Vacation rentals with lake access in Sullivan County

Find and book unique lake access rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated lake access rentals in Sullivan County

Guests agree: these lake access rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A charming farmhouse is showcased with a well-maintained porch and a welcoming staircase leading to the entrance. The front yard features vibrant pink flowers and lush greenery. A flag is mounted on the porch, adding a touch of character to the exterior.

Home in Muncy Valley

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

A Hiker’s paradise. Secluded Mountaintop Farmhouse

Big Horn Nature Conservancy is a nature lovers & hikers dream.This 4 bedroom farmhouse on 100 acres has beautiful trails wander on, mountain views, 1 mile from the nearest road. Big Horn is the spot to rest your soul. The lodge has a newly renovated kitchen, patio ,a beautiful porch for birdwatching and a large fire pit. This is the place for those looking to get away from it all and commune with nature. Very close to the village of Eagles Mere , Worlds End State Park, and the Loyalsock trail.

Guest favorite

A cozy living area features a soft sofa adorned with patterned pillows, accompanied by two decorative poufs. A stone fireplace is situated beside a wooden coffee table. Natural light enters through a window with sheer curtains, illuminating the rustic wooden walls and beams.

Cottage in Laporte

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Charming 3 Bedroom 2 Bath Cottage on Lake Mokoma

Lovely cottage less than 1 block walk to Lake Mokoma! Nestled within the heart of the Endless Mountains, the 3 Bears Treehouse offers access to the spring fed lake w/ private beach house, swimming, canoeing, volleyball, playground & nearby hiking. This home features 3 spacious bedrooms, 2 full bath, screened in porch with lake views, all centered around a cozy wood-burning stove living space abundant with board games & records. Come relax & unwind in this charming natural oasis set back in time.

Top guest favorite

A cozy lake house is presented with a green metal roof and white exterior. The front porch features rocking chairs and large windows. Lush greenery surrounds the home, complementing the serene landscape. A gravel pathway leads to the entrance, enhancing accessibility.

Home in Laporte

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

The Katonah House at Lake Mokoma

This cozy & updated lake property has everything you need for a comfortable stay! From cozy beds, to a bath with a large walk-in shower, laundry area, & an open kitchen w/ a breakfast bar & all the conveniences of home. The living room features a vaulted ceiling & wood fireplace. Outside on the patio there is a charcoal or gas grill, & a wood firepit for camp night! Enjoy a relaxing evening in a rocking chair on the porch, or in an oversized arm chair in the sunroom with a view of Lake Mokoma.

Guest favorite

A charming home is set amidst lush greenery, featuring a welcoming front porch surrounded by trees. Stone pathways lead to the entrance, while a sloped roof and dormer windows add character. Natural light filters through, creating a serene outdoor space.

Cottage in Eagles Mere

5 out of 5 average rating, 36 reviews

"Southlook Lodge" - The Best of All Worlds

Southlook Lodge. Take it all in. Walk/bike to the lake, town, or expansive trail system which connects to Loyalsock State Forest and Worlds End State Park. Relax on the front porch in a rocker or bed swing, or around one of two firepit settings in the private backyard and large deck surrounded by nature. Bright, charming, functional home with updated kitchen and tech amenities (WiFi, smart TV’s, Sonos). On the doorstep of Eagles Mere, the turn-of-the century Victorian “town that time forgot.”

Guest favorite

The lodge's stone chimney rises beside the grassy yard, which features two wooden chairs facing the tranquil lake. The view of the lake is framed by trees, while a cloudy sky adds a serene backdrop to this peaceful outdoor setting.

Place to stay in Forksville

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Lakefront Lodge

The “old school” lodge overlooks our humble, but beautiful lake, at Camp Maple Lake. Vacationing at Camp Maple Lake is a unique opportunity to explore the grounds of an old summer wilderness camp, without all the campers & counselors. Canoe on the lake, go fishing, or sit on the lake side deck with your cup of coffee & watch the sunrise. Sorry, the lake is not for swimming, just for snapping turtles and fish And don't forget to bring firewood and s’mores for a camp fire under the stars

A spacious deck is presented with green railings overlooking a tranquil lake. Several trees frame the view, and a round table with four chairs is positioned on the deck, offering a comfortable place to enjoy the natural surroundings.

