Vacation rentals in Shelley Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Shelley Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The charming cabin is nestled beside a serene pond, featuring a softly illuminated fountain. Twinkling string lights adorn the surrounding trees, casting a gentle glow on the property as evening falls. The warm lights from the cabin windows reflect beautifully on the water's surface.
Cabin in Wrightsville
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 236 reviews

The Roundtop Chalet (romantic couples retreat)

Indulge in a getaway to our charming cabin, the perfect retreat for all your special celebrations - be it anniversaries, birthdays, or simply a much-needed escape from routine. Perfectly designed for romantic getaways, this cabin seamlessly blends rustic charm with modern comforts. Savour the warmth of a cozy fireplace, unwinding in a hot tub,and indulge with unlimited lattes, crafted by our Breville Touch Espresso Machine. Embrace serenity at its finest and make memories that will last forever

Guest favorite
The cottage exterior is illuminated by soft string lights, creating a welcoming entry. A white door with an oval window leads inside, flanked by two large windows. Two adirondack chairs are positioned nearby, with potted plants adding natural touches to the entrance.
Guesthouse in Goldsboro
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews

Garden Cottage Charm for 2 - Near Hbg/York/Hershey

This beautifully styled cottage is truly a sanctuary - perfect for those who enjoy travel, personal retreat, or working remotely. Located on a pleasant 1.5 acre setting only 10 mins from Harrisburg and 20 mins to Messiah College, York, and Hersheypark. You will enjoy complete privacy with plenty of space to relax and make memories. A cozy living room, full kitchen, lovely bedroom with garden view (seasonal), and bath. Central AC, fresh linens, free WiFi, and parking provided. Pet/smoke-free.

Guest favorite
A quaint red cabin with large windows is surrounded by lush greenery. Steps lead up to a welcoming front door. The building's two-story design presents a cozy profile, set against a backdrop of trees and open lawn.
Cabin in York
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 200 reviews

Private Home on Rustic Farm

The Loomis House is a cozy loft cabin on private property. Free from the distractions of the outside world, but with all the conveniences of modern life. Deep Run Farm enjoys a quiet setting on the grounds of a colonial-era farm. Some of the original structures on the property date to the 1800s. This perfect rustic setting is conveniently close to shopping and major highways (US 30 and Interstate 83). Come to disconnect and enjoy the wildlife, or just for a quick lay-over in a quiet space.

Top guest favorite
A historic stone exterior is showcased, featuring a dark green door adorned with a circular wreath. Two rectangular windows with individual panes complement the textured stone walls. Planters with greenery are seen beneath the windows, adding a touch of nature to the entrance.
Home in Pequea
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

1700’s historic waterfront cottage

Be a part of history while staying on this waterfront property of the Ironmaster's Mansion. The two-story stone guesthouse, steps away from the mansion, was built in the year 1715. The timeless character of the home, paired with the peaceful property creates an escape that feels like you've gone back in time, all while being only 20 minutes outside of Lancaster City. The mansion was home to the first treasurer of the US, General Edward Hand’s daughter, and President Buchanan’s fiance.

Top guest favorite
Home in Elizabethtown
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Countryside Cottage

Come and enjoy this cozy home away from home! You will find this renovated home to have just what your family needs while being closely located to many popular attractions! We are located just minutes off of rt 283. Being very centrally located to the following: Hershey-10 min Harrisburg-20 min Lancaster-20 min We are very close to Hershey park, Spooky Nook sports, and many wedding venues in the area. With a cozy cottage feel you will find plenty of relaxation here in the country!

Top guest favorite
A private hot tub is shown on an outdoor deck, surrounded by lush trees and a view of the creek below. The clear water invites relaxation while offering a serene connection to nature.
Place to stay in Airville
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 266 reviews

Waterfront Log Cabin with Hot Tub

Situated on the water's edge of Muddy Creek, this newly renovated log cabin offers a unique, luxury getaway for those seeking a stay immersed in all that nature has to offer. While relaxing on the spacious outdoor deck, you will be treated with a panoramic view of Muddy Creek complete with an occasional sighting of the neighborhood eagle. Perfectly set up for a romantic getaway for two, The Log Cabin on Muddy Creek was created to provide a space for couples to rest and reconnect.

