from the heart of the historic village and its famed island beaches. A fresh take on the nautical style with modern, luxury finishes will provide all you need for work, play and relaxation. The Franklin grounds offer distinct seating areas including the covered patio, perfect to enjoy three season island breezes. The chic design of our 18 guestrooms will delight every sense.

Guest favorite
A soft, inviting bedroom is highlighted by a spacious bed dressed in white linens. Two decorative lamps with ornate bases sit on either side of the bed, illuminating plush pink pillows against a light-hued headboard. A framed mirror above the bed reflects natural light.
Hotel room in Falmouth
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Park Side Queen Room @ Frederick William House

This beautifully appointed room with private bath & sitting area, includes bike rentals, cable, free WIFI, overlooking gardens & park. We are located on the Shining Sea Bikeway in Falmouth, across the street from Goodwill Park, a short walk to the Steamship Authority. Guest are welcome to take bikes over to Martha's Vineyard for day excursions. Beach passes are available, 139 private & public beaches to choose from.

Guest favorite
Aerial view of the Briarwood Beach Motel grounds showcases a well-maintained expanse of green lawn. A large American flag stands prominently at the forefront. Colorful lounge chairs are arranged on the lawn, while the motel building is visible in the background, surrounded by trees.
Hotel room in Wareham
4.76 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Briarwood Beach Motel

Briarwood Beach Motel Just minutes from Cape Cod, our Motel is situated right on the water with unbelievable views / sunsets. We are a short walk from great New England restaurants with fresh seafood and drinks. Local hiking trails can be found close by, as well as a water park. Fish from the shore or launch a kayak into the Weweantic River right from the property!

A view of the harbor features several yachts docked along a wooden pier. Colorful flowers in a planter are positioned in the foreground. The sky is overcast, creating a calm ambiance over the water.
Hotel room in Tisbury
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

Vineyard Harbor - Harbor View Unit 224

Vineyard Harbor Motel offers comfortable rooms, water front units, a private beach and an incredible location. We are situated on the harbor in Vineyard Haven within walking distance to the ferry, unique shops, great restaurants and perfectly placed to explore the island. Vineyard Harbor Motel is the perfect location from which to explore Martha’s Vineyard.

A charming Victorian-style guesthouse features intricate architectural details and a vibrant green roof. Spacious wrap-around porches are visible, providing places for relaxation. The exterior showcases multiple balconies and large windows, contributing to an inviting atmosphere. Lush greenery is present in the foreground.
Hotel room in Oak Bluffs
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Queen Twin Room with Private Bath. Central Air.

Everything you want to explore is right outside the door. This room is located on the first floor with views of gingerbread cottages. A full private bath, central air and work space. The room has one queen and one twin bed. Very centrally located.

Guest favorite
Hotel room in Yarmouth
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 648 reviews

Ocean Breeze Motel - Standard Double

Nestled in a quiet residential setting, just steps from the warm waters of Nantucket Sound, The Ocean Breeze Motel offers a full complement of amenities and personal service to provide lasting vacation memories.

Popular amenities for Tisbury boutique hotels

When is the best time to visit Tisbury?

MonthJanFebMarAprMayJunJulAugSepOctNovDec
Avg. priceG$37,237 GYDG$50,626 GYDG$50,626 GYDG$47,697 GYDG$63,597 GYDG$81,588 GYDG$93,094 GYDG$107,110 GYDG$70,709 GYDG$53,973 GYDG$47,070 GYDG$37,865 GYD
Avg. temp0°C0°C3°C7°C12°C17°C21°C21°C18°C13°C8°C3°C

Quick stats about boutique hotels in Tisbury

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 20 vacation rentals in Tisbury

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Tisbury vacation rentals start at G$37,656 GYD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 940 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Wi-Fi availability

    20 of Tisbury vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Tisbury rentals

  • 4.8 Average rating

    Tisbury stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.8 out of 5!

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Massachusetts
  4. Dukes County
  5. Tisbury
  6. Boutique hotels