Cabin in Dushore

4.55 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Lakefront Cabin

My place is close to 2 state parks with amazing hiking trails and waterfalls. You’ll love the home because of the coziness, light, and natural surroundings. My place is good for couples, solo adventurers, families (with kids), and furry friends (pets). Enjoy sitting on the over sized deck overlooking the lake while swinging on the porch swing. Or grill some food on the brand new propane grill while admiring the view. There is also an outdoor fire pit area available above the cabin as well.

Top guest favorite

The cabin features a red metal roof and welcoming porch, framed by lush green trees. A wooden railing surrounds the entrance, showcasing an American flag. The exterior displays a combination of light-colored siding and stone accents, creating a rustic yet charming appearance.

Cabin in Hughesville

5 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Cabin @ Glen Mawr

Situated on beautiful Muncy Creek, the cabin is the place to be. Come and either relax or experience the outdoors. Enjoy fishing right out the back door, a stocked trout stream. Hunting state game lands close by. Hiking The LoyalsockTrail is only 15 minutes. 15 minutes away from Eagles Mere and Hunters Lake. Worlds End State Park. 30 minutes to Rickets Glenn State Park and Little League World Series. Plus numerous restaurants close by, such as Kathy’s Cafe in Hughesville, grocery stores.

Chalet in Eagles Mere

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 43 reviews

Algonac - Luxury Timber Lodge in Eagles Mere PA

A modern, open timber lodge set on three private, wooded acres In historic Eagles Mere, PA with every imaginable amenity for your family reunion, retreat, or event at this four-season luxury cabin in the endless mountains with access to the private Eagles Mere lake. Comfortably sleeps 12 with plenty of social space for your group to enjoy. 3 private bedrooms (1 king, 2 queens) with en suite full baths, 2 with loft beds, and a bunkroom with 2 queen beds, 2 twin beds, day bed and 2 baths.

Guest favorite

A log cabin is situated near a serene lake, surrounded by lush green trees. The structure features a covered porch, providing a tranquil view of the water and forest. Sunlight filters gently through the foliage, reflecting off the lake's surface.

Cabin in Dushore

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

Lake Akela Lodge

Cozy 5 bedroom log cabin on a lake. Get away from it all and enjoy hiking, fishing or just reading on the front porch. We host groups with a maximum of 16 guests. This is a special shared family retreat..we only rent it out a handful of times each year to help cover the costs. Our dad left us this special place and to respect his wishes we generally only host families and multi-generational gatherings...it was our dad's dream for this place to be a place for making family memories.

Top guest favorite

The charming exterior of the cottage features a welcoming entrance with a red arbor. Symmetrical hedges frame the path leading to the front door, while a stone with the word 'Welcome' is placed at the front. Tall trees are visible in the background.

Home in Eagles Mere

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Time Forgot Cottage

Spend your time away in this 1934 cottage in beautiful Eagles Mere. The "Time Forgot" cottage has so much history and charm. This cottage features 5 spacious bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, a large and updated eat in kitchen, and 2 covered porches. The kids will LOVE the large yard and playhouse. The cottage is centrally located in town. It is about a five-minute walk to the lake, the park, the Sweet Shop, Museum, Eagles Mere Inn and Country Store. You can’t get any more convenient!

Superhost

A two-story blue house is surrounded by greenery, with a spacious wooden deck at the front. The property features a gravel driveway and well-maintained lawn, accentuated by scattered stones and trees providing shade. The inviting entrance showcases a porch with a welcoming atmosphere.

Home in Eagles Mere

New place to stay

Hook, Wine, and Sinker

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay in the quaint little town of Eagles Mere. Located in the mountains, with the woods as your backyard, you are within walking/biking distance to the beach, as well as the main part of town. When not swimming at the lake or enjoying the outdoors, the house has a foosball table and a ping pong table to keep you active. You can also relax wth a book or board game on the screened in porch.

Superhost

A secluded log cabin is nestled among lush greenery, featuring a multi-windowed facade that captures natural light. Surrounding the cabin, a variety of tall grasses and trees contribute to the serene landscape under a bright blue sky with scattered clouds.

Home in Eagles Mere

Peaceful Mountain Retreat

Escape to this secluded log home with stunning mountain and meadow vistas and its own pond. Three hours from both Philadelphia and New York, this spacious cabin has open and private spaces, a wrap-around porch, and easy access to local attractions. Find the perfect balance between savoring the peace and quiet of this getaway and visiting area restaurants, stores, museums, and state parks.