Top guest favorite
Chalet in Bethel
5 out of 5 average rating, 238 reviews

Romantic Getaway, Breathtaking View w/ Hot Tub

Blue Mountain Overlook is located on Blue Mountain/Appalachian Trail. Escape to the beautiful Blue Mountains of Central Pennsylvania and relax in this secluded and spacious home. Nestled in the serene woods of Berks County, here you will enjoy the peace and tranquility of nature. Experience romantic luxury and solitude in a lush, wooded setting that offers a breathtaking, panoramic view of both mountains and valleys. This is a perfect destination spot to enjoy year round.

Top guest favorite
A modern cottage is nestled among trees, featuring a white exterior and contrasting dark roof. An outdoor patio with string lights provides a seating area, surrounded by natural stone landscaping and large rocks. The inviting structure exudes a serene charm, perfect for relaxation.
Home in Newport
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 448 reviews

Long Acre Farm Stay! Find seclusion on the back 40

Hi! Long Acre Hideaway is a secluded cottage dedicated to providing a quiet place for couples and/or small families to spend quality time with each other and with God. Come to the “back 40” of the farm to relax and rejuvenate! Experience some of the area’s best views on the walk around the perimeter of the farm on a 1.8 mile marked trail! Rest on the deck with a cup of coffee and watch for wildlife or soak in the private hot tub at night and watch the stars!

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a transformed tobacco barn is depicted, featuring a blend of red siding and a stone foundation. Lush landscaping with greenery and decorative features can be seen in front of the structure, which is framed by a clear blue sky.
Barn in Columbia
5 out of 5 average rating, 100 reviews

The Barn at Broadleaf Bend

Nestled in Lancaster County stands a magnificent 1750's Amish tobacco barn, thoughtfully transformed into a unique Airbnb experience. This historic structure, once the largest tobacco barn in the area, maintains its authentic charm while offering modern comforts. This extraordinary accommodation offers a rare opportunity to experience Lancaster County's agricultural history while enjoying the perfect base for exploring all the region has to offer.

Top guest favorite
The charming stone house is bathed in warm light, highlighting its inviting windows. Lush landscaping features a gravel pathway and seating areas, with a fire pit surrounded by chairs. Soft lighting strung between trees creates a cozy ambiance in the outdoor space.
Cottage in Stevens
5 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Cozy Cottage •HOT TUB • FIRE PIT• Peaceful Getaway

🌾 Welcome to Your Cozy Farm Retreat A peaceful, private guest cottage located on our small, quiet farm — complete with your own private hot tub, fire pit, and beautiful views. This is the perfect escape to relax, recharge, and enjoy the countryside. Sip coffee overlooking the fields, unwind in the hot tub under the stars, or explore the local farms, breweries, and trails nearby. Perfect for couples or solo travelers seeking a quiet getaway.

Top guest favorite
Home in Harrisburg
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 666 reviews

Walk to Midtown From Contemporary Uptown Harrisburg Home

Beautifully remodeled, single family, brick rowhome in the "Olde Uptown" neighborhood of Harrisburg. Take advantage of the extra care and personal touches in this property such as complimentary beverages and snacks, continental breakfast items, professionally designed interior, and incredibly comfortable king sized bed. You can walk to the fantastic Broad Street Market, local coffee shop and cafe, and the beautiful riverfront trail.

Guest favorite
Tiny home in Wellsville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 780 reviews

Tiny Home Getaway w/kayaks next to lake

Perched on an outcrop overlooking the Conewago mountains, this sweet tiny home for 2 offers a stylish, relaxing getaway where you can slow down for a few days with your favorite human. Cozy up on the hammock with a good book, spend the day on the lake with our two complimentary kayaks, roast marshmallows over the fire, sip wine to a spectacle of fireflies, settle into rocking chairs for some stargazing, and wake up happy 😊

Popular amenities for Shelley Island vacation rentals