Vacation rentals in Sandy Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sandy Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A three-story duplex showcases a covered parking area with a gravel surface. The exterior features multiple private decks with white railings. Large windows illuminate the structure, while a bright blue sky creates a visually appealing backdrop.

Home in Surf City

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Top 5% Rated, Cover Deck, Labor Day week available

Winter weeks/weekends available. 2026 Weeks now listed! All walkable Beach House w King Size Nectar bed, Large Covered Decks, ideal Food Location. * 7th Home from Beach (2 Min Walk) * Sleep 7+ comfortably * King Mattress (Nectar) * 6 Beach Badges & 6 Beach Chairs Included * Parking Onsite 4+ Cars + Boat (No struggling for Parking) * Lectrofan EVO Sound Machine in Master & 2nd BR * Covered Deck for Dining even in Rain/Lights * Super Fast Wifi 400+ * 1 Minute walk to Everything = Park and Relax

Guest favorite

The image captures a serene sunset over the bay, with the sun descending towards the horizon. Silhouetted docks are visible along the water's edge, reflecting warm colors across the tranquil surface. The calm atmosphere highlights the natural beauty of the surrounding landscape.

Home in Barnegat Light

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

Beautiful, vintage home on Barnegat Bay, LBI

Gorgeous, cosy waterfront property with amazing views over bay. Enjoy access to bay, ocean, beautiful beaches, and Barnegat Lighthouse. Bring your own boat, kayaks and explore the waterways! Bring your own bicycles to explore the island by land. *this is our private family home, not a hotel. Please respect it and treat it as you would your own home. **guests who leave the home messy (especially the kitchen) will be charged for any extra cleaning. Only guests with positive reviews accepted.

Top guest favorite

The coastal bungalow is surrounded by a gravel parking area, with well-maintained flower beds featuring colorful blooms. The front porch is adorned with festive bunting. A shaded outdoor dining area is visible, alongside various potted plants and a partially obscured white fence.

Home in Lacey Township

5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Harbor Breeze; a coastal escape

Take it easy at this tranquil seaside serenity - "no shoes, no shirt, no problems" :) My nautical themed coastal bungalow is just steps away from the Barnegat Bay and perfectly situated right in front of a picturesque harbor with a boat launch! This cozy retreat offers waterfront views, allowing you to watch boats drift by from the comfort of your own front porch. The interior is thoughtfully decorated creating a relaxing seaside atmosphere. Beach day? LBI and Island Beach both a short trip away

Guest favorite

A two-story beach house showcases a wooden facade and multiple balconies. The driveway is lined with gravel and features a parked car in front. Garage doors are situated beneath the balconies, providing easy access to the home.

Home in Harvey Cedars

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Beautiful Harvey Cedars home

Our 4 bedroom and 3 full bath home (+ bonus loft with bunks/sofa) sleeps 12 and is 1 block to the beach with traffic light & crosswalk (important!). Enjoy bay views as well as glorious sunrises and sunsets. After a day at the beach, grill and continue your outdoor beach vacation. The house is a short walk to the beach and bay as well as Harvey Cedars Marina, Bible Conference, and Harvest Cove. It's also located within short biking/walking distance to Harvey Cedars Park, restaurants and shops.

Guest favorite

Gentle waves roll onto a sandy beach under a clear sky. A wooden fence marks the beach area, with sparse vegetation visible in the foreground. The calming colors of the ocean and soft texture of the sand create a tranquil coastal setting.

Apartment in Harvey Cedars

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews

Maiden Lane Hideaway

Spacious studio 1 block from both the beach and bay in the heart of Harvey Cedars on Long Beach Island, NJ. Walk to restaurants, markets, ice cream, bar, liquor store and firehouse which hosts fun community events. Rental includes a coffee maker, blender, microwave, basic dishes, flatware. Sunny hideaway has a private patio, grill, two private entrances, access to an outside shower. Great couples retreat. Grab your surfboard, kayak, bicycles, beach bag and relax in this inviting environment.

Top guest favorite

A two-story home is viewed from the side, featuring a mix of blue and yellow siding. Lush landscaping with colorful flowers surrounds the property, while a patio area with lounge chairs and umbrellas is visible in the background, inviting relaxation.

Home in Ship Bottom

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 160 reviews

RATED AS LBI's BEST RENTAL - NEW

LONG BEACH ISLAND - New, 1 BLOCK TO OCEAN! - 3 bedroom, 2 bath, outdoor enclosed beach shower! 2-car garage, full laundry, gas fireplace, natural gas grille on private 2nd floor deck, 2nd grille on ground level. Impeccably maintained, natural light, and spacious. Restaurants and shops 1/2 block. Bagels, coffee and ice cream same block. Keurig & Cuisinart coffee makers. Exceptionally CLEAN. AIR PURIFIERS in all 3 Bedrooms. MIN 2 NIGHTS - off summer. MIN 5 NIGHTS - some summer weeks.

Top guest favorite

A living area features a light-colored couch paired with an ottoman, both set against warm wood-paneled walls. Lush plants are placed throughout, and a fireplace adds a cozy touch. A large mirror reflects natural light, enhancing the inviting ambiance.

Home in Barnegat Light

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 308 reviews

LBI Getaway Barnegat Light 2 BR 1BTH

Welcome to our cozy 2 bedroom 1 bath rental in Barnegat Light, NJ. Walking distance to everything you need for a couple's weekend or a family vacation! The beach is only 1.5 blocks away. Also a short walk to the lighthouse, nature trails, restaurants, golf course, children’s park, skate park, boat charters, and fishing. Bring your bikes, the activities are endless! Rental comes with 4 beach badges. *Please message me with any questions! *This rental is the upstairs only

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area is highlighted by a plush navy blue couch adorned with soft pillows. A round coffee table with a modern design sits in the center, complementing the light-colored walls and bright windows that allow natural light to fill the space.

Home in Seaside Heights

5 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews

Blissful Beach Bungalow 300ft to Beach & Boardwalk

Welcome to Blissful Beach Bungalow; located in the heart of Seaside Heights! Enjoy your dream beach vacation at our completely renovated 2 bedroom, 1 bathroom bungalow! This home comfortably accommodates up to 7 guests and is only 300ft from the famous Seaside Heights beach and boardwalk, making it the perfect spot for a family getaway or a fun trip with friends. 7 seasonal beach badges and off street parking for 2 vehicles are provided. Hosted by Michael's Seaside Rentals🌊

Superhost

An outdoor seating area is presented, featuring a central fire pit surrounded by six wooden Adirondack chairs. The space is well-lit, with soft lighting in the background. Stairs lead up to the upper floor, while a decorative rug adds a cozy element to the setting.

Home in Surf City

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Walk 2 Beach! Lrg Patio | Deck + Grill | Fire Pit!

Stay in this beautiful and cozy home just a short walk to the ocean! Unwind in this eclectic 2-bedroom home in the Surf City section of LBI. ✔ 4 Min walk to Surf City Beach ✔ 5 Mins drive to ❤︎ of LBI ✔ Near TONS of great restaurants + bars ✔ Full 2B upper floor w/ FREE parking on-site ✔ Large fire pit, corn hole, Jenga, and outdoor dining area ✔ Large Deck + Grill ✔ Fully Loaded Kitchen ✔ Free Coffee ✔ Self Check-in ✔ Professionally Cleaned + Sanitized

Guest favorite

A two-story beach home features grey siding with white trim and multiple balconies. The front yard is gravel-covered, providing easy access. Two garage doors are present on the ground floor. Surrounding trees enhance the private feel of the property against a backdrop of bright blue sky.

Home in Ship Bottom

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

LBI Charming Bay-side Dutch Colonial Home

Family oriented, LBI new construction Bay-side Dutch Colonial home in the heart of Ship Bottom with easy access on and off the bridge. The Home has 3 units , this unit is tiny living and sleeps 2 adults and two children. Brand new kitchen and bath, sleeper sofa and full size bed. Walk to everything: beach, bay, great restaurants & bars, ice cream & mini golf. Beach badges are included.

Superhost

The exterior of the float home features a welcoming entrance with a palm plant beside the door. A rooftop deck is visible, offering space for relaxation. The scene is complemented by a bright blue sky and the marina environment surrounding the home.

Houseboat in Lacey Township

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 273 reviews

Float and Relax ON the Water-Float Home w Kayaks!

Completely updated 1 bedroom Float Home on the beautiful Forked River! Enjoy a glass of wine for a sunset on your rooftop deck. Play, drink, and eat on the many party spots up and down the river. Fall asleep to the calming sound of water right outside your window. Awesome Lake Beach and Wibit only a mile away! Strong and fast WiFi! Kayaks included!!!

Top guest favorite

A serene sunset over Barnegat Bay paints the sky with soft hues of orange and pink. Silhouettes of Adirondack chairs provide a cozy spot for relaxation, while calm water reflects the colorful sky. A white picket fence and weathered dock frame the peaceful scene.

Home in Ocean Township

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 97 reviews

Bayfront, Reduced Off-Season Price, Kayaking, Fish

🌅 “Bayfront Gem”: Your Water’s Edge Retreat Awaken to the sun’s tender caress, its warmth dancing on your windowsill. With panoramic views of the Barnegat Bay, this custom oasis invites you to swim, kayak, fish, clam, bird watching and create lifelong memories. Let the moonlight guide your stay—a symphony of water and sky awaits. 🏖️🌙